HomeMy WebLinkAboutCounty Board of Supervisors - Minutes - 5/28/20191
Bayfield County Clerk
Scott S. Fibert, County Clerk
Kim Mattson, Accountant Jeran Rekemeyer, Deputy Clerk
Gail M. Reha, Bookkeeper Allison Radke, Clerk III
Ph: 715.373.6100 ● Fx: 715.373.6153 ● Email: sfibert@bayfieldcounty.org ● 117 E. Fifth Street, PO Box 878, Washburn, WI 54891
Draft Minutes of the:
Bayfield County Board of Supervisors’ Meeting
May 28th, 2019 4:30 p.m.
Bayfield County Board Room, Bayfield County Courthouse, Washburn, WI
The Bayfield County Board of Supervisors was called to order at 4:33 p.m. by Bayfield County
Chairman, Dennis Pocernich. A roll call was taken by County Clerk, Scott Fibert, as follows: George
Newago- present; Thomas Gordon- absent; Larry Fickbohm- present; Harold Maki- absent; Jeremy
Oswald- present; Jeffrey Silbert- present; Dennis Pocernich- present; Fred Strand- present; Thomas
Snilsberg- absent; Marty Milanowski- present; David Zepczyk- absent; James Crandall- present; Brett
Rondeau- present. Total: 9 present, 4 absent. A quorum was present to conduct business.
The following were also present for today’s meeting: County Administrator- Mark Abeles-Allison;
County Clerk- Scott Fibert; Clerk III- Allison Radke; Director of Human Services- Elizabeth Skulan;
Human Services Financial Manager- Nikki Revak; Reporter from The Daily Press- Michelle Jensen.
BAYFIELD COUNTY BOARD BUDGET PLANNING MEETING 4:30 p.m.
3. Pledge of Allegiance; The Pledge of Allegiance was recited by all in attendance.
4. Welcome and Opening Remarks; Dennis Pocernich, County Board Chair;
County Board Chair Pocernich welcomed all in attendance. He has served as County Board
Chair for 5 years. According to Chair Pocernich, the budget is one of the most important tasks
that the County Board has. It is the responsibility of County Board Supervisors to work together
to accomplish great things for Bayfield County.
5. Budget Planning and Priority Setting Overview; Mark Abeles-Allison, Bayfield County
Administrator;
UW-Extension Area Director Mary Pardee was not present for the meeting. Bayfield County
Administrator Mark Abeles-Allison posed four budget questions/topics to consider. They
included: maximum levy, additional highway reconstruction in 2019, highway debt, major
expenditures, and other. Information will be discussed from various sources: survey information,
financial information, information from Departments Heads on major expenses, and answer
some questions. Abeles-Allison explained financial trends referring to a spreadsheet from the
years 1985-2019. Budgetary timelines were discussed, including that budgets are due to the
County Administrator’s Office on August 23rd.
2
6. Bayfield County Finance Overview; Mark Abeles-Allison;
County Administrator Abeles-Allison gave a financial overview, including topics such as the
annual levy and fund balances. Bayfield County Taxes increased about 1% per year. Bayfield
County has very little debt. The current focus is the Highway budget. This is due in part to the
severe flood damage. Additionally, wages and healthcare costs have increased. Markets are
down for timber sales which impacts revenue. County Administrator Abeles-Allison reviewed a
document entitled Draft 2018 General Fund Balance from the auditors. The document gives
information about non-spendable, committed, assigned, and un-assigned balances. Bayfield
County is currently finishing a five-year Highway road repair project, initiated by the Bayfield
County Board. There was a discussion about future Highway repairs and how that fits into the
2020 budget.
County Board Supervisor Harold Maki arrived at 4:47 p.m.
County Board Supervisor David Zepczyk arrived at 4:50 p.m.
7. County Budget Survey Results and Discussion; Mark Abeles-Allison;
County Administrator Ables-Allison gave an overview of the County Budget Survey Results.
Figures were discussed. It was the 6th year of doing a survey. Survey responses were up by
about 50%. There were articles in all local newspapers, as well as advertisements. Responses
were categorized by municipalities. The new/key question was regarding debt service for
County Highways. See the table below for response information:
Debt Service for County Highways:
64% Support 6 miles or more
I support a 6-Mile Bayfield
County Highway
reconstruction plan at a cost
of $1 million in debt service
paid through taxes in 2020.
I support an 8.6-Mile
Bayfield County Highway
reconstruction plan at a cost
of $1.65 million in debt
service paid through taxes in
2020.
I support a Bayfield
County Highway
reconstruction plan
using existing resources
and no new taxes in
2020.
Residents/
Property Owners
296 Responses
78
26.35%
111
37.5%
107
36.14%
County
Supervisors
11 Responses
4
36.6%
7
63.64%
0
0%
Suggestions and ideas were submitted from County Board Supervisors and Bayfield County
citizens. UW-Extension, especially Theresa LaChappelle, was instrumental in helping put this
survey and results together.
8. Budget 2020 Projects; Mark Abeles-Allison;
County Administrator Abeles-Allison explained numerous 2020 Budget Projects including a
preliminary summary of major expenses in the 2020 budget. The figures for some projects are
3
estimates at this point. A multiple page document was compiled with different proposed budget
projects. An additional .5 FTE employee was a trend in several Departments.
9. Setting Budget Priorities and County Comparisons; Mark Abeles-Allison;
County Administrator Abeles-Allison outlined the process of budget priorities and gave County
comparisons between Ashland, Bayfield, and Barron Counties. A representative from the
Wisconsin Counties Association aided in comparisons with l1 local counties. This model also
provided an average for the various counties. This information can help inform decisions and
help make comparisons.
10. 2020 Levy Discussion; Mark Abeles-Allison;
County Administrator Abeles-Allison led a discussion about the 2020 Levy. County Board
Supervisors agreed to levy the maximum amount allowed.
11. Budget Calendar, Wrap-Up, Discussion and Possible Action Regarding 2020 Budget;
Dennis Pocernich and Mark Abeles-Allison;
County Board Chair Pocernich and County Administrator Abeles-Allison concluded the Budget
Planning meeting with a discussion regarding the four main budget questions/topics to consider.
There was a discussion regarding short vs long-term borrowing. The preference was short-term
borrowing. The general consensus was to reconstruct 8.6 miles for County Highways, until all
roads are built to standards. Comments were received regarding short-term borrowing
including: addressing the road issues now to stay ahead of the game, rather than falling behind.
Major expenditures were discussed. The Highway Department is proposing 2 parking lots: in
Iron River and in Mason. Additional staff is being requested in multiple departments. The
County Board would like specifics on the costs of additional employees. Land Records is
proposing a $125,000 cost for orthophotography. There was discussion about the need of doing
this project in 2020. There were questions regarding the $400,000 jail cell renovation figure.
Many of the additional issues and costs at the Bayfield County Jail are related to the increasing
meth and opioid epidemics. The Ashland/Bayfield County Housing study and transportation
needs were also discussed.
12. Adjourn, approximately 5:50pm.
There being no further business to come before the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors’,
Chairman Pocernich adjourned the Budget Planning portion of the meeting at 5:55 p.m.
County Board Supervisor Rondeau departed at 5:56 p.m.
4
REGULAR MONTHLY MEETING OF THE BAYFIELD COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
BAYFIELD COUNTY BOARD MEETING: Approximately 6:00 p.m. Start
The Bayfield County Board of Supervisors was called to order at 6:04 p.m. by Bayfield County
Chairman, Dennis Pocernich. A roll call was taken by County Clerk, Scott Fibert, as follows: George
Newago- present; Thomas Gordon- absent; Larry Fickbohm- present; Harold Maki- present; Jeremy
Oswald- present; Jeffrey Silbert- present; Dennis Pocernich- present; Fred Strand- present; Thomas
Snilsberg- absent; Marty Milanowski- present; David Zepczyk- present; James Crandall- present; Brett
Rondeau- absent. Total: 10 present, 3 absent. A quorum was present to conduct business.
The following were also present for today’s meeting: County Administrator- Mark Abeles-
Allison; County Clerk- Scott Fibert; Clerk III- Allison Radke; Planning and Zoning Director- Rob
Schierman; Northern Lights Director- Pauline Darling; National Park Service Apostle Islands
Superintendent- Lynne Dominy; Director of Tourism and Fair- Mary Motiff.
1. Public Comment; None received.
2. Motion Regarding the Minutes of the April 23rd, 2019 Bayfield County Board of
Supervisors’ Meeting;
Motion by Newago, Milanowski to approve the minutes of the April 23rd, 2019 Bayfield County
Board of Supervisors’ meeting. No additions or corrections. Motion carried.
3. Introduction of New National Park Service Apostle Islands Superintendent, Lynne Dominy;
County Administrator Abeles-Allison introduced the new National Park Service Apostle Islands
Superintendent, Lynne Dominy. Dominy also gave a brief self-introduction. She has worked
with the National Parks Service for 33 years. Dominy looks forward to working with local
communities and the two tribal nations. 2020 will be the 50th Anniversary of the Apostle Islands.
Her last position was at Acadia National Park in Maine. She has been working in the Apostle
Islands for about a month and has visited nearly every island. There were questions about the
current conditions of the Apostle Islands National Park. Dominy reported that there has been
significant damage from winter and erosion damage from high water. Little Sand Bay is under
construction. Multiple County Board Supervisors thanked Dominy for her presence and her
work.
4. Economic Impact of Tourism; Mary Motiff, Director of Tourism and Fair;
Director of Tourism and Fair Mary Motiff explained some of the benefits of tourism, including
the economic benefit. Leisure & Hospitality account for 27% of jobs in Bayfield County. Visitor
spending has been up 11.58% this year. Bayfield County had the 5th highest percentage increase
in Wisconsin. Motiff also highlighted Tourism’s Facebook page and the monthly Bayfield
County Wild podcast.
5. Discussion and Possible Action regarding Northern Lights Line of Credit increase
by $50,000;
5
This agenda item was moved up due to a visit from Northern Lights’ Director, Pauline
Darling. She introduced herself explaining some of her background. She is working to right-
size the organization. Darling thanked Bayfield County for all they have done for Northern
Lights. She hopes for Northern Lights-Bayfield County relationship to be a supportive
partnership. She has worked with USDA funding in Waupaca. She is currently working to
get the books straight and for Northern Lights’ to become self-sufficient. Since Darling
started on March 16th, there have been many changes. The Northern Lights Board authorized
a market study. They are working to clean up contracts and looking for bids at market pricing
to result in savings. Director Darling concluded that quality care is the most important
concern.
There was a discussion regarding the possible increase for emergency purposes in the
Northern Lights Line of Credit. The increase will be from $200,000 to $250,000.
Motion by Silbert, Maki to increase Northern Lights Line of Credit by $50,000. A roll call
was taken as follows: Newago-yes, Gordon-absent, Fickbohm- yes, Oswald-yes, Silbert-yes,
Pocernich-yes, Strand-yes, Snilsberg-absent, Milanowski-yes, Zepczyk-yes, Crandall-yes,
Rondeau-absent, Maki-yes. (10-yes, 0-no, 3 absent) Motion carried.
6. Criminal Justice Annual Report; Barb Flynn, Criminal Justice Coordinator;
This agenda item will be forwarded to June.
7. Bayfield County Resolution No. 2019-26; Grant in the Jail setting for a Non-Narcotic, Non-
Addictive, Injectable Medication; Medication-Assisted Treatment Service; Barb Flynn,
Criminal Justice Coordinator;
County Administrator Abeles-Allison gave an overview of this grant that would impact the jail
setting with funding for this medication. It is a voluntary shot that helps with drug and alcohol
addictions. These shots have been given with positive results. The medication is given monthly
and helps decrease relapse.
WHEREAS, the Bayfield County Criminal Justice Department has received grant funding in
the amount of $17,400.00 from Wisconsin Department of Health Services, Division of Care
and Treatment Services to assist in addressing the ongoing opioid and alcohol addictions in
northern Wisconsin. Total award to be expended by June 30, 2019, and
WHEREAS, the 2019 Budget does not contain any projections to account for any revenue or
expenditures for said grant, and
WHEREAS, it is the desire of the Bayfield County Criminal Justice Council to accept and
expend said grant,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors
assembled this the 28th day of May 2019 hereby approve the following budget amendment
for the Nonnarcotic, Non-addictive Injectable Medication Medication-Assisted Treatment
Service within the Jail Setting Grant:
6
Increase Revenue:
100-04-43553 Nonnarcotic, Non-Addictive Injectable Medication;
Medication-Assisted Treatment Service within the Jail Setting $17,400.00
Increase Expenses:
100-04-54509-50290 Contractual $2,400.00
100-04-54509-50391 Medical Supplies $15,000.00
IT IS FURTHER RESOLVED that the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors hereby amends
the 2019 budget by $17,400.00 for grant revenue/expenses.
Motion by Crandall, Fickbohm to approve Resolution No. 2019-26, grant in the jail setting for
a non-narcotic, non-addictive, injectable medication; Medication-Assisted Treatment Service,
with 1 change to an account number. A roll call was taken as follows: Newago-yes, Gordon-
absent, Fickbohm- yes, Oswald-yes, Silbert-yes, Pocernich-yes, Strand-yes, Snilsberg-absent,
Milanowski-yes, Zepczyk-yes, Crandall-yes, Rondeau-absent, Maki-yes. (10-yes, 0-no, 3 absent)
Motion carried.
8. Reports of the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee No. 2019-07 and No. 2019-
08; Petitions to amend the Bayfield County Zoning Ordinance regarding the Zoning of:
(Please receive and place on file as one item.); Rob Schierman, Planning and Zoning Director;
Rob Schierman, Planning and Zoning Director, summarized the two reports from the Planning and
Zoning Committee.
Full copies of resolutions, ordinances, and reports can be found at: www.bayfieldcounty.org
or the Bayfield County Clerk’s Office: 715-373-6100, 117 East 5th Street Washburn, WI
54891.
a) Creating MM Zoning District and Eliminating Special Exceptions;
Planning and Zoning Director Schierman gave information about the Amendment Creating
Metallic Mining Zoning District and Eliminating Special Exception. He explained that this
Amendment will give more control to the municipalities that have a large part in the re-zoning
process. The Board of Adjustment and Corporation Counsel asked that this Amendment be
included in the Ordinance.
b) Creating Section 13-1-25A Metallic Mineral Exploration, Prospecting, Bulk Sampling,
Mining and Reclamation;
This is a new Ordinance for Metallic Mineral Exploration, Prospecting, Bulk Sampling, Mining
and Reclamation. This Ordinance was recommended by Bayfield County Corporation Counsel
to clarify the language. Schierman reported that the new language would prepare Bayfield
County in addressing any applications should they be received.
Motion by Silbert, Milanowski to receive and place on file Reports No. 2019-07 and No. 2019-
08. Motion carried.
9. Bayfield County Ordinance No. 2019-07; Amendment Creating MM Zoning District and
Eliminating Special Exceptions; Bayfield County Code of Ordinances, Wisconsin;
7
Planning and Zoning Director Schierman gave more information regarding Ordinance No. 2019-
07. It has been a long process for Zoning Director, Corporation Counsel, and County Board
Supervisors to work on this Ordinance.
The Bayfield County Board of Supervisors ordains as follows:
That the Bayfield County Zoning Ordinance, adopted June 1, 1976, be and the same, is
hereby amended as follows:
WHEREAS, Wisconsin Statutes §59.69 (5) authorizes the County Board to adopt a zoning
ordinance; and
WHEREAS, Wisconsin Statutes §59.69(5)(e) authorizes the County Board to amend an
ordinance; and
WHEREAS, Section 13-1-104 Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin authorizes
the County Board to make amendments to Title 13, Chapter 1 of the Code of Ordinances,
Bayfield County, Wisconsin pursuant to Wisconsin Statutes §59.69; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to amend language in
Section 13-1-21(e) Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by deleting reference to
a special exception fee; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to amend language in
Section 13-1-22(j) Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by deleting language
allowing minimum side and rear yard setbacks and road setbacks to be reduced or eliminated
by obtaining a special exception; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to amend language in
Section 13-1-25 Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by deleting the word
“metallic”; and make a correction of typo; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to amend language in
Section 13-1-41(b)(1a) Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by deleting all
references to special exceptions; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to amend language in
Section 13-1-60(a) Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by adding the “M-M”
to Zoning District Dimensional Requirements; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to create language in
Section 13-1-61(o) Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by adding “M-M
Metallic Mining” to Zoning District; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to amend language in
Section 13-1-62 Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by adding Non-ferrous
metallic mining as a conditional use in the I, A-1, F-1, F-2 and M-M zoning districts and by
deleting conditional uses Bulk Sampling, Equipment, Storage, Prospecting and similar
activities in non-ferrous metallic mining or quarrying in the I, A-1, F-1 and F-2 zoning
districts; and
8
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to amend language in
Section 13-1-63(g)(5) Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by deleting All
references to special exceptions; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to amend language in
Section 13-1-102(e)(2)e.; (3) & (4) Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin by
deleting all references to special exceptions; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed in the best interest of the County of Bayfield that the Code of
Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin be further modified and amended in the manner
hereinafter set forth;
NOW, THEREFORE, the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors does hereby ordain as
follows:
SECTION 1. Subsection (e) [Fees] of Section (13-1-21); [General Land Use
Requirements] of Article B [General Provisions] of Chapter 1 [Zoning] of Title 13 [Zoning
Code] of the Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby amended to read as
follows, with deletions highlighted by the double strike out feature (deletions):
13-1-21(e) Fees
aa. Board of Adjustment Hearing ...........................................................
Special Exception ................................................ $ 550.00
Variance or Appeal .............................................. $ 800.00
Refiling & Reopening* ....................................... $ 800.00
Reopening & Reconsideration ............................. $ 250.00
SECTION 2. Subsection (j) [Special Exceptions] of Section (13-1-22), [Setbacks and
Height Restrictions] of Article B [General Provisions] of Chapter 1 [Zoning] of Title 13
[Zoning Code] of the Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby amended to
read as follows, with deletions highlighted by the double strike out feature (deletions):
13-1-22(j) Special Exceptions
(j) Special Exceptions. Minimum side and rear yard setbacks (other than shoreline and
public road setbacks) and minimum private road setbacks may be reduced, and side and rear
yard setbacks (other than shoreline and public road setbacks) in commercial districts may be
eliminated, by special exception granted by the Board of Adjustment pursuant to Section 13-
1-102-(e)(4).
SECTION 3. Section (13-1-25) [Metallic and Nonmetallic Mines] of Article B [General
Provisions] of Chapter 1 [Zoning] of Title 13 [Zoning Code] of the Code of Ordinances,
Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby amended to read as follows, with correction
highlighted by the double underline feature (additions) and deletions highlighted by the
strike out feature (deletions):
Sec. 13-1-25 Metallic and Nonmetallic Mines.
9
(a) General Requirements. The purpose of this Section is to insure ensure that all
metallic and nonmetallic mining operations, including the removal of sand and gravel, are
conducted at locations and in such a manner so as to be compatible with the uses of
neighboring lands and to minimize environmental degradation.
(b) Permit. A conditional use permit shall be required before the commencement of any
excavation or exploratory drilling, and an additional conditional use permit shall be required
prior to any active mining or drilling operation in Bayfield County. Expressly allowed
without a conditional use permit shall be nonmetallic mining sites that affect less than one (1)
acre of total area over the life of the mine and preliminary exploration of potential sand and
gravel sites when exploratory excavation is minimal, provided that there shall be immediate
site restoration following such exploration. Applications for the post-exploration phase of
mining of mineral deposits other than aggregates such as stone, sand and gravel, shall be
accompanied with an Environmental Impact Analysis in accordance with Section 13-1-42.
(c) Basis of Approval. In passing upon a conditional use permit, the Planning and
Zoning Committee shall consider the four (4) stages of a mining operation: exploration,
prospecting, ongoing commercial operation (extraction and processing), and reclamation,
their effects upon the factors listed under Section 13-1-41, and whether or not they are
consistent with the purpose of this Section, In order to facilitate such considerations, the
following information shall be required by the Planning and Zoning Committee:
(1) A legal description of the proposed site.
(2) A detailed description of the topography and vegetative cover of the area to be
mined.
(3) The proposed setbacks that are to be observed and a description of the access to the
area.
(4) A description of all phases of the contemplated operation, including types of
equipment that may be used, the extent of vegetation removal, proposed dispositions of
spoils, planned precautions against various types of pollution and plans for ongoing
reclamation and erosion prevention where the operation is to include sand and gravel
washing, the estimated daily quantity of water to be used, its source, and its disposition.
(5) A site restoration plan, which shall include detailed grading and re-vegetation plans,
and a written statement indicating the timetable for such restoration; in accordance with
ABDI Land Conservation Department recommended approval and Title 16 Bayfield County
Nonmetallic Mining Reclamation Ordinance.
(d) Conditions of Approval.
(1) The Planning and Zoning Committee shall require as conditions of the permit.
(a) A boundary survey or accurate identification of exterior boundaries.
(b) That appropriate setbacks and other dimensional requirements as set forth by the
Planning and Zoning Committee be met.
10
(c) That appropriate measures be taken to avoid nuisance affecting surrounding uses,
pollution of any sort, and erosion.
(d) That no more than a forty (40) acre parcel shall be permitted at any one time.
(2) The Planning and Zoning Committee may require as conditions of the permit, as
well as other conditions it determines to be necessary and appropriate pursuant to Section 13-
1-41:
(a) That suitable landscaping, screening, and fencing be required.
(b) That a surety bond be posted to assure compliance with the provisions of the
conditional use permit and to assure proper restoration or cleanup.
(c) That the applicant provide the Planning and Zoning Committee with all test methods
and results as well as company interpretations of the test data including that obtained by
drilling, coring and excavating.
(d) Designated hours and days of operation.
(e) An expiration date.
(e) Duration of Conditional Grant. The initial grant to carry on a mining operation
shall be effective for a period of time to be specified by the Planning and Zoning Committee.
To extend the operation beyond the initial time period, a new conditional grant must be
applied for and all new conditions must be met.
(f) Existing Quarry Operations. The owners of quarry, mining, and/or drilling sites
shall submit to the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee the names of the
quarry, mining, and/or drilling owners and operators, including all parties to farm out
contracts.
(g) Prohibited Areas. Nonmetallic mining, and/or drilling for oil or gas shall not be
allowed in the following areas:
(1) Under lakes, rivers, creeks, or streams.
(2) Within one (1) mile of Lake Superior or connected wetlands.
(3) Within one (1) mile of any lake, river, creek, or stream.
NOTE: Nonmetallic mine sites may be permitted within one (1) mile of Lake Superior and
connected wetlands and within one (1) mile of any lake, river, creek or stream, but shall be
excluded from under lakes, rivers, creeks, or streams.
SECTION 4. Subsection (b)(1a) of Section (13-1-41); [Conditional Uses] of Article B
[General Provisions] of Chapter 1 [Zoning] of Title 13 [Zoning Code] of the Code of
Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby amended to read as follows, with deletions
highlighted by the double strike out feature (deletions):
11
13-1-41(b)(1a) Conditional Uses.
(1a) In the Shoreland. The Planning and Zoning Agency shall send written notice to the
appropriate office of the Department of Natural Resources at least 10 days prior to any
hearing on a proposed variance, special exception or conditional use permit, appeal for a map
or text interpretation, map or text amendment, and copies of all proposed land divisions
submitted to the county for review and shall also send the same office copies of any decision
on a variance, special exception or conditional use permit, or appeal for a map or text
interpretation, and any decision to amend a map or text of an ordinance.
SECTION 5. Subsection (a) of Section 13-1-60 [Zoning District Dimensional
Requirements] of Article D [Zoning District] of Chapter 1 [Zoning Code] of Title 13 [Zoning
Code of Ordinances], Bayfield County Wisconsin is hereby amended to read, in part, as
follows with additions highlighted by the double underline feature (additions):
Zoning
District
Minimum
Area
Minimum
Average
Width
Principal
Building
Accessory
Building
F-2, A-2, M-M 35 acres 1,200' 75' 30'
SECTION 6. Section 13-1-61 [Zoning Districts] of Article D of Chapter 1 [Zoning Code]
of Title 13 [Zoning Code or Ordinances], Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby created to
read, in part, as follows with additions highlighted by the double underline feature
(additions):
(o) M-M Metallic Mining. This district is to provide for large contiguous tracts that
may be used for metallic mining operations; no residential structures allowed.
SECTION 7. Subsection (a) of Section 13-1-62 [Classification of Uses] of Article D
[Zoning District] of Chapter 1 [Zoning Code] of Title 13 [Zoning Code of Ordinances],
Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby amended to read, in part, as follows with deletions
highlighted by the double strike out feature (deletions) and additions highlighted by the
double underlined feature (additions):
PERMISSIBLE USES R-4
R-3
R-1
R-2 R-RB C I M A-1 A-2 F-1 F-2 W M-M
Non-Ferrous Metallic Mining, Quarry,
(*EIA required)
(Bulk Sampling, Equipment, Storage,
Prospecting, etc.)
C C C C C
Non-Ferrous Metallic Mining Exploration C C C C C
12
SECTION 8. Subsection (g)(5) of Section (13-1-63); [Town of Russell Overlay] of Article
B [General Provisions] of Chapter 1 [Zoning] of Title 13 [Zoning Code] of the Code of
Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby amended to read as follows, with deletions
highlighted by the double strike out feature (deletions):
13-1-63(g)(5) Town of Russell Overlay District
(5) Permitted Uses – All uses permitted within the underlying zoning district, by right
or by special exception, shall be permitted unless specifically prohibited below. In all cases,
the more restrictive requirement(s) shall apply.
SECTION 9. Subsections (e)(2)e; (3) & (4) [Board Powers] of Section (13-1-102); [Board
of Adjustment] of Article B [General Provisions] of Chapter 1 [Zoning] of Title 13 [Zoning
Code] of the Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby amended to read as
follows, with deletions highlighted by the double strike out feature (deletions):
13-1-102(e)(2)e; (3) & (4) Board Powers
e. The basis of review in granting a variance or special exception shall include those
items listed in Section 13-1-41(b)(4)a and, in granting a variance, the Board may attach
conditions listed in Section 13-1-41(b)(4)b and/or other conditions, if such conditions as are
reasonably related to the purpose of the zoning restriction in question or to environmental
problems that may be caused or aggravated by the variance or special exception if the
condition were not imposed.
(3) Whenever a variance or special exception is granted, the Bayfield County Planning
and Zoning Agency, shall record the decision granting it, setting forth the terms and
conditions of the variance or special exception and a legal description of the property to
which it pertains, with the Bayfield County Register of Deeds. The terms and conditions of
the variance or special exception shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of all current
and future owners of such property. The recording fee shall be paid by the applicant to the
Department within ninety (90) days after notice thereof has been sent to the applicant by the
Department. If the applicant fails to do so, the variance or special exception shall be null and
void, and no permit shall be issued pursuant thereto.
(4) The Board may grant special exemptions for the reduction of minimum side and rear
yard setbacks (other than shoreline and public road setbacks) and minimum private road
setbacks as provided in Section 13-1-22(j). The provisions of Section 13-1-41 shall govern
such special exceptions in the same manner as they govern conditional uses, except that the
granting authority shall be the Board of Adjustment rather than the Planning and Zoning
Committee.
SECTION 10. Except as specifically modified and amended by this ordinance, the Bayfield
County Code of Ordinance shall remain in force and effect exactly as originally adopted and
previously amended. All ordinances or parts of ordinances inconsistent with or in
contravention of the provisions of this ordinance are hereby repealed.
SECTION 11. SEVERABILITY. If a court of competent jurisdiction adjudges any section,
clause, provision, or portion of this ordinance unconstitutional or invalid, the remainder of
this ordinance shall not be affected thereby.
13
SECTION 12. EFFECTIVE DATE. This ordinance shall take effect and be in full force
from and after its passage.
Motion by Silbert, Fickbohm to adopt Amendatory Ordinance No. 2019-07. Motion carried.
10. Bayfield County Ordinance No. 2019-08; Zoning Ordinance Creating Section 13-1-25A
Metallic Mineral Exploration, Prospecting, Bulk Sampling, Mining and Reclamation;
Planning and Zoning Director Schierman gave further information about Ordinance No.
2019-08 to the County Board.
The Bayfield County Board of Supervisors ordains as follows:
That the Bayfield County Zoning Ordinance, adopted June 1, 1976, be and the same, is
hereby amended as follows:
BAYFIELD COUNTY ZONING ORDINANCE CREATING SECTION 13-1-25A
METALLIC MINERAL EXPLORATION, PROSPECTING, BULK
SAMPLING, MINING AND RECLAMATION
WHEREAS, zoning is an essential function performed by local government since it
allows a municipality to protect its citizens’ quality of life, welfare and safety; and
WHEREAS, metallic mineral mining is a permitted activity under State law and may
provide beneficial impacts for County residents, including employment opportunities and
improvement of local economies; and
WHEREAS, metallic mineral mines and metallic mineral mining operations pose special
challenges since:
• Metallic mineral mining, unlike many other activities, may only be developed at
a specific location at which a mineral deposit exists; and
• Metallic mineral mining may create substantial impacts which adversely affect
public health, safety, convenience and welfare; and
• Metallic mineral mining may harm and cause serious damage to not only the
immediate surrounding areas of the mining operation, but also to areas and
resources beyond the immediate surroundings such as waterways, wells and
other water supplies, air, and other environmental resources; and
• The adverse effects of metallic mineral mining may not be limited to the years a
mine is in operation but may substantially impact future generations; and
WHEREAS, Chapter 293 of the Wisconsin Statutes recognizes the County’s authority to
participate in the local regulation of metallic mineral mining and grants an express
authority for the County to negotiate and enter into a local agreement and require an
operator to obtain an approval or permit under a zoning or land use ordinance; and
WHEREAS, conditional uses enjoy acceptance as valid and successful tools of
municipal planning to cope with situations where a use may create unique problems or
14
hazards if allowed to develop as a matter of right; and
WHEREAS, the purpose of this Ordinance is to provide alternate methods by which an
operator may obtain a mining permit, both of which recognize the need for reasonable
regulation of mining.
NOW, THEREFORE, the County Board of Supervisors for Bayfield County does ordain
as follows:
Section 1. Section 13-1-25A [Metallic Mineral Mining.] of Article B [General
Provisions] of Chapter 1 [Zoning Code] of Title 13 [Zoning of the Code of Ordinances],
Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby created to read as follows, with the creations
highlighted by the double underline feature (additions).
Sec. 13-1-25A. Metallic Mineral Mining.
(a) Definitions.
Capitalized terms used in this Ordinance, unless otherwise specifically defined, are defined
as follows:
(1) Any term not expressly defined in this Ordinance. Shall have the meaning set
forth in Wis. Stat. Chapter 293, and if not defined therein then as defined in Wis.
Admin, Code Ch. NR 132, and if not defined therein then as defined in Wis. Admin.
Code Ch. NR 182.
(2) Affiliate. Means any Person that, directly or indirectly, controls, or is controlled by,
or is under common control with a Person. “Control” (and the correlative meanings
of the terms “controlled by” and “under common control with”) means the
possession, directly or indirectly, of the power to direct or cause the direction of the
management and policies of such Person.
(3) Applicable Laws and Regulations. Means any federal, State, municipal, regulatory
or other governmental entity law, regulation, requirement, condition, restriction, or
binding agreement applicable to Exploration, an Exploration Site, Prospecting, a
Prospecting Site, Bulk Sampling, a Bulk Sampling Site, a Mining Site, Mining, a
Mining Operation, or other provision contained within an Exploration Permit,
Prospecting Permit, Bulk Sampling Permit or Mining Permit issued pursuant to this
Ordinance.
(4) Applicant. Means any Person that has or intends to submit an Application for a
Mining Permit to Bayfield County pursuant to this Ordinance.
(5) Application. Means an application filed or to be filed with Bayfield County by
which the Applicant applies for a Mining Permit pursuant to this Ordinance and shall
contain all the information required by the Ordinance, including, but not limited to,
the information required pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(l) of this Ordinance or as
may otherwise be reasonably required by the County.
15
(6) Buffer Area. Means an undisturbed vegetated area measured from the property line
of the Mining Site into the Mining Site, in which no Mining Operations, structures or
roads can occur or be constructed except for the construction and maintenance of a
vegetated berm or a berm constructed of materials acceptable to the County.
(7) Bulk Sampling. Means the same definition as set forth in Wis. Stat. § 293.01(2m),
as may be amended.
(8) Bulk Sampling Permit. Means a permit issued pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(f) of
this Ordinance.
(9) Bulk Sampling Site. Means the entire area of land upon which Bulk Sampling will
occur.
(10) Conditional Use Permit. Means a permit issued pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(n) of
this Ordinance.
(11) Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit. Means a Mining Permit issued by virtue
of an approved and issued Conditional Use Permit.
(12) County. Means the County of Bayfield.
(13) County Board. Means the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors.
(14) County Board of Adjustments. Means the Board of Adjustment of Bayfield
County pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 59.694.
(15) County Zoning Ordinance. Means the zoning and land use ordinance adopted by
Bayfield County pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 59.69.
(16) County Planning and Zoning Committee. Means the Bayfield County Planning
and Zoning Committee of the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors, and the
designated county zoning agency of Bayfield County pursuant to Wis. Stat. §
59.69(2).
(17) Exploration. Means exploration as defined in Wis. Admin. Code Ch. NR 130, as
may be amended.
(18) Exploration Permit. Means the permit required pursuant to Section as a condition
of engaging in Exploration.
(19) Exploration Site. Means the entire area of land upon which Exploration will occur.
(20) Government Body or Agency. Means any State, federal, municipal entity,
department, agency, regulatory authority, or other government unit having
jurisdiction or maintaining any other authority to regulate Exploration, an
Exploration Site, Prospecting, a Prospecting Site, Bulk Sampling, a Bulk Sampling
Site, Mining, a Mining Site, or Mining Operations.
16
(21) Local Agreement. Means an agreement entered into pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.41.
and approved pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(o) of this Ordinance.
(22) Local Agreement/Mining Permit. Means a Mining Permit issued by virtue of an
approved Local Agreement.
(23) Local Committee. Is a committee created pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.33 and
Section 13-1-25A(h) of this Ordinance.
(24) Mining or Mining Operation. Means all or part of the process involved in the
mining of nonferrous metallic minerals, on or as part of the Mining Site, other than
for Exploration, Bulk Sampling, or Prospecting, including, but not limited to:
a. Extraction from the earth of mineral aggregates or minerals for off-site use or
sale, including drilling and blasting, as well as associated activities such as
excavation, grading and dredging of such materials.
b. Manufacturing or processing operations that may involve the use of
equipment for the crushing, screening, separation or blending of the mineral
aggregates or metallic minerals obtained by extraction from the mining site
or with materials transferred from off-site.
c. Manufacturing processes aimed at producing metallic or nonmetallic
products for sale or use by the operator.
d. Stockpiling or storage of metallic or nonmetallic products for sale or use off-
site and stockpiling of waste materials.
e. Transport of the extracted metallic or nonmetallic materials, finished
products or waste materials to or from the extraction site.
f. Disposal of waste materials.
g. Reclamation of extraction site.
h. Prospecting or Exploration for metallic minerals is not mining under the
terms of this Ordinance.
i. Commercial extraction, agglomeration, beneficiation, construction of roads,
removal of overburden and the production of refuse.
(25) Mining Permit. Means either a Conditional Use Permit issued pursuant to Section
of this Ordinance, or a Local Agreement negotiated, approved and issued pursuant to
Wis. Stat. § 293.41 and Section 13-1-25A(o) of this Ordinance.
(26) Mining Site. Means the entire area of land upon which Mining Operations will
occur, and shall include, but not be limited to, the surface area disturbed by a
Mining Operation, the surface area from which the nonferrous metallic minerals or
refuse or both have been removed, the surface area covered by the refuse, all lands
disturbed by the Mining Operation or associated activities, the surface area covered
17
by construction or improvement of haulage ways, and any surface areas in which
processing facilities, structures, equipment, materials and any other activities
associated with the Mining Operation are situated, operated, conducted or
otherwise utilized.
(27) Operator. Means any Person who is engaged in, or who has applied for and been
granted a Mining Permit to conduct Mining, Mining Operations, or other activities
associated with Mining on a Mining Site or as part of a Mining Operation, whether
individually, jointly or through subsidiaries, agents, employees or contractors.
(28) Ordinance. Means this metallic mining ordinance adopted by Bayfield County and
included in the County Zoning Ordinances as a use in the M-M District.
(29) Permittee. Means any Person granted a Mining Permit pursuant to this Ordinance.
(30) Person. Means any person, individual, owner, operator, corporation, limited liability
company, partnership, association, municipality, interstate agency, State agency or
federal agency.
(31) Prospecting. Means the same definition as set forth in Wis. Stat. § 293.01(18) and
Wis. Admin. Code Ch. NR 131, as each may be amended.
(32) Prospecting Permit. Means a permit issued pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(e) of this
Ordinance.
(33) Prospecting Site. Means the entire area of land upon which Prospecting will occur.
(34) Retained Expert. Means professional consultants, including, but not limited to,
engineers, attorneys, planners, environmental specialists, and other consultants with
skills relevant to reviewing, processing and acting upon applications for a Mining
Permit or to issues associated with the inspection, monitoring and enforcing of
approvals and requirements of a Mining Permit.
(35) Section. Means a specific section of this Ordinance.
(36) State. Means the State of Wisconsin.
(37) WI DNR. Means the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources.
(38) WI DNR Exploration License. Means an exploration license issued by WI DNR
pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.21(2).
(39) Zoning Administrator. Means the administrator of the Bayfield County Zoning and
Conservation Department.
(b) Findings, Purpose and Authority.
(1) Findings.
18
a. Metallic mining is a permitted activity under State law and has the potential
to both beneficially and adversely impact County residents, environments
and economies. Metallic mining may provide employment opportunities,
needed industrial materials and significant economic benefits to local
communities. Metallic mining operations, however, have the potential to
create nuisance conditions, negatively impact property values and present
health and safety impacts to County residents if not properly designed and
operated.
b. Exploration, Prospecting and Bulk Sampling are regulated by the State, yet it
is appropriate for the County to reasonably regulate these uses and operations
to the extent that such regulation generally falls within the County’s
jurisdiction, such as regulation of hours of operation, traffic and noise levels.
c. Many aspects of Mining Operations are subject to State and/or federal
regulation. WI DNR is the unit of State government responsible for
regulating any adverse impact of metallic mining and reclamation on the air,
lands, water, plants, fish and wildlife in the State. The County is also
authorized to regulate metallic mining so long as its regulation is not
preempted by other Applicable Laws and Regulations. Accordingly, the
County enacts this Ordinance to further the purposes stated above, which
include, but are not limited to, the protection of people on neighboring
properties to a Mining Site in the County, their domestic animals, structures,
businesses and human endeavors and activities situated thereon, as well as the
protection of County resident health, safety, convenience and general welfare
from the potential adverse effects from metallic mineral mining, including,
but not limited to:
1. Sounds, noise, earth movement, shock, vibrations, cracks in structures
and interference with the peace, quiet and enjoyment of life on
neighboring properties resulting from mining activities.
2. Smells, odors, dust and particulates entering upon neighboring
properties and impacting County residents. The County is not, by this
Ordinance, regulating air or air quality, but seeks to protect
neighboring properties, people and the County and activities therein
from the adverse effects of smells, odors, dust and particles due to
Mining Operations, whether transported or moved by gravity,
vehicles, people, wind, weather, climatic condition or other forces.
3. Light and light pollution entering upon neighboring properties from a
Mining Site or as a result of Mining Operations.
4. Damage to the County’s property tax base.
5. Damage to or destruction of public roads, public highways and
bridges from vehicles and equipment used in or at the Mining Site or
as part of Mining Operations.
19
6. Adverse effects on educational, recreational and business facilities in
the County.
7. Adverse effects on agricultural, forestry, industry and business future
growth in the County.
8. Adverse effects on uses of land in the County in accordance with their
character and adaptability.
9. Adverse effects on the beauty and amenities of the neighboring
landscape and the County’s physical features.
10. Adverse effects on healthy surroundings for citizens’, residents’ and
visitors’ quality of life.
d. Given the potential effects of Mining Operations noted above and given the
complexity and uniqueness of each proposed Mining Operation, the County
requires a mechanism by which to control the local impacts of Mining
Operations, without duplicating or conflicting with Applicable Laws and
Regulations.
e. A Conditional Use Permit is a flexible planning and land use regulatory
device designed to cope with situations, problems and hazards which may
result from the specific metallic mineral mining project under consideration.
f. A Local Committee, created pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.33, presents an
opportunity for the County, the Applicant, other units of government and
other stakeholders to discuss and plan for the County’s concerns associated
with a proposed Mining Operation, and to develop solutions to address those
concerns. The findings of a Local Committee may be a useful tool in
negotiating a Local Agreement.
g. A Local Agreement, as statutorily permitted pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.41,
provides the County flexibility in the approval process by allowing an
Applicant and the County to negotiate terms prior to commencement of the
actual approval process. Also, a Local Agreement acts as a specific exception
to general zoning requirements, and therefore allows the County to set forth
its approvals in one binding agreement with an Applicant.
h. There exist two separate and independent procedures by which an Applicant
may obtain a Mining Permit under this Ordinance: (1) the Applicant may
apply for and the County may approve the issuance of a Conditional Use
Permit pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(n) or (2) the Applicant and the County
may enter into a Local Agreement pursuant to the terms of Wis. Stat. §
293.41 and Section 13-1-25A(o). A Local Agreement may include terms,
conditions and provisions that the County may deem necessary to protect the
health, welfare, safety and convenience of the County and its residents. The
benefits of a Local Agreement include, but are not limited to, addressing the
County’s, Applicant’s and Operator’s concerns regarding the Mining
Operation, the ability to modify or waive certain provisions of this Ordinance
20
and any other County regulation, the inclusion of other parties or units of
government in the Local Agreement, memorialize the findings of a Local
Committee created pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.33, and memorialize the
overall understanding of the parties in a binding agreement. A Conditional
Use Permit shall be approved pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(n) and
suspended, modified, amended or revoked pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(s)
of this Ordinance. A Local Agreement shall be entered into and approved
pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.41 and Section 13-1-25A(o), and may be
suspended, modified, amended or revoked pursuant to its terms and Section
13-1-25A(s).
i. This Ordinance is not intended to conflict with, defeat the purpose of, or
violate the spirit of State or federal law. This Ordinance shall be interpreted
and applied in a manner that complements, and does not conflict with, State
law as set forth in Wis. Stat. § 293.41 or other Applicable Laws or
Regulations.
(2) Purpose. The purpose of this Ordinance is to accomplish the following:
a. To complement State law regulating Exploration, Prospecting and Bulk
Sampling.
b. To establish local minimum standards for Mining Operations conducted
within the County, and a process by which to systematically consider Mining
Permit Applications and Mining Operations in a manner that promotes the
health, safety, welfare and convenience of the County and its residents.
c. To minimize or prevent any adverse on- or off-site impacts resulting from
Mining Operations, including, but not limited to, the potential impacts set
forth in Section 13-1-25A(b)(1)(c).
d. To set forth rules and procedures to govern Mining and Mining Operations
within the County, establish procedures for the administration and
enforcement of this Ordinance, and provide penalties for its violation.
e. To specifically set forth the requirements for any Person desiring to engage
in Mining or any Mining Operation in the County to first obtain a Mining
Permit from the County and subsequently act and operate in accordance with
the conditions on such Mining Permit so the County can, to the extent of the
County’s authority, promote the public health, safety, convenience and
general welfare.
f. To encourage and ensure, to the greatest extent possible:
1. Planned and orderly land use development;
2. The protection of property values and the property tax base;
3. Careful planning and efficient maintenance of highway systems and
other transportation infrastructure;
21
4. Adequate highway, utility, health, educational and recreational
facilities;
5. The needs of agriculture, forestry, industry and business in future
growth;
6. The use of land and other natural resources which are in accordance
with their character and adaptability;
7. The protection of surface and groundwater resources;
8. The conservation of soil, water and forest resources;
9. The protection of the beauty and amenities of the landscape and
physical features within the County;
10. Healthy surroundings for citizens’ and visitors’ enjoyment and
lifestyles; and
11. The efficient and economical use of public funds.
g. To ensure that Mining Operations are permitted in Bayfield County only
pursuant to a Mining Permit, issued by virtue of a Conditional Use Permit
or a Local Agreement, and only after a Mining Permit is issued by the
County in accordance with this Ordinance.
h. To ensure that the County may utilize a Local Agreement, as permitted in
Wis. Stat. § 293.41, as a Mining Permit separate and apart from any
procedure set forth for a conditional use.
i. To ensure that conditions placed on a Mining Permit granted as a
Conditional Use Permit are crafted and tailored to address existing and
anticipated conditions and circumstances pertinent to the Mining Operation
and impacts on the Mining Site and other areas that may be impacted by the
Mining Operations throughout the County.
j. To ensure that all conditions placed on a Mining Permit that is issued as a
Conditional Use Permit are:
1. Consistent with the purposes of this Ordinance;
2. Within the jurisdiction of the County;
3. Not arbitrary or unreasonable;
4. Have a substantial relation to public health, safety, convenience
and/or general welfare;
5. Supported by substantial evidence; and
22
6. To the extent practicable, measurable.
k. To ensure coordination with WI DNR and all other State and federal
regulatory bodies of a Mining Operation in the County.
l. To ensure consistency with Bayfield County Comprehensive Plan and/or
Town Comprehensive Plans, as may be amended.
(3) Authority. This Ordinance is adopted under the authority of the powers set forth in
Wis. Stat. Chapter 59, Wis. Stat. Chapter 66, Wis. Stat. Chapter 293, and any other
authority granted to the County under State or federal law.
(c) Applicability, Exemptions, Interpretation, and Effective Date
(1) Applicability. This Ordinance shall apply to the use and proposed use of land within
the unincorporated areas of the County that are subject to the County Zoning
Ordinance, for the purpose of any proposed Mining Operation regardless of when
such use is commenced and regardless of where such use is proposed within the
County.
(2) Exemptions. This Ordinance does not apply to:
a. Except as set forth in Sections 13-1-25A(i)(2) and 13-1-25A(o)(5) below,
any Mining Operations made specifically exempt from any requirement in
this Ordinance pursuant to a Local Agreement with the Operator under Wis.
Stat. § 293.41.
b. Except as set forth in Sections 13-1-25A(i)(2) and 13-1-25A(o)(5) below,
any other requirements of the County Zoning Ordinance that may be
modified or waived in a Local Agreement.
(3) Interpretation. Except as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(t) of this Ordinance, this
Ordinance is not intended to repeal, abrogate, annul, impair or interfere with any
existing laws, regulations, ordinances, rules, standards or permits that are not
specific to metallic mining previously adopted pursuant to other Wisconsin law.
(4) Severability. Should any section, clause, provision or portion of this Ordinance be
adjudged unconstitutional, invalid, unlawful or unenforceable by a final order of a
court of competent jurisdiction, including, but not limited to, all applicable appeals,
the remainder of this Ordinance shall remain in full force and effect.
(5) Effective Date of Ordinance. Subject to Section 13-1-25A(t), this Ordinance shall
take effect the day after the date of publication or posting as provided by Wis. Stat. §
59.14.
(6) Modification, Amendment, Suspension or Elimination of this Ordinance. Any
modification, amendment, suspension or elimination of this Ordinance, whether in
part or in full, shall require a majority affirmative vote by the County Board.
23
(7) Impact on Existing County Zoning Ordinances. This Ordinance shall amend the
existing County Zoning Ordinances as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(t). In the event
of any conflict between this Ordinance and any other County Zoning Ordinances or
any other general County codes, regulations or ordinances, this Ordinance shall
control.
(d) Exploration Permit.
(1) Permit Required. No person may commence any Exploration except in
conformance with a valid Exploration Permit issued by the County pursuant to this
Section 13-1-25A(d). Exploration may only be conducted as a permitted use within
the M-M zoned district as set forth in the County Zoning Ordinance. The
Exploration Permit issued by the County is a separate permit from the WI DNR
Exploration License.
(2) Conditions on Exploration Permit. The County shall grant an Exploration Permit
if the applicant for the Exploration Permit can demonstrate satisfaction of the
following conditions:
a. Compliance with all terms and conditions of the WI DNR Exploration
License for the duration of the WI DNR Exploration License.
b. Compliance with all applicable County ordinances.
c. Demonstrate to the satisfaction of the County that all other applicable and
required federal, State and local permits and approvals required for the
Exploration have been or will be obtained prior to commencement of any
Exploration.
d. Submit a copy of all permits, approvals or waivers of permits to the County,
both at the time of application for the Exploration Permit and during the term
of the Exploration Permit.
e. Comply with all Applicable Laws and Regulations and any other
Government Body or Agency permits, approvals, conditions or restrictions
for the Exploration.
f. Provide proof that any financial assurances required by a Government Body
or Agency, if any, have been obtained as required by any Applicable Laws
and Regulations.
(3) The County shall impose conditions on the Exploration Permit related to the
following:
a. Provide a Buffer Area or screening from the Exploration sites if the
Exploration activities would cause undue noise, dust, lighting, odors or other
adverse impacts on neighboring properties.
b. Establish a setback of at least 1,200 feet between any Exploration Site and
any existing occupied structure.
24
c. Conduct Exploration only on Monday through Friday, not earlier than
6:00 a.m. and not later than 9:00 p.m., and on Saturday not earlier than 6:00
a.m. and not later than noon, to avoid substantial or undue impacts on
neighboring properties and County residents.
d. Limit night lighting if Exploration occurs during hours of darkness to that
which is minimally necessary for security and worker safety.
e. Control off-site noise levels to the maximum extent practicable to avoid
adverse impacts to neighboring landowners.
f. All hazardous chemicals or substances kept on the Exploration Site or related
to the Exploration shall be stored in State-approved storage containers and
storage areas.
g. Take necessary measures to control fugitive dust.
h. Maintain compliance with all State and federal permits related to the
Exploration, the suspension or revocation of which shall cause the automatic
termination of the County Exploration Permit.
i. Any other conditions that the County deems reasonable and necessary and
that are:
1. Within the jurisdiction of the County;
2. Not arbitrary or unreasonable;
3. Have a substantial relation to public health, safety, convenience
and/or general welfare;
4. Supported by substantial evidence; and
5. To the extent practicable, are measurable.
(4) Compliance. Must be met at all times or the Exploration Permit may be revoked or
subject to enforcement, fines and penalties as provided in Section 13-1-25A(s).
(5) Duration of Exploration Permit. The Exploration Permit shall be of the same
duration as the WI DNR Exploration License, so long as the Exploration Permit
holder complies with all required applicable laws and regulations, all permits, orders,
conditions or other requirements set forth by any government body or agency, and
suspension or revocation of the Exploration Permit does not occur pursuant to this
Ordinance.
(e) Prospecting Permit.
(1) Permit Required. No person may commence any Prospecting except in
conformance with a valid Prospecting Permit issued by the County pursuant to this
25
Ordinance. Prospecting may only be conducted as a conditional use within the M-M
zoned district as set forth in the County Zoning Ordinance.
(2) Conditions on Prospecting. The County shall grant a Prospecting Permit if the
Applicant can demonstrate satisfaction of the following conditions:
a. Compliance with all applicable County Ordinances.
b. Demonstrate, to the sole satisfaction of the County, that all Applicable Laws
and Regulations promulgated by any Government Body or Agency,
including, but not limited to, a WI DNR permit for the same Prospecting
activity, have been or will be obtained prior to commencement of any
Prospecting.
c. Submit a copy of all permits, approvals or waivers of permits to the County,
both at the time of application for the Prospecting Permit and during the term
of the Prospecting Permit.
d. Compliance with all Applicable Laws and Regulations and any other
Government Body or Agency permits, approvals, conditions or restrictions for
the Prospecting.
e. Provide proof that any financial assurances required by a Government Body
or Agency, if any, have been obtained as required by any Applicable Laws
and Regulations.
(3) The County shall impose conditions on the Prospecting Permit related to the
following:
a. Provide a Buffer Area or screening from the Prospecting sites if the
Prospecting activities would cause undue noise, dust, lighting, odors or other
adverse impacts on neighboring properties.
b. Establish a setback of at least 1,250 feet between any Prospecting Site and
any existing occupied structure.
c. All hazardous chemicals or substances kept on the Prospecting Site or related
to the Prospecting shall be stored in State-approved storage containers and
storage areas.
d. Conduct Prospecting only on Monday through Friday, not earlier than
6:00 a.m. and not later than 9:00 p.m., and on Saturday not earlier than 6:00
a.m. and not later than noon, to avoid substantial or undue impacts on
neighboring properties and County residents.
e. Limit night lighting if Prospecting occurs during hours of darkness to that
which is minimally necessary for security and worker safety.
f. Control off-site noise levels to the maximum extent practicable to avoid
adverse impacts to neighboring landowners.
26
g. Take necessary measures to control fugitive dust.
h. Maintain compliance with all State and federal permits related to the
Prospecting, the suspension or revocation of which shall cause the automatic
termination of the Prospecting Permit.
i. Any other conditions, including but not limited to additional buffers and
screening, that the County deems reasonable and necessary and that are:
1. Within the jurisdiction of the County;
2. Not arbitrary or unreasonable;
3. Have a substantial relation to public health, safety, convenience
and/or general welfare;
4. Supported by substantial evidence; and
5. To the extent practicable, are measurable.
(4) Compliance. Conditions established pursuant to the Prospecting Permit must be met
at all times or the Prospecting Permit may be revoked or subject to enforcement,
fines or penalties as provided in Section 13-1-25A(s).
(5) Duration of Prospecting Permit. The Prospecting Permit shall be of the same
duration as the Prospecting Permit issued by WI DNR for the same Prospecting
activities, so long as all the Prospecting Permit holder complies with all required
Applicable Laws and Regulations, all permits, orders, conditions or other
requirements set forth by any Government Body or Agency, and suspension or
revocation of the Prospecting Permit does not occur pursuant to this Ordinance.
(f) Bulk Sampling Permit.
(1) Permit Required. No person may commence any Bulk Sampling except in
conformance with a valid Bulk Sampling Permit issued by the County pursuant to
this Ordinance. Bulk Sampling may only be conducted as a conditional use within
the M-M zoned district as set forth in the County Zoning Ordinance.
(2) Conditions on Bulk Sampling. The County may set the following conditions on a
Bulk Sampling Permit to ensure that any party engaging in Bulk Sampling shall:
a. Comply with all applicable County Ordinances.
b. Demonstrate, to the sole satisfaction of the County, that all Applicable Laws
and Regulations promulgated by any Government Body or Agency,
including, but not limited to, a WI DNR permit for the same Bulk Sampling
activity, have been or will be obtained prior to commencement of any Bulk
Sampling.
27
c. Submit a copy of all permits, approvals or waivers of permits to the County,
both at the time of application for the Bulk Sampling Permit and during the
term of the Bulk Sampling Permit.
d. Comply with all Applicable Laws and Regulations and any other
Government Body or Agency permits, approvals, conditions or restrictions
for the Bulk Sampling.
e. Provide proof that any financial assurances required by a Government Body
or Agency, if any, have been obtained as required by any Applicable Laws
and Regulations.
(3) The County shall impose conditions on the Bulk Sampling Permit related to the
following:
a. Provide a Buffer Area or screening from the Bulk Sampling sites if the Bulk
Sampling Permit activities would cause undue noise, dust, lighting, odors or
other adverse impacts on neighboring properties.
b. Establish a setback of at least 1,250 feet between any Bulk Sampling Site and
any existing occupied structure.
c. All hazardous chemicals or substances kept on the Bulk Sampling Site or
related to the Bulk Sampling shall be stored in State-approved storage
containers and storage areas.
d. Conduct Bulk Sampling only on Monday through Friday, not earlier than
6:00 a.m. and not later than 9:00 p.m., and on Saturday not earlier than 6:00
a.m. and not later than noon, to avoid substantial or undue impacts on
neighboring properties and County residents.
e. Limit night lighting if Bulk Sampling occurs during hours of darkness to that
which is minimally necessary for security and worker safety.
f. Control off-site noise levels to the maximum extent practicable to avoid
adverse impacts to neighboring landowners.
g. Take necessary measures to control fugitive dust.
h. Maintain compliance with all State and federal permits related to the Bulk
Sampling, the suspension or revocation of which shall cause the automatic
termination of the Bulk Sampling Permit.
i. Any other conditions, including but not limited to additional buffers and
screening, that the County deems reasonable and necessary and that are:
1. Within the jurisdiction of the County;
2. Not arbitrary or unreasonable;
28
3. Have a substantial relation to public health, safety, convenience
and/or general welfare;
4. Supported by substantial evidence; and
5. To the extent practicable, are measurable.
(4) Compliance. Conditions established pursuant to the Bulk Sampling Permit must be
met at all times or the Bulk Sampling Permit may be revoked or subject to
enforcement, fines and penalties as provided in Section 13-1-25A(s).
(5) Duration of Bulk Sampling Permit. The Bulk Sampling Permit shall be of the
same duration as the Bulk Sampling permit issued by WI DNR so long as all the
Bulk Sampling Permit holder complies with all required Applicable Laws and
Regulations, all permits, orders, conditions or other requirements set forth by any
Government Body or Agency, and suspension or revocation of the Bulk Sampling
Permit does not occur pursuant to this Ordinance.
(g) Mining Permit Required.
(1) Zoning Designation. Mining Operations may only be conducted within the M-M
zoned district and only after issuance of a Mining Permit, as required in this
Ordinance.
(2) Mining Permit Requirement. No person may commence construction of a Mining
Site or engage in any Mining Operations in the County except in conformance with a
valid Mining Permit issued by the County pursuant to this Ordinance and within an
M-M zoned district. A Mining Permit shall be issued as a result of a Conditional Use
Permit approved pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(n) or as a result of the approval and
adoption of a Local Agreement pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(o).
(3) Duration of Mining Permit. The Mining Permit shall last through all Mining
Operations and reclamation of the Mining Site so long as the Operator complies with
all provisions of this Ordinance, any condition imposed by a Conditional Use
Permit/Mining Permit, the terms of a Local Agreement in a Local Agreement/Mining
Permit, all required Applicable Laws and Regulations, all permits, orders, conditions
or other requirements set forth by any Government Body or Agency, and suspension
or revocation of the Mining Permit does not occur pursuant to this Ordinance.
(h) Local Committee.
(1) Formation. A Local Committee may be formed or convened pursuant to Wis. Stat. §
293.33.
(2) Powers of a Local Committee. A Local Committee may:
a. Facilitate communications between an Applicant, Operators and the County.
b. Analyze implications of the Mining Operations.
29
c. Review and comment on reclamation plans.
d. Develop solutions to growth-induced issues caused by Mining Operations.
e. Take other steps permitted by the County Planning and Zoning Committee.
f. Take any other steps permitted to Wis. Stat. § 293.33.
(3) Parties Included in a Local Committee. The County Planning and Zoning
Committee shall determine the size of the Local Committee and the parties that
make up the Local Committee, in the County Planning and Zoning Committee’s sole
discretion, which may include:
a. Representatives of any town, village, city or tribal government representative
that may be affected by the Mining Operations.
b. Representatives of other industries or affected units of government that may
be affected by Mining Operations, such as school districts, police/fire
emergency responders, business and industry, economic development, and
environmental and other interest groups or other interested parties.
c. Other interested persons, including, without limitation, a representative of the
Applicant and the Operator, which may be the same person if the Applicant
shall be the Operator pursuant to the Mining Permit.
(4) Parties Required in a Local Committee. The following parties shall be included
in a Local Committee:
a. At least one representative of the County Planning and Zoning Committee.
b. At least one member of the County Board.
c. The County Planning and Zoning Administrator or his or her designee.
(5) Local Committee Findings and Recommendations. A Local Committee’s
findings, recommendations or reports shall not be binding upon the County Planning
and Zoning Committee in negotiating a Local Agreement, nor upon the County
Board when reviewing and deciding upon an Application for Local
Agreement/Mining Permit.
(i) Local Agreement
(1) Local Agreement as Mining Permit. A Local Agreement may be used as the basis
to obtain a Mining Permit and shall be approved pursuant the terms of Wis. Stat. §
293.41 and as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(o).
(2) Required Information. A Local Agreement shall include the following information
pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.41(2):
30
a. A legal description of the land subject to the Local Agreement and the names
of its legal and equitable owners.
b. The duration of the Local Agreement.
c. The uses permitted on the Mining Site.
d. A description of any conditions, terms, restrictions or other requirements
determined to be necessary by the County or by any town, village, city or
tribal government for the public health, safety and welfare of its residents.
e. town, village, city or tribal government to enable the development to proceed.
f. The applicability or nonapplicability of any County, town, village, city or
tribal government ordinances, approvals or resolutions.
g. A provision for the amendment of the Local Agreement.
h. Other provisions deemed reasonable and necessary by the parties to the Local
Agreement.
i. Any other terms set forth in this Ordinance that require inclusion in the Local
Agreement, including the terms set forth in Section 13-1-25A(o)(5).
(3) Modification of Zoning Requirements. Except for the requirements set forth in
Sections 13-1-25A(i)(2), 13-1-25A(o)(5) and 13-1-25A(s)(6)(b), and except for a
requirement that mining activity may take place only within the M-M zoned district,
a Local Agreement may modify, waive or alter the provisions of this Ordinance, the
County Zoning Ordinance, and any other County regulations. Any Local
Agreement/Mining Permit shall address the subjects of Sections 13-1-25A(p), 13-1-
25A(q) and 13-1-25A(s); provided, however, the terms set forth in these Sections
may be amended in a Local Agreement/Mining Permit if agreed to by the parties to
the Local Agreement. In the event the terms of this Ordinance require specific votes
or actions for such waiver, or amendment, waiver or amendment cannot occur absent
such votes or specific action.
(4) Application. An Applicant desiring to obtain a Local Agreement/Mining Permit
shall follow the application requirements in Section 13-1-25A(k) and Section 13-1-
25A(l).
(5) Negotiation. The County Planning and Zoning Committee shall be the designated
body to negotiate a Local Agreement on behalf of the County. The County Planning
and Zoning Committee may consider input from any Local Committee convened
pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.33 and Section 13-1-25A(h); however, the County
Planning and Zoning Committee shall not be bound by any recommendations of the
Local Committee or other local units of government when negotiating a Local
Agreement. but should take local governments comments into consideration.
31
(6) Effective Date. A Local Agreement/Mining Permit may not take effect until
approved by the County Board as required in Wis. Stat. § 293.41(4) and Section 13-
1-25A(o).
(7) Review and Decision Process. An Application for a Local Agreement/Mining
Permit shall follow the process set forth in Section 13-1-25A(o).
(8) Suspension or Revocation. A Local Agreement/Mining Permit may be suspended
or revoked as provided in the Local Agreement/Mining Permit.
(j) Conditional Use Permit.
(1) Conditional Use Permit as Mining Permit. A Conditional Use Permit may be used
as the basis to obtain a Mining Permit and shall be approved pursuant the terms set
forth in Section 13-1-25A(n).
(2) Application. An Applicant desiring to obtain a Conditional Use Permit/Mining
Permit shall follow the Application requirements in Section 13-1-25A(k) and Section
13-1-25A(l).
(3) Review and Decision Process. A Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit
Application shall follow the review and decision process set forth in Section 13-1-
25A(n).
(4) Suspension or Revocation. A Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit may be
suspended or revoked as provided in the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit and
pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(s).
(5) Requirements in a Conditional Use Permit. A Conditional Use Permit/Mining
Permit shall include the information required in Section 13-1-25A(n) and any other
conditions warranted within the County Planning and Zoning Committee’s
discretion, subject only to Section 13-1-25A(j)(6).
(6) Conditions. A Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit may contain any terms and
conditions that the County Planning and Zoning Committee deems necessary, and as
described in Section 13-1-25A(n)(5), in light of the Mining Operations and in
response to the specific issues presented by the proposed Mining Operations, and
that are:
a. Within the jurisdiction of the County;
b. Not arbitrary or unreasonable;
c. Have a substantial relation to public health, safety, convenience and/or
general welfare;
d. Supported by substantial evidence; and
e. To the extent practicable, are measurable.
32
(k) Procedures For Applying For a Mining Permit.
(1) Application. An Application for a Mining Permit shall be filed with the County
Planning and Zoning Administrator and shall include an electronic copy and 20
paper copies of the Application, including the required components set forth in this
Section 13-1-25A(k) and Section 13-1-25A(l). The Application shall not be deemed
complete until the Applicant has submitted, and the Zoning Administrator has
accepted, all required portions of the Application as set forth in this Section 13-1-
25A(k) and Section 13-1-25A(l), and as otherwise required by the County.
(2) Statement of Application for Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit or Local
Agreement/Mining Permit. The Application shall specifically state whether the
Applicant seeks a Mining Permit by virtue of approval as a Conditional Use Permit
pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(n) of this Ordinance, or by virtue of approval of a
Local Agreement pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(o).
(3) Review and Determination. If the Applicant seeks a Conditional Use
Permit/Mining Permit, review and decision on the Application shall occur pursuant
to Section 13-1-25A(n). If the Applicant seeks a Local Agreement/Mining Permit,
review and decision shall occur pursuant to Section 13-1-25A(o).
(l) Mining Permit Application Requirements.
(1) General Requirements.
a. Any Applicant for a Mining Permit shall submit the information and
Application fee required by this Section 13-1-25A(l) and the fees required in
Section 13-1-25A(m) in order for the County to properly review the
Application.
b. The Applicant may provide the required Application information by
reference to other documents submitted to another Government Body or
Agency, including any information or documents submitted to a Local
Committee as permitted pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.33. In cases of
documentation by reference, the Applicant shall provide a copy of the
referenced document and a specific cross-reference identifying where the
information required by this Section 13-1-25A(l) is located in any referenced
material.
c. A non-refundable Application fee in the amount of $5,000.00 for costs and
expenses to commence the Application review process. The application fee
may be increased to cover the amount of any additional costs, expenses, fees
or other amounts which the County may incur to commence the Application
review process if those amounts are reasonably known to the County at the
time the Application is submitted.
d. A Reimbursement Agreement and deposit, as described in Section 13-1-
25A(m), including an acknowledgment that the Applicant shall be
responsible for any costs or expenses incurred by the County in its review
33
and determination of the Application, regardless of whether a Mining Permit
is actually issued to the Applicant or Operator for the Mining Operations.
e. If known at the time of Application, any applicable fees and any additional
information that is provided to assist the Retained Experts with reviewing the
Application on the County’s behalf.
f. The Application shall contain a statement, signed and notarized by the
Applicant that includes all of the following:
1. That the Applicant is duly authorized to bind itself, any Operator, and
any Permittee to the conditions and provisions set forth in this
Ordinance and in any Mining, Permit issued for the Mining
Operations contemplated in the Application.
2. That all statements, representations, documents and information
which are set forth in or accompany the Application are true, correct,
accurate and complete.
3. That the Applicant, Operator and Permittee, while engaged in
metallic mining activities and in reclamation activities, agree to abide
by all of the provisions and requirements of its Mining Permit, this
Ordinance, and all other Applicable Laws and Regulations.
4. That the Applicant’s representations and statements made in the
Application shall continue to exist and survive after a Mining Permit
is issued to the Applicant by the County, and that the Applicant is
duly authorized to bind itself, any Operator, and any Permittee for
future compliance with the terms of the Mining Permit.
5. That the Applicant grants permission and consent to the County, its
officers, employees, agents, consultants, contractors and
representatives to enter the real property subject to the Application
and the anticipated Mining Site for purposes of inspecting,
measuring, observing and any other verification that the information
contained in the Application is true and correct.
(2) Ownership Information and Operator Information.
a. The name, address, phone number, and email address of the Applicant.
b. The name, address, phone number and email address of the Operator.
c. The name, address, phone number, and email address of all owners or lessors
of the land on which the Mining Operation will occur.
d. If the Applicant is not an individual but is a corporation, partnership, limited
partnership, limited liability company or other entity:
34
1. The name and address of each director, partner or member of the
Applicant.
2. The name, address and position held by each officer or member of the
Applicant.
3. A list of the Applicant’s, or any Affiliate of the Applicant, experience
in mine projects, a list of current mine projects and the status of
compliance at each project site.
e. Proof that all local taxes, special charges, special assessments, fees, and
forfeitures (and any interest or penalties thereon) owed by the landowner
and/or Operator of the proposed Mining Site are current.
f. If the Operator is not an individual but is a corporation, partnership, limited
partnership, limited liability company or other entity:
1. The name and address of each director, partner, or member of the
Operator.
2. The name and address and position held by each officer or member of
the Operator.
3. A list of the Operator’s, or any Affiliate of the Operator, experience
in mine projects, a list of current mine projects and the status of
compliance at each project site.
(3) Site Information and Maps.
a. As to each parcel of real estate which is to be a part of the proposed Mining
Site and included in the use of any Mining Operation:
1. The legal description of the parcel.
2. The name, address and telephone number of each owner of an interest
in the parcel along with a statement of the interest in that parcel held
by that owner.
3. The tax parcel identification number of the parcel.
4. A statement as to what structures, improvements and roadways will
be situated on such parcel.
5. How such parcel will be used as part of the Mining Operation.
6. If the parcel is subject to a lease, the parties to such lease should be
identified and a summary of its terms should be stated.
7. A description of any utilities (public or private) or transportation
facilities on the parcel.
35
8. A description of any buildings or existing structures that will be
removed to accommodate any Mining Operations.
b. Any planned assemblage of parcels for any portion of the Mining Site or to
be used as part of the Mining Operation.
c. Any other anticipated County or other Government Body or Agency land use
approvals necessary to commence Mining Operations.
d. Approximate dates that Mine construction or other preliminary work on the
Mining Site is expected to begin, when Mining Operations will commence,
and when Mining Operations are anticipated to end.
e. The Applicant’s best estimate and explanation of the life expectancy of the
Mine.
f. A list of all minerals and materials to be extracted from the Mining Site. This
should include, but not be limited to, amounts of non-metallic and metallic
materials to be extracted.
g. Survey maps and parcel identification numbers of all contiguous parcels
owned by the same landowner/lessor on which the Mining Operation will be
located and any additional contiguous parcels on which the landowner/lessor
has secured a right of first refusal.
h. An aerial photo of the proposed site at a scale of not less than 1-inch equals
660 feet.
i. A topographic map of the Mining Site extending one mile beyond the Mining
Site boundaries at contour intervals no wider than 10 feet showing the
boundaries of the Mining Site, the location and total acreage of the Mining
Site, and the name of all roads within one mile of the Mining Site.
j. A site plan for the Mining Site showing the location of all existing and
proposed buildings and other structures, equipment, stockpiles, storage and
parking areas, road access points, driveways, and Buffer Areas along
bordering properties and public roads.
k. A plan for staking or marking the borders of the entire Mining Site and for
securing the Mining Site by appropriate measures, which may include
fencing or alternative measures consistent with Mine safety and security and
in accordance with all Applicable Laws and Regulations.
l. A map on which all residential, agricultural and municipal wells within one
mile of the boundaries of the Mining Site in all directions are marked and
given a numerical identification of the location.
m. The location and name of all surface waters, including, but not limited to,
lakes, private or public ponds, streams (including intermittent streams and
36
headwaters), drainage ditches, wetlands, drainage patterns, and other water
features on the site and within one mile of the Mining Site.
n. A description of the distribution, depth and type of topsoil for the Mining
Site. The description shall include the geological composition, depth and
width of the metallic deposit, and the location of slopes greater than 20% and
highly erodible soils.
o. A map identifying the location of all other non-contiguous sites within the
County or adjacent towns, cities, or villages, if any, that will contribute
material to the Mining Operation.
(4) Operation Plan. The Application shall include a written narrative description of
the Mining Operation in sufficient detail to allow the County and the public to
understand and assess the size and scope of the proposed Mining Operation and
potential impacts of the Mining Operation on public health, safety, convenience
and general well-being within the County. The operation plan is intended to
provide the information necessary to determine what information and conditions
shall be set forth in the Mining Permit. Each part of the operation plan shall be
prepared and verified by an appropriate professional expert in the field described in
the operation plan. The operation plan shall include a description of all significant
aspects of the proposed Mining Operation, including, but not limited to, the
following:
a. A summary of planned facilities for excavating, extracting, mining, milling,
ore-processing, transportation, tailings disposal, other waste disposal,
sedimentation, settling, retention and detention ponds, office buildings and
other structures, roads, railroad lines and utilities and the proposed location
of each.
b. Maps showing the maximum lateral extent and minimum and maximum
depth of underground or open pit workings and the location of primary
shafts, tunnels and other primary underground workings. Any map
submitted to satisfy this requirement shall be updated on an annual basis.
c. An estimate of the maximum number of people directly employed at the
mine site during each phase and an estimated breakdown by job
classification of all such employees, where such employees will park their
vehicles, eat, and what facilities are available for their use.
d. Types of Mining equipment to be used.
e. Plans for visual screening of mining activities around the perimeter of the
Mining Site and on the sides of any public highway.
f. Plans for lighting on site and measures to limit light pollution, including a
description and analysis of the ambient noise audible in half-mile
increments within a five-mile radius of the proposed Mining Site.
g. Radiation levels anticipated in waste rock.
37
h. A plan describing the methods for preventing access to all underground
Mine workings after Mine closure.
i. Dates of the planned commencement and cessation of the Mining Operation.
j. Description of hours of any Mining Operation on any portion of the Mining
Site, including all times when any vehicles will enter or leave any portion
of the Mine Site.
k. Description of mining methods, machinery and equipment to be used for
extraction and processing of the extracted material, and the sequence of
operations.
l. Estimated volume of material to be extracted over the life of the Mine and
for the next calendar year.
m. Identification of all proposed off-site trucking routes, if any, together with
the frequency of traffic and the common schedule of travel to be used for
transporting extracted materials or products to or from the Mining Site; a
description of the types of vehicles to be used on public roads and their
respective weights, lengths, widths, axle numbers and spacing, and ESAL
ratings both when empty and legally loaded; an assessment, which shall
include core sampling, of the adequacy of roads within proposed off-site
trucking routes and a description of any proposed alterations or
improvements to such roads; and a description of any traffic control or
other measures needed to protect public safety.
n. A water budget, including an estimate of the amount of daily water use,
water sources, and methods for disposing of water used or falling on the
Mining Site, including, but not limited to, methods used for infiltration and
control of run-off.
o. A listing of any hazardous materials, including, but not limited to, stored or
operational fuel supplies that will be used or located on the Mining Site and
a description of measures to be used for securing and storing these
materials. The operation plan shall also include a written plan for the use of
any hazardous materials at the Mining Site and procedures for responding
to spills of these materials and fuels on the Mining Site and the frequency
of regular drills for responding to spills on the Mining Site.
p. An erosion control plan, which shall describe what the Operator will do to
prevent material from the Mining Site from eroding, migrating or moving
onto neighboring properties or into other areas off the Mining Site.
q. A plan to control particles, which shall describe what the Operator will do
to prevent/limit/minimize the volume of particles entering onto neighboring
properties from the Mining Site and from vehicles and equipment engaged
in the Mining Operation.
38
r. A noise plan, which shall describe what the Operator will do to keep the
noise from Mining Operations below the decibel limits set forth in Section
13-1-25A(p)(6).
s. A blasting plan, which shall describe under what circumstances blasting
will be used, what type and volume of explosives which will be used, with
what frequency blasting will occur, between what hours blasting will occur,
and what steps the Operator will undertake to minimize the effects of the
noise and vibration from blasting on neighboring properties and the public.
t. A tailings and waste products plan, which shall set forth what projected
volume of tailings or other waste products or materials will be generated
each year, an indication of on what parcels of land such tailings and waste
materials will be situated, how the tailings and waste products will be
moved, and what steps the Operator will undertake to minimize the amount
of particulate matter entering on neighboring properties or other areas
outside of the Mining Site. This plan shall address specifically what the
Operator will do if the Mining Operations encounter radioactive materials,
radon, or other hazardous substances or materials.
u. A utilities plan, which shall describe the public utility and public service
requirements for the Mining Operation and describe the manner in which
all utility services will be provided at the Mining Site and the potential
system upgrades which the Mining Operation may require.
v. A roadway and traffic analysis of all reasonably foreseeable roadway needs
arising in the County due to the Mining Operations and reasonably
foreseeable secondary impacts of the Mining Operation which may result in
the demand for additional roadway improvements. With respect to roads in
the County, the analysis shall identify and describe the anticipated needs for
roadway modifications resulting from the likely mine-related traffic
impacts, including both primary and secondary impacts, and shall fully
describe the existing reasonably foreseeable mine-related changes to traffic
patterns, traffic volume, the class of roadways associated with those
patterns, and any load-related needs and restrictions. Such analysis shall set
forth in detail exactly what the Operator will do in the event of any damage
or destruction to public roads, highways and bridges, or other infrastructure,
as well as private roads, bridges and infrastructure, resulting from Mining
Operations or activities affiliated with the Mining Operations, whether
conducted on the Mining Site or off the Mining Site.
w. A fencing plan with a diagram depicting and describing where perimeter
fencing will be installed and maintained to prevent injury to persons and
animals from entry onto the Mining Site.
x. A County impact summary report, which shall include a thorough narrative
description of the Mining Operations in sufficient detail to allow the
County to assess probable physical, environmental and developmental
impacts of the proposed Mining Operations, and assess and summarize the
potential and estimated impacts on the human health, safety and welfare of
39
residents of the County, based on the potential environmental,
socioeconomic and other impacts of the proposed Mining Operation. The
report shall include, but shall not be limited to, the likely and potential
impacts of the proposed Mining Operations with respect to each of the
following baselines:
1. A life-of-mine analysis of impacts upon social and environmental
baseline parameters through completion of reclamation, including
any impact market conditions may have on Mining Operations.
2. A traffic impact analysis that discusses all reasonably foreseeable
roadway construction and maintenance needs arising in the County
from the proposed Mining Operation and reasonably foreseeable
secondary impacts of the Mining Operation that may result in the
demand for additional roadway or other infrastructure
improvements, repairs or additional maintenance needed as a result
of the Mining Operations, including a description of the anticipated
needs for roadway modifications resulting from the Mining
Operations, both primary and secondary, and shall fully describe the
existing reasonably foreseeable changes to traffic patterns, traffic
volume, the class of roadways associated with those patterns, and
any load-related needs and restrictions.
3. The impacts of Mining Operations on employment, economic
activity and tax base within the County.
4. The impacts of Mining Operations on the County’s population and
housing stock, including the availability of such housing stock.
5. The impacts of the Mining Operations on the need for additional
government services, including, but not limited to, infrastructure,
utilities, schools, fire protection, emergency medical services, and
police.
6. The expected changes in land use within the County, including the
percentage of lands devoted to each use currently and in the future
environmental impacts resulting from Mining Operations.
7. A description of the current environmental characteristics of the
Mining Site, including wildlife, vegetation and physical parameters
of groundwater quality and quantity, and surface water quality and
quantity, including wetlands as compared to the same environmental
characteristics after the Mining Operations commence.
8. A description of the topographical and aesthetic features of the
proposed Mining Site, including other geographical vegetative
conditions.
9. A description of the cultural features of the proposed Mining Site,
including, but not limited to, an inventory and analysis of all
40
historical and cultural sites and landmarks.
y. Copies of other submittal or application documents for the Mining
Operation to any other Government Body or Agency.
z. Copies of Approvals from any Government Body or Agency for the Mining
Operation.
aa. Any other information deemed necessary by the County in order for the
County to make an informed and educated decision on the Application and
to determine any appropriate conditions or terms to be set forth in the
Mining Permit.
(m) Reimbursement Agreement, Administration Deposit, Fees and Costs
(1) This Section 13-1-25A(m) is not intended to generate excess revenues for the
County’s use for purposes not related to an Application or any Mining Operation,
but the County, and hence its taxpayers, shall not be required to bear the financial
burden and obligations associated with the costs and expenses the County incurs in
connection with an Application or any Mining Operations. To that end, this Section
13-1-25A(m) provides that the Applicant shall be responsible for reimbursement of
all costs and expenses incurred by the County in connection with the Application.
(2) At the time an Application is filed with the County Planning and Zoning
Administrator, the Applicant shall execute for the benefit of the County a
Reimbursement Agreement, which shall require the Applicant and any other
Person associated with the proposed Mining Operation to pay any costs or
expenses incurred by the County in its review and determination of the
Application, and provide adequate security guaranteeing payment of the cost of the
investigation, review and processing of the Application, including, but not limited
to, Retained Expert fees, attorneys’ fees, administrative costs, expenses of
disseminating information to the public, expenses incurred to conduct required
public hearings, and other matters compelled by the need to review and respond to
the Application as provided by this Ordinance. The Reimbursement Agreement
shall require the Applicant and any other Person associated with the Mining
Operations to be responsible for payment of any costs or expenses incurred by the
County in its review and determination of the Application, regardless of whether a
Mining Permit is actually issued to the Applicant or Operator for the Mining
Operations. The Reimbursement Agreement shall also detail the Operator and
Permittee’s ongoing obligation and responsibility for payment of any costs and
expenses incurred by the County in connection with the Mining Permit, including,
but not limited to, costs of Retained Experts to ensure ongoing compliance with the
Mining Permit.
(3) The Applicant shall initially deposit $50,000.00 with the County to be
deposited in an administrative fee account for Application and proposed
Mining Operations so such funds are available to be withdrawn by the County and
used to reimburse the County for the costs and expenses the County incurs in
connection with Application review and Mining Operations. If the initial deposit of
$50,000.00 falls below $25,000.00, the County will notify the Applicant or
41
Operator and the Applicant or Operator will make an additional deposit into such
administrative fee account within 15 days of receipt of such notice so that the
remaining balance in the administrative fee account never remains below
$25,000.00 for more than 15 days.
(4) The Applicant shall be responsible for all costs and expenses incurred by the
County as a result of the Application and request for a Mining Permit, whether
such costs and expenses are incurred before or after the actual Application filing.
Actual costs may include, but are not limited to, Retained Expert Fees, County staff
time, travel expenses, professional fees, review fees, and equipment and material
costs. Such costs shall not exceed those which are reasonably charged for the same
or similar services by licensed professionals of the type retained.
(5) The County shall use standard cost and time accounting practices to
document its time and expenses in performing any work and purchasing any
equipment and services that will be billed to the Applicant. The Applicant may
review the accounting records upon written request at least five (5) business days in
advance to the County Planning and Zoning Administrator or its designee.
(6) Costs and expenses the County incurs under this Section 13-1-25A(m) shall be
billed to the Applicant for reimbursement to the County on a monthly basis and
shall be deducted from the initial deposit amount set forth in Section 13-1-
25A(m)(3) within 30 days of such billing. The County may elect to have any costs
and expenses billed directly to the Applicant by any Retained Expert or other party
performing services on behalf of the County in reviewing the Application. Should
the initial deposit fail to cover any costs and expenses, and the Applicant fails or
refuses to pay costs within 30 days upon request or demand from the County, the
County may stop processing the Application and deny any Mining Permit that has
not been issued. A Mining Permit shall not be issued until any fees or actual costs
incurred by the County prior to issuance have been paid in full.
(7) If an Applicant withdraws its Application at any time after the Application is
submitted to the County, all fees and charges assessed for work to that point in time
by the County shall be paid by the Applicant. Any balance remaining of the
deposit, after the payment of all fees and charges incurred by the County, shall be
refunded to the Applicant.
(n) Review Process for Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit Applications
(1) Application for Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit. The process set forth in
this Section 13-1-25A(n) shall apply to an Application that requests the grant of a
Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit.
(2) Initial Review. Upon receipt of a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit
Application, the County Planning and Zoning Administrator shall complete an
initial review to determine if additional information or expertise is necessary to
properly evaluate the Application. The County Planning and Zoning
Administrator’s acceptance of an Application does not render the Application
complete. The County Planning and Zoning Administrator may retain the services
of Retained Experts to assist in determining whether the Application is complete
42
and complies with the requirements of this Ordinance and other applicable County
regulations and all other Applicable Laws and Regulations, as applicable and as
determined by appropriate State and federal authorities on matters relating to State
and federal law and regulation.
(3) Notice of Receipt. Within 30 days of receipt of the complete Application, the
County Clerk shall also publish or post a class 2 notice under Wis. Stat. Chapter
985 indicating that the Application has been filed and transmitted to the County
Planning and Zoning Committee. A copy of the Application shall be made
available for public review.
(4) Additional Information. The County Planning and Zoning Committee may
request the Applicant to submit additional information if the County Planning and
Zoning Committee determines that the Application is incomplete, or if the County
Planning and Zoning Committee determines that additional information is needed
to determine whether the proposed Mining Operation will meet the applicable
standards. The County Planning and Zoning Committee may also retain the
services of Retained Experts to review the Application and report to the County
Planning and Zoning Committee whether additional information is required for
review of the Application and to determine whether the proposed Mining
Operations meet the applicable standards. The County Planning and Zoning
Committee shall make a determination regarding the need for additional
information or expertise within 90 days after receiving the Application, which time
period may be extended for a period of time up to an additional 90 days in the
County Planning and Zoning Committee’s sole and absolute discretion. If the
County Planning and Zoning Committee determines that no additional information
or expertise is necessary, the Application shall be deemed complete.
(5) Conditions. The County Planning and Zoning Committee may place conditions of
approval upon the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit based on the following
considerations or addressing the following concerns:
a. Any minimum operational standards for the Mining Operations, as set forth
in Section 13-1-25A(p).
b. Any reporting requirements, as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(q).
c. Any change in operation requirements, as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(r).
d. Any notification requirements regarding other Government Body or
Agency reports, conditions, approvals or actions.
e. Any notification requirements regarding notices or violations issued by any
other Government Body or Agency.
f. Reimbursement of all County costs and expenses as described in Section
13-1-25A(m) or as may otherwise be incurred.
g. Duration or phasing of the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit
43
h. Any conditions to address concerns of adverse effects of the Mining
Operations as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(b)(1)(c).
i. Any conditions, requirements or restrictions related to employment and
economic improvement as a result of the Mining Operations.
j. Any other conditions that the County Planning and Zoning Committee may
deem reasonable and necessary and that are:
1. Within the jurisdiction of the County;
2. Not arbitrary or unreasonable;
3. Have a substantial relation to public health, safety, convenience
and/or general welfare;
4. Supported by substantial evidence; and
5. To the extent practicable, are measurable.
(6) Retained Expert Findings. To the extent practical and within the area of expertise
of a Retained Expert, a Retained Expert shall provide a written verification that any
conditions imposed by the County Planning and Zoning Committee are related to
the purpose of this Ordinance and are based upon facts and information that would
support the imposition of the condition.
(7) Public Hearing and Determination by County Planning and Zoning
Committee. Within 120 days of receipt of the complete Application, the County
Planning and Zoning Committee shall hold a public hearing on the Application
following a class 2 notice under Wis. Stat. Chapter 985. Within 180 days of receipt
of the complete Application, and any additional information requested by the
County Planning and Zoning Committee, and following the public hearing (which
may be adjourned from time to time in the County Planning and Zoning
Committee’s sole and absolute discretion) the County Planning and Zoning
Committee shall make findings of fact and determination of whether to grant the
Application’s request for a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit, or deny the
Application’s request for a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit.
(8) Approval and Issuance of Mining Permit. Upon the County Planning and
Zoning Committee’s approval of the Application’s request for a Conditional Use
Permit/Mining Permit, the approved Conditional Use Permit shall be deemed the
Mining Permit.
(9) Remedies on Denial. If the County Planning and Zoning Committee denies the
Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit request, an Applicant may exercise any
remedies available under the County’s ordinances or at law, including, but not
limited to, an appeal to the County’s board of adjustment pursuant to Wis. Stat. §
59.694(4). The County’s board of adjustment shall apply the common law
certiorari standard of review in rendering its decision and may elect to accept
additional evidence, within the board of adjustment’s discretion. In addition, the
44
Applicant may re-submit its Application in accordance with this Ordinance, and
re-submittal shall constitute an Application in conformance with all provisions of
this Ordinance, provided that any differences between the original Application and
the new Application shall be summarized by the Applicant in a document entitled
“Explanation of Reasons for Re-Submittal.” An Application received by re-
submittal may be denied for any reason that any original Application may be
denied.
(o) Review and Approval Process for Local Agreement/Mining Permit
(1) Application for Mining Permit by Local Agreement. The process set forth in this
Section 13-1-25A(n) shall apply to an Application that requests the grant of a
Mining Permit by virtue of the County Board’s approving and adopting a Local
Agreement pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 293.41.
(2) Initial Review. Upon receipt of an Application for Local Agreement/Mining
Permit, the County Planning and Zoning Administrator shall complete an initial
review to determine if additional information or expertise is necessary to properly
evaluate the Application. The County Planning and Zoning Administrator’s
acceptance of an Application does not render the Application complete. The
County Planning and Zoning Administrator may retain the services of Retained
Experts to assist in determining whether the Application is complete and complies
with the requirements of this Ordinance and other applicable County regulations.
(3) Notice of Receipt. Within 30 days of receipt of the complete Application, the
County Clerk shall also publish or post a class 2 notice under Wis. Stat. Chapter
985 indicating that the Application has been filed and transmitted to the County
Planning and Zoning Committee. A copy of the Application shall be made
available for public review.
(4) Additional Information. The County Planning and Zoning Committee may
request the Applicant submit additional information if the County Planning and
Zoning Committee determines that the Application is incomplete, or if the County
Planning and Zoning Committee determines that additional information is needed
to determine whether the proposed Mining Operation will meet the applicable
standards. The County Planning and Zoning Committee may also retain the
services of Retained Experts to review the Application and report to the County
Planning and Zoning Committee whether additional information is required for
review of the Application and to determine whether the proposed Mining
Operations meet the applicable standards. The County Planning and Zoning
Committee shall make a determination regarding the need for additional
information or expertise within 90 days after receiving the Application. If no
additional information or expertise is deemed necessary, the Application shall be
deemed complete. The County Planning and Zoning Committee is designated as
the sole and exclusive agent of the County Board in relation to the negotiation of a
Local Agreement. When an Application is deemed complete, the County Planning
and Zoning Committee shall establish dates and locations for meetings to negotiate
a Local Agreement.
45
(5) Requirements in a Local Agreement. A Local Agreement shall include the
following information and terms:
a. The requirements set forth in Wis. Stat. § 293.41(2) and in Sections 13-1-
25A(i)(2), 13-1-25A(i)(3) and 13-1-25A(s)(6)(b). Minimum operation
standards such as those set forth in Section 13-1-25A(p).
b. Reporting requirements such as those set forth in Section 13-1-25A(q).
c. Change in operation requirements such as those set forth in Section 13-1-
25A(r).
d. Inspection, enforcement, procedures and penalties such as those set forth in
Section 13-1-25A(s), including a forfeiture schedule. The County Board
may delegate its enforcement powers under the Local Agreement to the
County Planning and Zoning Committee. Section 13-1-25A(s)(6)(b) may
not be modified in a Local Agreement/Mining Permit.
e. The process of reimbursement of all County expenses incurred as a result of
the Application review process and the negotiation process of the Local
Agreement.
f. Other consideration for impacts of a Mining Operation paid to the County or
other units of government.
(6) Optional Contents of Local Agreement. The County Planning and Zoning
Committee may consider the specific provisions in the Local Agreement related to
the following, without limitation:
a. Any conditions, requirements or restrictions needed to adequately address
concerns of adverse effects of the Mining Operations as set forth in Section
13-1-25A(b)(1)(c).
b. Any conditions, requirements or restrictions needed to adequately address
concerns of specific environmental impacts and effects on natural
resources, whether those natural resources are located entirely within the
County or partially within the County.
c. Any conditions, requirements or restrictions related to employment and
economic improvement as a result of the Mining Operations.
d. Any notification requirements regarding other Government Body or
Agency reports, conditions, approvals or actions, including notifications to
the Operator for mining operations located outside of the County.
e. Any notification requirements regarding notices or violations issued by any
other Government Body or Agency.
f. Requirements to minimize the impact of Mining Operations on roads,
bridges or other transportation infrastructure.
46
g. Reimbursement of all County costs and expenses incurred by the County, its
agents and any Retained Experts in the review and negotiation of the Local
Agreement and in the review and determination of whether to issue the Local
Agreement/Mining Permit.
h. Duration or phasing of the Local Agreement/Mining Permit.
i. Any recommendations or information provided by the Local Committee,
other Government Body or Agency, or relating to other Applicable Laws
and Regulations.
j. Any other conditions that the County Planning and Zoning Committee may
deem reasonable and necessary.
(7) Modification of Zoning Ordinance Requirements. Except for the requirements
set forth in Sections 13-1-25A(i)(2), 13-1-25A(i)(3), and 13-1-25A(s)(6)(b), a
Local Agreement may modify, waive or alter the provisions of this Ordinance and
any other County regulations; provided, however, that if the terms of this
Ordinance require specific votes or specific action for such waiver, waiver cannot
occur absent such votes or specific action.
(8) Recommendation to the County Board. Upon completion of negotiations, the
County Planning and Zoning Committee shall either recommend that the County
Board grant the Application’s request for approval of the Local Agreement/Mining
Permit or recommend that the County Board deny the Application’s request for
approval of the Local Agreement/Mining Permit. The County Planning and Zoning
Committee’s recommendation shall not be binding upon the County Board.
(9) Decision by the County Board.
a. Notice and Hearing. Upon recommendation by the County Planning and
Zoning Committee, the County Clerk shall place the County Planning and
Zoning Committee’s recommendation on the agenda for the next regular
meeting of the County Board. At that meeting, the County Board shall set a
date for a public hearing. At least 15 days prior to the public hearing, the
County Clerk shall publish or post a class 2 notice under Wis. Stat. Chapter
985. At the public hearing, the County Board shall take public comment on
the Application and proposed Local Agreement/Mining Permit.
b. County Board Decision. Within 30 days following the public hearing, the
County Chairperson shall set a date for a County Board meeting to consider
a final decision on the Application and Local Agreement/Mining Permit. At
that meeting, the County Board shall review the complete Application, any
Local Committee reports or information, any reports or information from
other units of government or parties that participated in the Local
Committee or may be party to the Local Agreement, any Retained Experts’
reports, public comments made, and information provided at the public
hearing, and any other information deemed necessary by the County Board.
Consideration of the Local Agreement/Mining Permit may be adjourned
47
from time to time as the County Board may determine in its sole and
absolute discretion.
c. Approval and Issuance of Mining Permit. Upon the County Board’s
approval of the Application for Local Agreement/Mining Permit and
adoption of the Local Agreement, the Local Agreement shall be deemed the
Mining Permit.
d. Effective Date. A Local Agreement/Mining Permit shall be effective after
all of the County Board, and the governing body of any other county, town,
village, city or tribal government which is identified as a party to the Local
Agreement approve the Agreement in a public meeting.
e. Remedies on Denial. If the County Board fails to approve the Local
Agreement/Mining Permit, an Applicant may re-submit its Application in
accordance with this Ordinance, and re-submittal shall constitute an
Application in conformance with all provisions of this Ordinance, provided
that any differences between the original Application and the new
Application shall be summarized by the Applicant in a document entitled
“Explanation of Reasons for Re-Submittal.” An Application received by re-
submittal may be denied for any reason that any original Application may
be denied.
f. Recording. Upon approval of a Local Agreement/Mining Permit, the
County Clerk shall record a copy of the Local Agreement/Mining Permit
against any parcel of real property upon which the Mining Site sits or is
used as part of the Mining Operation. The Applicant shall secure all
required approvals and permissions to record the Local Agreement/Mining
Permit from the necessary property owners in order to comply with this
Section 13-1-25A(o)(9)(f).
(p) Minimum Operational Standards Applicable to All Mining Permits
(1) The standards set forth in this Section 13-1-25A(p) shall be considered as
conditions in a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit or as the foundation of
negotiations in developing the terms of a Local Agreement/Mining Permit. The
standards set forth in Section 13-1-25A(p) shall be deemed the minimum
operational standards and no Mining Permit may allow standards below those set
forth in this Section 13-1-25A(p) unless set forth otherwise in a Local Agreement.
(2) General Standards.
a. The borders of the entire Mining Site will be appropriately staked or marked,
and the Mining Site will be secured by appropriate measures which may
include fencing or other alternative measures consistent with mine safety and
security as set forth by any Government Body or Agency.
b. The Operator shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the County that all
other Applicable Laws and Regulations of any Government Body or
Agency required for the Mining Operation have been or will be obtained
48
prior to commencement of any Mining Operation. The Applicant shall also
deliver copies of any applications, notices, reports, approvals or waivers
from any Government Body or Agency regarding the Mining Operations’
compliance with Applicable Laws and Regulations prior to commencing
any Mining Operations.
c. The Operator shall provide proof that it has provided the financial
assurances as required under Wis. Stat. Chapter 293 or any other
Applicable Laws and Regulations.
d. The Operator shall agree to comply with all Applicable Laws and
Regulations and any other Government Body or Agency permits, approvals,
conditions or restrictions for the Mining Operations.
(3) Buffer Areas. The Operator shall provide a Buffer Area from the boundaries of the
Mining Site to protect bordering properties from noise, dust, lighting, odors,
blasting and other adverse impacts of the Mining Operation along bordering
property lines and public roadways.
a. The Buffer Area shall provide a setback of one mile from the Mining Site to
the property line of any adjacent property owner unless a landowner
consents to a lesser distance, but not less than 2000 feet. If consent is
provided for a lesser distance, a copy of such consent agreement shall be
recorded against the property at the register of deeds office for the county in
which the land is located and a copy of the agreement shall be provided to
the County Clerk.
b. The Buffer Area shall provide a setback of one-half mile from the Mining
Site to any school, medical facility, nursing home, or community based
residential facility.
c. The Operator shall screen the Mining Operations from public view.
Screening may be achieved through the use of berms, additional setbacks or
other measures deemed adequate by the County Planning and Zoning
Committee and the County Board.
(4) Hours of Operation. The Operator shall limit normal hours of operations at the
Mining Site to 9 hours a day Monday through Friday not earlier than 7:00 a.m. and
not later than 8:00 p.m. and on Saturday not earlier than 8:00 a.m. and not later
than noon, to avoid substantial or undue impacts on neighboring properties and
County residents. During any Mining Operations occurring after sunset, the
Operator shall use white noise or lighted backup alarms on equipment. Operations
on-site shall not occur on Sundays or legal holidays.
(5) Control of Light. The Operator shall limit night lighting on a Mining Site to that
which is minimally necessary for security and worker safety. Every effort consistent
with the legal requirements for safety shall be made to minimize illumination of the
night sky and neighboring properties. At a minimum such measures shall include the
following:
49
a. The use of full cutoff shrouds on all lights.
b. Portable lighting shall be used only as necessary to illuminate temporary
work areas.
c. The use of berms of sufficient height coupled with other methods of visual
screening to block light from the Mining Site to neighboring properties.
d. The design and location of access roads, driveways and other access points
to the Mining Site to minimize lights from traffic and operations to
neighboring properties.
(6) Control of Noise.
a. The Operator shall control off-site noise levels to avoid adverse impacts to
neighboring landowners. The noise levels at the boundaries of the mining or
processing site shall not exceed 65 dB. The noise levels at the boundaries of
any school, medical facility, nursing home, or community based residential
facility shall not exceed 60 dB. Decibels shall be based on dB(A). which is
the unit of sound level expressed in decibels (dB) and A-weighted as
described in ANSI § 1.4-1983 and shall be measured in accordance with
accepted protocols.
b. Noise levels shall be monitored at the Mining Site’s property boundary by
an independent testing company. The tests shall occur for a 10-day period
at least once per quarter. The results shall be reported to the County within
30 days of the last test result.
(7) Blasting Requirements. In addition to all other applicable provisions of this
Ordinance and any other Applicable Laws or Regulations, the Operator shall
comply with the following requirements when engaging in any blasting activity as
part of the Mining Operations:
a. Blasting may only occur between the hours of 10:00 a.m. and 2:00 p.m.,
Monday through Friday. Blasting may not occur on weekends or outside of
the hours set forth herein.
b. No later than 30 days prior to blasting, the Operator shall provide written
notice of its intended blasting to the County Administrator and to each
property owner whose property is located within two miles of the perimeter
of the Mining Site.
c. The Zoning Administrator, either upon request of an impacted landowner or
by the Zoning Administrator’s discretion, may require that any structure
lying within a two-mile radius of the perimeter of the Mining Site be
surveyed by an independent third party, the cost of which shall be paid by
the Operator, prior to any blasting activities on the Mining Site. The Zoning
Administrator, either upon request of an impacted landowner or by the
Zoning Administrator’s discretion, may require that any structure lying
within a two-mile radius of the perimeter of the Mining Site be surveyed by
50
an independent third party, the cost of which shall be paid by the Operator,
after any blasting activities on the Mining Site to determine whether the
blasting activities caused property damage to any structures or other
property within the two-mile radius of the perimeter of the Mining Site.
d. The Operator shall comply with all Applicable Laws and Regulations when
conducting blasting activities.
(8) Well Monitoring and Impact on Groundwater Quality. In order to ensure
compliance with the Applicable Laws and Regulations regarding groundwater
quality, the Operator shall monitor all private and public wells (to the extent access
can be secured), at the Operator’s sole cost and expense, located within three miles
of the perimeter of the Mining Site in order to provide baseline data concerning
quantity and quality of water. The Operator shall comply with the requirements of
this Section 13-1-25A(p)(7) for a period of two years prior to commencement of
construction of any portion of the Mining Site or commencement of any Mining
Operation, and during the period of the Mining Operation, and continuing for no
less than five years after the completion of the Mining Site reclamation. The wells
shall be monitored quarterly for lead, arsenic, turbidity, total dissolved solids,
chlorides, nitrates, specific conductivity and any toxic substance that may
reasonably be believed to be present in the ore deposit proposed to be mined. Well
monitoring required under this Ordinance shall be performed by an independent
consultant agreeable to both the County and the Operator. All test and monitoring
results shall be reported to the County within 30 days of completion. Mining
Operations shall not cause an exceedance of groundwater quality standards in Wis.
Admin. Code Ch. NR 140 or as otherwise may be set forth in any Applicable Law
or Regulation. Any test or monitoring result showing that groundwater quality
standards have not been met as set forth in Wis. Admin. Code Ch. NR 140 or any
other Applicable Law or Regulation shall be cured by the Operator at the
Operator’s sole cost and expense.
(9) Fugitive Dust Control. In addition to any ambient air monitoring required by WI
DNR, the Operator shall comply with best management practices for control of off-
site fugitive dust, including, but not limited to, use of truck covers, watering roads
and equipment, and stabilizing stock piles.
(q) Reporting
(1) Considerations. The standards set forth in this Section 13-1-25A(q) shall be
considered as conditions in a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit or as the
foundation of negotiations in developing the terms of a Local Agreement/Mining
Permit.
(2) Ongoing Reporting Requirements.
a. The Operator shall provide notice to the County of any notices of
violations, citations, or other enforcement actions taken by any other
Government Body or Agency as a result of the Mining Operation or any
activity on the Mining Site. The Operator shall provide notice to the County
of such actions within 15 days after receiving such notice from the
51
Government Body or Agency.
b. All monitoring data, sampling results and any other test results required by
this Ordinance shall be undertaken at the Operator’s expense and provided
to the County Clerk. Unless otherwise specified in this Ordinance, all
monitoring data sampling results and any other test results shall be provided
to the County Clerk within 30 days of receipt of the results by the Operator.
(3) Annual Report.
a. No later than October 1 of each calendar year, the Operator shall submit an
annual report to the County Planning and Zoning Committee for all active
and intermittent Mining Sites and Mining Operations for which the Operator
has a Mining Permit in Bayfield County. The County Planning and Zoning
Committee may require that the Operator appear at a County Planning and
Zoning Committee meeting to present the annual report and answer
questions from the County Planning and Zoning Committee. The County
Board may also require that the Operator appear at a County Board meeting
to present the annual report and answer questions from the County Board.
The reporting period shall be from the date of the issuance of the first
Operator’s Mining Permit to August 31, and thereafter from September 1 to
August 31.
b. The annual report shall include the following information:
1. An identification of the Operator and location of the Mining Site.
2. A map or drawing of the entire Mining Site accurately showing each
use, activity and area associated with all Mining Operations.
3. A map or drawing accurately showing the area of excavation, the
unclaimed area and the reclaimed area, including a calculation of
the number of acres for each type.
4. A written description of activities, including ore extraction and
waste material production and operations on the Mining Site for the
previous calendar year, including the cubic yards each of material
extracted, processed, and waste material produced.
5. A written description of all activities and operations on the Mining
Site, including ore extraction and waste material production or
processing anticipated for the following calendar year.
6. A written report demonstrating how the Operator has been in
compliance with all terms and conditions of its Mining Permit and
this Ordinance. The report shall include all groundwater, surface
water and other monitoring results, as well as a copy of all annual
reports or other reports submitted to any other Government Body or
Agency.
52
7. A summary of all areas of non-compliance, a plan for bringing non-
compliant areas into compliance, and any actions taken by any
Government Body or Agency as a result of any alleged or actual
non-compliance.
8. A signed certification by the Operator to the effect that: “I certify
that this information is true and accurate, and except as expressly set
forth herein, the metallic mineral mining site and operations
described herein and for which the County issued the Mining
Permit dated complies with all
conditions of the County ordinances and codes, and all other
governmental or other regulatory authority requirements, laws,
regulations and requirements and is in compliance with any
applicable permits, requirements, conditions and approvals required
for operation of the metallic mineral mining site and operations
described herein and for which the County issued the Mining Permit
dated __________.”
9. Any other materials required in this Ordinance that may not have
been already submitted at the time of the annual report.
10. Any other materials or information that the Zoning Administrator,
County Planning and Zoning Committee or County Board deems
necessary.
c. Quarterly Inspection Summary. The Operator shall submit to the County
Clerk, within 30 days following the close of each calendar quarter, a report
summarizing the results of the following inspections:
1. Daily Inspections. The Operator shall inspect any tailings ponds and
any other waste lagoons on a daily basis for evidence and
indications of any phenomenon, activity or process which might
affect the integrity of any tailings pond or dike.
2. Monthly Inspections. The Operator shall designate one or more
qualified senior personnel to inspect any tailings ponds and any
other waste lagoons on a monthly basis and prepare, sign and date a
report. If the person or persons making the monthly inspections is
not a Wisconsin registered professional engineer, then the Operator
shall also provide for quarterly inspections as required herein by a
Wisconsin registered professional engineer.
3. Natural Event Inspections. The Operator shall inspect any tailings
ponds and any other waste lagoons after any unusual natural
occurrence, including, but not limited to, the following: earthquake,
tornado, flood, storm event exceeding the 100-year storm threshold,
or any other natural event which the Operator should reasonably
expect could affect the integrity of the tailings pond, dike or other
areas of the Mining Site.
53
d. Inspection Logs. All daily, monthly and quarterly inspection observations
shall be recorded in a log and maintained on the premises of the Mining
Site and be made available for inspection by County officials during regular
business hours. The Operator shall submit copies of inspection logs to the
County upon request.
(r) Changes in Operation.
(1) Considerations. The standards set forth in this Section 13-1-25A(r) shall be
considered as conditions in a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit or as the
foundation of negotiations in developing the terms of a Local Agreement/Mining
Permit.
(2) Expansion. Expansion of the Mining Site or any Mining Operation that is not
specifically allowed by or is inconsistent with any limitation or parameters of the
Mining Permit is prohibited and is a violation of this Ordinance. Performance of
activities not described in, or activities not expressly allowed by the Mining Permit
shall be considered an unlawful expansion and a violation of this Ordinance. The
movement of any waste, ore or concentrate to a Mining Site from a location outside
the boundary of that Mining Site shall be deemed an unlawful expansion of
Mining Operation unless such movement is specifically and expressly authorized
in a Mining Permit issued pursuant to this Ordinance.
(3) Suspension or Termination of Mining.
a. An Operator must provide notice to the County as soon as possible of any
temporary halt of Mining Operations lasting more than 180 days, including,
but not limited to, a statement showing projected loss of employment.
Notice shall include the reason for the temporary suspension as well as
plans to ensure continued compliance of all Applicable Laws and
Regulations throughout the suspension period.
b. The Operator must provide notice of its intent to permanently terminate any
or all Mining Operations at the Mining Site no later than one year before
the proposed Mining Operation, or any portion of the Mining Operation, is
terminated. The Operator must provide notice by the end of each calendar
year of any significant change in the anticipated timing of each major phase
of the Mining Operation as originally detailed in the plan of operation
submitted as part of the Application pursuant to this Ordinance and explain
any reasonably foreseeable changes to the overall Mining Operation
lifetime based on such changes.
c. Upon receipt of a notice of temporary halt in mining or upon a cessation
lasting more than 180 days, whichever is sooner, the County Planning and
Zoning Committee may require that the Operator take additional measures
to ensure that public health, safety and welfare are protected during the
temporary cessation of Mining Operations, including, but not limited to, a
temporary cap on tailing facilities, additional security measures, additional
erosion control measures, and other site stabilization measures.
54
d. A suspension longer than two years shall be considered a permanent
abandonment and require the Operator to commence closure and
reclamation. The Operator may request the County Planning and Zoning
Committee re-evaluate this requirement based on exceptional
circumstances. The County Planning and Zoning Committee shall not be
obligated to grant the request for re-evaluation. The County Planning and
Zoning Committee’s determination of the Operator’s request for re-
evaluation is not subject to appeal or other additional review.
(4) Major Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit Modifications or Amendment.
If a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit has been issued, both the County and
the Operator may pursue an amendment to that Conditional Use Permit/Mining
Permit during the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit term pursuant to this
Section 13-1-25A(r)(4) and Section 13-1-25A(s)(7)(b).
a. The County reserves the right to reopen and modify any Conditional Use
Permit/Mining Permit if it is determined by the County Planning and
Zoning Committee, upon the basis of newly discovered evidence, including,
but not limited to, evidence presented that any Mining Operation or any
part of the Mining Operation by any Government Body or Agency, such
Mining would, without further conditions placed on the Mining Permit,
substantially endanger the environment, public health, safety or welfare of
the community. Any action to reopen a Mining Permit shall be done by
hearing with at least 30 days’ notice to the Operator. In order to reopen the
Mining Permit and modify any terms and conditions, the County Planning
and Zoning Committee must determine that there is reasonable cause to
believe that the newly discovered evidence demonstrates a threat to the
environment, public health, safety or welfare.
b. Should the Operator desire to modify the Conditional Use Permit/Mining
Permit in any way, it may request modification by submitting a written
application and evidence supporting such modification to the County Clerk.
Such application shall be in substantially the same form as the original
Application for the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit, with the same
level and substance of information required, although it shall be permissible
to incorporate by reference any portions of the original Application that still
pertain to the re-opening request. Upon receipt of the application to modify
the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit, the County shall follow the
procedures outlined in this Ordinance for review of an application for a
Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(n).
(5) Minor Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit Modifications and
Amendments. Upon request by either the County or the Operator for a minor
modification to the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit, the County Planning
and Zoning Committee has the discretion to determine that a proposed Mining
Permit modification is so inconsequential in scope or limited in proposed duration
that the Mining Permit modification procedures outlined under Section 13-1-
25A(r)(4) are unnecessary and therefore inapplicable. If such a determination is
made, the County Planning and Zoning Committee may act on the proposed minor
Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit modification at a properly noticed County
55
Planning and Zoning Committee meeting. The County Planning and Zoning
Committee’s decision shall require a majority vote by the County Planning and
Zoning Committee.
(6) Local Agreement/Mining Permit Modification and Amendment.
a. The County or the Operator may request to modify or amend a Local
Agreement/Mining Permit according to the procedures set forth in the
Local Agreement/Mining Permit.
b. The Local Agreement/Mining Permit may address both major
modifications and amendments and minor modifications or amendments.
c. Any modification or amendment to a Local Agreement/Mining Permit shall
be executed by all parties thereto and shall be approved according to the
requirements set forth in Wis. Stat. § 293.41(4), Section 13-1-25A(i)(3) and
Section 13-1-25A(o)(6).
d. The County Board may delegate its authority to modify, amend, suspend or
revoke a Local Agreement/Mining Permit pursuant to this Section 13-1-
25A(s)(6)(c) to the County Planning and Zoning Committee.
(7) Transfer of Mining Permit. When one Operator succeeds to the interest of
another in a Mining Site, the County shall release the current Operator of the
responsibilities imposed by the Mining Permit only if all the following conditions
are met, pursuant to the County’s reasonable discretion:
a. Both the Operator and the successor Operator are in compliance with the
requirements and standards of this Ordinance and all other Applicable Laws
and Regulations.
b. The successor Operator assumes the responsibility of the current Operator
in writing and agrees to operate, complete and reclaim the Mining
Operations in accordance with the Mining Permit and all other Applicable
Laws and Regulations.
c. The successor Operator shows proof of financial responsibility in the same
manner and amount as the current Operator and the successor Operator
agrees to maintain any instrument of financial assurance at the same level
as the current Operator.
d. The County Planning and Zoning Committee makes a written finding that
all conditions of the existing Mining Permit will be complied with by the
successor Operator.
e. The Local Agreement, if any, is amended to reflect the change in Operator
and Persons responsible under the Local Agreement.
(8) Commencement of Reclamation. Reclamation of any Mine shall begin within one
year after cessation of Mining Operations, whether temporary or permanent, in
56
accordance with the reclamation plan as set forth in Wis. Stat. Chapter 293 and as
may be required by any Government Body or Agency.
(s) Inspection, Enforcement, Procedures and Penalties Associated with a Mining Permit.
(1) Application of Section 13-1-25A(s). The provisions of this Section 13-1-25A(s)
apply to a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit. The provisions of this Section
13-1-25A(s) shall be considered for inclusion in a Local Agreement/Mining Permit
provided, however, that the terms set forth in Section 13-1-25A(s)(6) are required
elements of a Local Agreement unless otherwise agreed by majority vote of the
County Board.
(2) Inspection of Mining Operation.
a. Upon issuance of a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit, the Operator is
deemed, as a condition of the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit
issuance, to have consented to allow inspections of the Mining Site and all
Mining Operations by the County Planning and Zoning Committee or its
designee(s) for the purpose of determining compliance with the provisions
of this Ordinance and the terms and conditions of the Conditional Use
Permit/Mining Permit. Inspections may occur pursuant to this Section 13-1-
25A(s).
b. All required records to demonstrate lawful operation of the Mining
Operation shall be maintained by the Operator at the Mining Site and made
available within a reasonable time to the County Planning and Zoning
Committee or its designee(s) to assist the County Planning and Zoning
Committee to determine compliance with the provisions of this Ordinance.
c. The Operator shall provide access to the Mining Site and Mining
Operations to allow the County Planning and Zoning Committee or its
designee(s) to inspect for the purpose of investigating any complaint
against the Operator alleging a condition that negatively impacts the public
health, safety or welfare.
d. If, as a result of any inspections or investigations, the County Planning and
Zoning Committee determines that any Retained Expert should undertake
any further inspections or investigations, the County may hire a Retained
Expert, the expense of which shall be paid by the Operator pursuant to
Section 13-1-25A(m). If the Operator fails to provide access for the
inspections or investigations, or provide payment of the County’s expenses,
the County may take enforcement action under this Section 13-1-25A(s) or
as otherwise set forth in this Ordinance.
(3) Violations. In addition to failure to comply with any provision of this Ordinance,
the following are specific violations under this Ordinance:
a. Failure to comply with any term or condition set forth in the Conditional
Use Permit/Mining Permit.
57
b. Failure to comply with any Applicable Law or Regulation, or failure to
comply with any permit, approval, order, condition, directive or
requirement issued by a Government Body or Agency.
c. Engaging in any Mining Operation or any activities associated with
metallic mining without a Mining Permit granted by the County pursuant to
this Ordinance.
d. Failure to comply with the applicable minimum standards and other terms
of this Ordinance, all other County ordinances and codes, and any
Applicable Law or Regulation, or failure to comply with any applicable
permits, approvals or conditions required for the Mining Operation as set
forth by a Government Body or Agency.
e. Making an incorrect or false statement in the information and
documentation submitted as part of the Application, Mining Permit
approval process, or during inspection of the Mining Operation by the
County or its designees or other duly appointed representative.
f. Failure to timely file the annual operational report under Section 13-1-
25A(q).
g. Failure to comply with any conditions of approving the Application or any
agreements entered into as a condition of approving the Application and
issuing the Mining Permit.
h. Failure to provide or maintain any financial assurance required as a
condition to issuing the Mining Permit.
i. Failure to take appropriate action in response to a notice of violation,
citation, request for additional financial assurance, or other order issued by
the County.
(4) Notice of Violation. The County Planning and Zoning Committee or its designee
may issue a notice of violation and order for curing the violation upon a violation
of any term of this Ordinance or upon any violation of the terms and conditions of
a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit pursuant to the following provisions.
a. The County Planning and Zoning Committee shall issue a notice of
violation within 30 days of the County’s obtaining knowledge of the
violation by service upon the Operator. The notice of violation may include
an order, proposed work plan or other remediating steps to cure the
violation. The Operator shall have 30 days from the Operator’s receipt of
the notice of violation and order to complete all necessary work to cure the
violations to the County’s satisfaction.
b. Any Person affected by a notice and order issued in connection with the
enforcement of this Ordinance may request and shall be granted a hearing
on the notice of violation and order before the County Planning and Zoning
Committee, provided such person shall file with the County Clerk a written
58
petition requesting the hearing and setting forth the person’s name, address,
telephone number and a brief statement of the grounds for the hearing, the
requested relief, or for the mitigation of the order. Such petition shall be
filed within 30 days of the date the notice and order are served upon the
Operator. Upon receipt of the petition for hearing, the County Clerk shall
set a time and place for a hearing before the County Planning and Zoning
Committee and shall give the petitioner written notice thereof. In the event
the petitioner is not the Operator, the County shall provide notice of the
hearing to the Operator.
c. After the hearing, the County Planning and Zoning Committee by a
majority vote, shall sustain, modify or withdraw the notice, or modify the
order, depending on the County Planning and Zoning Committee’s
findings, as to whether the provisions of this Ordinance have been complied
with. The petitioner shall be notified within 10 days of the County Planning
and Zoning Committee’s issuance of its findings and any modification of
the order. In the event the petitioner is not the Operator, the County shall
provide a copy of the County Planning and Zoning Committee’s findings of
fact and any modification of the County’s order to the Operator.
d. The proceedings of the public hearing, including the findings and decision
of the County Planning and Zoning Committee and the reasons therefor,
shall be summarized in writing and entered as a matter of public record in
the office of the County Clerk. Such record shall also include a copy of
every notice and order issued in connection with the case.
e. If the Operator fails to correct or cure the violation to the County Planning
and Zoning Committee’s satisfaction in accordance with any compliance
schedule, order or other findings approved by the County Planning and
Zoning Committee, the County Planning and Zoning Committee may
revoke the Mining Permit and commence legal action against the Operator
for injunctive relief and additional appropriate forfeitures.
f. Prior to the County’s issuance of a notice and order, and prior to the public
hearing set forth in Section 13-1-25A(s)(4)(b) above, the County may take
such action as necessary in order to protect the public’s health, welfare and
safety, including, but not limited to, the remedies set forth in Section 13-1-
25A(s)(5) in the event of any violation of this Ordinance or the Mining
Permit.
(5) Remedies. The County Planning and Zoning Committee may take any appropriate
action or proceeding against any Person in violation of this Ordinance or in
violation of the terms of the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit, including, but
not limited to, the following:
a. Issue a stop work order for all Mining Operations.
b. Issue a notice of violation and order that specifies the action to be taken to
remedy a violation.
59
c. Issue a citation in accordance with the County’s citation ordinance or
pursuant to the County’s general authority.
d. Refer the matter to legal counsel for consideration and commencement of
legal action, including, but not limited to, the assessment of forfeitures
under Section 13-1-25A(s)(9) and injunctive relief.
e. Suspend or revoke the Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit pursuant to
Section 13-1-25A(s)(6) or Section 13-1-25A(s)(7).
(6) Suspension or Revocation of Mining Permit Issued Pursuant to Section 13-1-
25A(o) as a Local Agreement/Mining Permit.
a. Upon receipt of a notice of violation as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(s)(4),
and after giving notice and conducting a hearing if requested pursuant to
Section 13-1-25A(s)(4)(b), the County Board may suspend or revoke a
Local Agreement/Mining Permit for a violation of this Ordinance or the
terms of the Local Agreement/Mining Permit. A Local Agreement/Mining
Permit may also be revoked if it is determined after notice and a hearing
that there has been an abandonment of mining as defined under Wis. Stat. §
293.61.
b. Any suspension or revocation of a Local Agreement/Mining Permit,
whether in part or in full, shall require a majority vote by the County Board.
c. The County Board may delegate its authority to suspend or revoke a Local
Agreement/Mining Permit pursuant to this Section 13-1-25A(s)(6)(c) to the
County Planning and Zoning Committee. If the County Board delegates its
authority to the County Planning and Zoning Committee pursuant to this
Section 13-1-25A(s)(6)(c), any reference to the County Board in Section
13-1-25A(s) shall also include the County Planning and Zoning Committee.
(7) Suspension or Revocation of Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit.
a. Upon receipt of a notice of violation as set forth in Section 13-1-25A(s)(4)
and after giving notice and conducting a hearing if requested pursuant to
Section 13-1-25A(s)(4)(b), the County Planning and Zoning Committee
may suspend or revoke a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit for a
violation of this Ordinance or the terms of the Conditional Use
Permit/Mining Permit. A Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit may also
be revoked if it is determined after notice and a hearing that there has been
an abandonment of mining as defined under Wis. Stat. § 293.61.
Notwithstanding the terms of this Section 13-1-25A(s)(7), the County
Planning and Zoning Committee may suspend or revoke a Conditional Use
Permit/Mining Permit pursuant to the terms of Section 13-1-25A(s) if such
suspension or revocation is necessary to protect public health, welfare and
safety.
b. Any modification, amendment, suspension or elimination of a Conditional
Use Permit/Mining Permit, whether in part or in full, shall require a
60
majority affirmative vote by the County Board.
c. The County Board may delegate its authority to modify, amend, suspend or
revoke a Conditional Use Permit/Mining Permit pursuant to this Section
13-1-25A(s)(7)(c) to the County Planning and Zoning Committee. If the
County Board delegates its authority to the County Planning and Zoning
Committee pursuant to this Section 13-1-25A(s)(7)(c), any reference to the
County Board in Section 13-1-25A(s) shall also include the County
Planning and Zoning Committee.
(8) General Revocation Provisions Applicable to All Mining Permits. The
following shall apply to revocation of any Mining Permit:
a. Revocation of any Mining Permit shall terminate the Operator’s right and
authority to continue Mining Operations pursuant to this Ordinance but
shall not affect the Operator’s obligation to comply with any continuing
obligations of the Operator under the terms of the Mining Permit or any
agreement to which the County is a party.
b. Revocation of any Mining Permit shall not terminate any obligation set
forth in this Ordinance or in the Mining Permit, whether existing or a future
obligation, of the Operator or any Person associated with the Mining
Operation.
(9) Penalties. Any Person or Operator who violates this Ordinance or any of the
provisions contained herein shall forfeit not less than $10 or more than $10,000 for
each violation, as reasonably determined by the County Planning and Zoning
Committee. Each day of violation is a separate offense.
a. The County Planning and Zoning Committee shall, promptly after verifying
any violation of any provision of a Mining Permit, notify the Operator in
writing of such violation and require the Operator to report to the County
Clerk within 10 days.
b. The County shall be entitled to recover from the violator the reasonable and
necessary expenses associated with prosecution of the violation.
c. All funds recovered pursuant to this Section 13-1-25A(s) will be placed in
an assigned account established by the County and used at the County
Planning and Zoning Committee’s sole discretion consistent with achieving
the intent of this Ordinance.
d. The remedies provided herein shall not be exclusive of other remedies.
e. If the Operator fails to correct or cure the violation to the County Planning
and Zoning Committee’s satisfaction in accordance with any compliance
schedule approved by the County Planning and Zoning Committee, the
County Planning and Zoning Committee may revoke the Mining Permit
and commence legal action against the Operator for injunctive relief and
additional appropriate forfeitures.
61
(10) Non-Waiver. A failure by the County to take action on any past violation(s) shall
not constitute a waiver of the County’s right to take action on any present or future
violations.
(t) Effective Date and Revisions to Existing County Zoning Ordinance. This
Ordinance shall become effective as provided in Section 13-1-25A(c)(5) upon its adoption
and publication by the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors.
(u) Prohibited Areas. Metallic mining, and/or drilling for oil or gas shall not be
allowed in the following areas:
(1) Under lakes, rivers, creeks, or streams.
(2) Within one (1) mile of Lake Superior or connected wetlands.
(3) Within one (1) mile of any lake, river, creek, or stream.
Section 2. Except as specifically modified and amended by this ordinance, the Bayfield
County Code of Ordinance shall remain in force and effect exactly as originally
adopted and previously amended. All ordinances or parts of ordinances inconsistent
with or in contravention of the provisions of this ordinance are hereby repealed.
Section 3. SEVERABILITY. If a court of competent jurisdiction adjudges any section,
clause, provision, or portion of this ordinance unconstitutional or invalid, the
remainder of this ordinance shall not be affected thereby.
Section 4. EFFECTIVE DATE. This ordinance shall take effect and be in full force
from and after its passage.
Motion by Silbert, Strand to adopt Amendatory Ordinance No. 2019-08. Motion carried.
The Executive/Closed Session agenda item was moved to earlier in the meeting, in order for
Planning and Zoning Director Schierman to participate.
11. The Bayfield County Board of Supervisors may entertain a motion to move in and out of
Executive/Closed Session pursuant to: §19.85(1)(g) to confer with legal counsel for the
governmental body who is rendering oral or written advice concerning strategy to be adopted
by the body with respect to litigation in which it is or is likely to become involved.
Motion by Crandall, Milanowski to enter Closed/Executive Session at 7:04 p.m. Motion
carried.
The following were allowed to remain in Executive/Closed Session: County Administrator-
Mark Abeles-Allison; County Clerk- Scott Fibert; Planning and Zoning Director-Rob
Schierman; Clerk III- Allison Radke.
Discussion took place regarding the Red Cliff Zoning Lawsuit.
62
There being no further business to conduct in Executive/Closed Session, a motion was made
by Crandall, Zepczyk to return to Open Session at 7:24 p.m. Motion carried.
12. Bayfield County Resolution No. 2019-27; Request to Adopt the certified Bayfield
County Farmland Preservation Plan under s. 91.16, Wis. Stats.; Land Water
Conservation Department;
A background was provided regarding Resolution No. 2019-27, Request to Adopt the
certified Bayfield County Farmland Preservation Plan. This Resolution was reviewed and
recommended by the Land Water Conservation Committee.
WHEREAS, Bayfield County first adopted a Farmland Preservation Plan in 1982, which
was expired and needed significant updates; and
WHEREAS, the county’s Farmland Preservation Plan, as the name of the plan implies, is an
attempt to preserve agricultural land at the county-level, and allows for landowners that farm
land inside an Agricultural Enterprise Area to obtain tax credits on their agricultural land;
and
WHEREAS, the Bayfield County Land and Water Conservation Department in conjunction
with the Northwest Regional Planning Commission, Bayfield County Staff, and local
farmers, prepared a farmland preservation plan (FPP) that meets the requirements under s.
91.10(1), Wis. Stats.,
WHEREAS, the Bayfield County Land and Water Conservation Department requests that
under s. 91.16, Wis. Stats. that the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors adopt the Farmland
Preservation Plan for Bayfield County, Wisconsin, as presented;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Bayfield County Board of
Supervisors, meeting this May 28th, 2019, adopt the Farmland Preservation Plan for Bayfield
County, Wisconsin, as presented.
Motion by Strand, Milanowski to approve Resolution No. 2019-27, requesting to adopt the
certified Bayfield County Farmland Preservation Plan. Motion carried.
13. Bayfield County Resolution No. 2019-28; Request to Amend the 2019 UW-Extension
Budget to account for receiving two 4-H Grants; UW-Extension, Bayfield County;
County Administrator Abeles-Allison gave information regarding Resolution No. 2019-28 which
involves UW-Extension receiving two 4-H Grants. The 4-H grants are for the summer youth
program, which is now named Superior Adventures. The two grants together total $4,500.
WHEREAS, the Bayfield County UW-Extension Office has received a grant, which will
start on March 27, 2019 and end on August 31, 2019, from the Apostle Island Area
Community Fund, an Affiliate of the Duluth-Superior Area Community Foundation in the
amount of $4,000 and a grant from the Wisconsin 4-H Foundation in the amount of $500 for
the program “Potential Adventures Through 4-H”.
WHEREAS, the 2019 Bayfield County UW-Extension 292 budget needs to be amended to
reflect these increases and expenses:
63
Revenue Accounts to increase for a total of: $ 4,500
# 292-25-48516-001 Potential Adventures Grant Revenue in the amount of: $ 4,500
Disbursement Accounts to increase for a total of: $ 4,500
# 292-25 -55636 - 50290 Contractual Services in the amount of: $ 2,118
# 292-25 -55636 - 50332 Mileage in the amount of: $ 900
#292- 25- 55636- 50340 Operating Supplies in the amount of: $ 1,482
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors
assembled this 28th day of May 2019, does hereby amend the 2019 292-UW-Extension
budget to reflect the increase in revenues by $ 4,500 and the increase in expenditures by $
4,500.
Motion by Newago, Crandall to approve Resolution No. 2019-28, a request to amend the 2019
UW-Extension budget to account for receiving two 4-H Grants, with a change in two account
numbers. A roll call was taken as follows: Newago-yes, Gordon-absent, Fickbohm- yes,
Oswald-yes, Silbert-yes, Pocernich-yes, Strand-yes, Snilsberg-absent, Milanowski-yes,
Zepczyk-yes, Crandall-yes, Rondeau-absent, Maki-yes. (10-yes, 0-no, 3 absent) Motion carried.
14. Bayfield County Resolution No. 2019-29; Request to Amend the 2019 UW-Extension
Budget, Hazelnut-Finished Pork Grant; UW-Extension, Bayfield County;
County Administrator Abeles-Allison explained Resolution No. 2019-29, a UW-Extension
budget amendment accepting a Hazelnut-Finished Pork Grant. It was reviewed and
recommended for approval by the UW-Extension Committee. This grant amounts to $39,777.
WHEREAS, the Bayfield County UW-Extension Office has received a grant from the
Northern Central Sustainable Agriculture Research & Education (SARE), University of
Minnesota, for the Project “Hazelnut-Finished Pork in the Upper Midwest: A New High-
Value Product from a Sustainable Production System” which will start on March 15, 2019
and end on March 31, 2021.
WHEREAS, the 2019 Bayfield County UW-Extension 292 budget needs to be amended to
reflect these increases and expenses:
Revenue Accounts to increase for a total of: $39,777
# 292-25-43570-014 - Hazelnut Finished Pork SARE Grant in the amount of $39,777
Disbursement Accounts to increase for a total of: $39,777
# 292 - 25 - 55654 - 50290 Contractual Services in the amount of: $37,308
# 292 - 25 - 55654 - 50332 Mileage in the amount of: $1,045
#292 - 25 - 55654 - 50336 Lodging in the amount of: $ 424
#292 - 25 - 55654 - 50340 Operating Supplies in the amount of: $1,000
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors
assembled this 28th day of May 2019, does hereby amend the 2019 292 UW-Extension
budget to reflect the increase in revenues by $ 39,777 and the increase in expenditures by $
39,777.
64
Motion by Strand, Fickbohm to approve Resolution No. 2019-29, requesting to amend the
2019 UW-Extension budget for a Hazelnut-Finished Pork Grant. A roll call was taken as
follows: Newago-yes, Gordon-absent, Fickbohm- yes, Oswald-yes, Silbert-yes, Pocernich-yes,
Strand-yes, Snilsberg-absent, Milanowski-yes, Zepczyk-yes, Crandall-yes, Rondeau-absent,
Maki-yes. (10-yes, 0-no, 3 absent) Motion carried.
15. Bayfield County Resolutions No. 2019-30; No. 2019-31; No. 2019-32; No. 2019-33; No. 2019-
34; No. 2019-35; No. 2019-37; No. 2019-38; Wisconsin Counties Association Resolutions;
Please address Resolutions as one motion.
Information was provided regarding the following eight Wisconsin Counties Association (WCA)
Resolutions by County Administrator Abeles-Allison. They are being proposed to the WCA for
legislature consideration.
a) Resolution to Increase the Payments to Towns with County Forests from $.30 to $2.00
per acre;
An increase in payments to Towns with County Forests is a topic that has been discussed
by Bayfield County for many years.
WHEREAS, the State of Wisconsin has 29 Counties with 2.4 million acres of County
Forest Land;
WHEREAS, County Forest lands are entered under Wisconsin State Statute 28.11 County
Forest Law, which outlines the framework for County Forest Management;
WHEREAS, Wisconsin State Statute 28.11 requires compensation and a reasonable
revenue to Towns;
WHEREAS, The State currently provides a payment of $.30 per acre to local units of
government containing County Forest lands. This amount was established in 1989 and has
not increased in 30 years;
WHEREAS, payments for National Forest lands are approximately $2.00 per acre to local
units of government;
WHEREAS, these payments to towns help maintain forest roads providing access into the
county forest;
WHEREAS, the DNR is willing to consider a budgetary fix to this issue; and
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors
Assembled this 28th Day of May 2019, supports an increased PILT payment to Counties
with County Forest Lands to $2.00 per acre.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors
Assembled this 28th Day of May 2019, recommends that the Wisconsin Counties
Associations does hereby urge the State Legislature to increase the Acreage Share
Payment to towns with County forest lands, to $2 per acre.
65
b) Action to address the Mental Health Epidemic in County Jails;
This Resolution encourages working with Jail and Sheriff staff to help ensure that inmates
receive medications while in jail and to reduce the mental health impact on communities.
WHEREAS, the number of individuals with mental health issues in county jails has
exploded over the past decade; and,
WHEREAS, those with mental illness need specialized care and attention;
and,
WHEREAS, demands on local correctional institutions is greater than can be sustained;
and,
WHEREAS, this workload and case type is overwhelming jail staff.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Bayfield County Board of
Supervisors assembled this 28th day of May 2019, do hereby request that WCA Support
Legislation addressing mental health issues in county jails including:
• That individuals on psychotropic medicines before incarceration be allowed to
continue while in jail, with no interruption to funding of those medications if the
individual is currently enrolled in a state program which provides that resource.
• That increased state DOC funding be made available for crisis intervention utilizing
licensed mental health professionals that hold prescribing licensure.
c) Action to support Legislation Funding Additional Assistant District Attorney
Positions;
This item, which would fund an Assistant District Attorney, is currently being proposed in
the legislature and is supported by Bayfield County District Attorney Kimberly Lawton.
WHEREAS, District Attorneys are the gatekeeper for cases at the Circuit Court Level; and
WHEREAS, Multiple studies have shown that County District Attorneys are overloaded
and unable to maintain existing caseloads, and
WHEREAS, overloaded result in delayed and less effective sanctions as time elapses; and
WHEREAS, legislation considered in SB 54, 2017 address the ADA shortage; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Bayfield County Board of
Supervisors assembled this 28th day of May 2019, do hereby request that WCA Support
Legislation addressing Assistant District Attorney Shortages.
d) Support Expansion of Wisconsin Department of Corrections Opening Avenues to
Re-Entry Success (OARS) to the entire state of Wisconsin;
66
Wisconsin offers this re-entry program through the Department of Corrections in 44
Counties in the Southern part of the State. It provides additional case-management once
individuals leave prison. Bayfield County is asking that the program be extended to this
region as well.
WHEREAS, the OARS program enhances public safety by supporting the successful
transition, recovery and self-sufficiency of offenders with mental health needs as they
reintegrate into the community.
WHEREAS, this is a vision and effort that should be supported and encouraged by every
county in the state.
WHEREAS, OARS enhances public safety by reducing recidivism and revocation rates.
WHEREAS, People released from incarceration often face difficulty finding housing and
employment. Those on OARS have opportunities before and after release to plan,
reducing the chance of relapse into unhealth lifestyles.
WHEREAS, OARS is currently available in 44 Counties in the State of Wisconsin.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Bayfield County Board of
Supervisors assembled this 28th day of May 2019, do hereby request that WCA supports
expansion of the OARS program to the entire state of Wisconsin.
e) Volunteer Emergency Medical Response;
Senator Bewley wrote this legislation, proposing to provide tax credits and incentives for
Volunteer Emergency Medical Responders.
WHEREAS, Bayfield County is a very rural area with less than 10 people per square
mile; and,
WHEREAS, a large portion of the Ambulance, Emergency Medical and Fire Response
within the county is volunteer; and,
WHEREAS, Increasingly, rural areas like ours are having more and more difficulty in
recruiting and retaining volunteer emergency responders, resulting in longer response
times; and,
WHEREAS, Increasingly, neighboring services are called upon to respond in these
emergency situations because of the shortage of local volunteers; and
WHEREAS, AB 142 and SB 135 have been created to introduce non-refundable tax
credits for volunteer emergency responders, and
WHEREAS, the first credit equals $20 for each hour an individual who volunteers spends
on active duty, in training or in class. The second credit equals the volunteers
unreimbursed expenses. The maximum an individual may claim a year is $1000 and $400
respectively.
67
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Bayfield County Board of
Supervisors assembled this 28th day of May 2019, do hereby request that WCA Support
this Legislation in order to make volunteering more attractive and financially affordable.
f) Medicaid Expansion;
Two Resolutions were submitted addressing increased Medicaid funding. Both versions
support additional funding, with different terminology. Both Health Director Wartman
and Human Services Director Skulan were supportive of either option, with a
consideration to include additional funding for the Counties. There was a discussion
regarding the two Resolution versions and Version 2 was chosen as Bayfield County
Resolution 2019-35. The title was discussed, and it was recommended to change it to:
Human Services/Health Services Expansion. It was also decided to remove the phrase
Medicaid Expansion from the Resolution.
Bayfield County supports increased human services and health services funding for
Wisconsin residents. Bayfield County supports state expansion of services with some
dollars coming back to counties to accommodate workload increases in Economic
Support/Income Maintenance Consortium.
WHEREAS, with services comparable to adjacent states an additional 82,000 Wisconsin
fewer residents could receive health care coverage who are currently underserved; and
WHEREAS, this service increase would improve the health, wellbeing and productivity
of thousands of residents in the areas of preventive care, prenatal care, opioid and other
drug treatment, behavioral health and crisis intervention, lead poisoning, treatment of
chronic disease, dental health and support people with disabilities thus providing for
healthier families and a more productive workforce; and
WHEREAS, most states in the country are providing services at this level resulting in
improved health care of their citizens; and
WHEREAS, Wisconsin has lost an amount exceeding $800 million over the last eight
years. This has not benefitted the health of Wisconsin’s citizens.
WHEREAS, the Wisconsin Department of Health Services projects a $325 million
savings from the increased service level.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that Bayfield County supports the adoption
of increased human services and health services as soon as can be implemented based on
humanitarian and economic grounds; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that funding from savings in
accepting the expansion be designated to the counties as recommended by the Wisconsin
Counties Human Services Association to accommodate a workload increase in Economic
Support/Income Maintenance Consortium.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Wisconsin Counties
Association consider adoption of this resolution as part of their policy platform.
68
g) Conduct Additional Research on Chronic Wasting Disease to Improve Testing,
Treatment, and Management Options;
This Resolution encourages additional research on Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) to
improve testing, treatment, and management options.
WHEREAS, Chronic wasting disease (CWD) is a serious disease of captive and wild
cervids and threatens to cause considerable economic, cultural, and ecological damage to
Wisconsin;
WHEREAS, A better understanding of CWD is needed to develop better management
tools;
WHEREAS, Current funding and research levels are not commensurate to the threat
posed by CWD;
WHEREAS, since its discovery in Wisconsin in a wild deer harvested in 2001 it is now
been found in wild deer in 26 counties and in 25 captive deer farms;
WHEREAS, the most heavily infected areas of Dane and Iowa counties the prevalence
rate in adult males is over 35 percent and in adult females is over 15 percent;
WHEREAS, the WI Department of Health the Center for Disease Control and the World
Health Organization all recommend that meat from cervids only be eaten from cervids that
have tested negative for CWD;
WHEREAS, in 2018 the DNR sold over 803,000 gun and archery deer hunting licenses to
over 750,000 Wisconsin residents and to over 53,000 non-residents;
WHEREAS, in 2011 hunting -related expenditures in Wisconsin totaled $2.5 billion in
2011. 88% of hunters participated in deer hunting, making it the most popular form of
hunting in the state.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors
Assembled This 28th day of May 2019, does hereby request that WCA urge the State
Legislature to direct state agencies and provide funding to conduct the following research
and development in order to better manage CWD:
• Develop a reliable, rapid, and easy to administer CWD test that can be conducted on
live cervids.
• Develop a reliable, rapid, and easy to administer CWD test that can be implemented
in the field on harvested deer and can provide immediate results.
• Develop a vaccine for CWD for cervids.
• Develop a cure for CWD infected cervids.
• Breed heritable resistance to CWD in captive cervids such that the cervids are both
asymptomatic and do not carry and shed prions.
69
• Determine CWD prion longevity and virulence in contaminated soil, feed, and crops
under a range of environmental conditions and soil types.
• Develop a better understanding CWD prion movement in the environment once
outside of a cervid.
• Expand monitoring of individual animal and herd health in CWD endemic zones to
better understand the effect of CWD on population dynamics.
• Conduct epidemiological assessment of CWD prions on human health including
whether humans are already carriers of CWD prions, the likelihood of CWD prions
infecting humans and causing disease, and the impact of eating CWD positive deer,
if any.
• Conduct additional research to determine viability and methodology for composting
CWD infected cervids.
h) Enact Stronger Regulations to Limit the Spread of Chronic Wasting Disease;
With this Resolution, Bayfield County is requesting that WCA support stronger regulations in
Wisconsin to limit the spread of CWD.
WHEREAS, Chronic wasting disease (CWD) is a serious disease of captive and wild cervids and
threatens to cause considerable economic, cultural, and ecological damage to Wisconsin; CWD is
a fatal, neurological disease of cervids;
WHEREAS, since its discovery in Wisconsin in a wild deer harvested in 2001 it is now
been found in wild deer in 26 counties and in 25 captive deer farms;
WHEREAS, the most heavily infected areas of Dane and Iowa counties the prevalence
rate in adult males is over 35 percent and in adult females is over 15 percent;
WHEREAS, the WI Department of Health the Center for Disease Control and the World
Health Organization all recommend that meat from cervids only be eaten from cervids that
have tested negative for CWD;
WHEREAS, in 2018 the DNR sold over 803,000 gun and archery deer hunting licenses to
over 750,000 Wisconsin residents and to over 53,000 non-residents;
WHEREAS, in 2011 hunting-related expenditures in Wisconsin totaled $2.5 billion in
2011. 88% of hunters participated in deer hunting, making it the most popular form of
hunting in the state;
WHEREAS, with no known cure or vaccine, the only option currently available to
manage CWD is to aggressively limit the transmission and spread of CWD;
WHEREAS, current regulations do not adequately limit human assisted transmission of CWD.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, The Bayfield County Board of Supervisors
Assembled this 28th day of May 2019, does hereby request that WCA urge the State
Legislature to make the following changes to State Statutes and concordant Administrative
Rules:
70
• Change ATCP 10.56(1) to eliminate exceptions that allow transport of live cervids
without a Certificate of Veterinary Inspection.
• Change NR 10.105(7) to prohibit the export of cervid carcasses which have any part
of the spinal column or head attached from CWD affected areas in which a wild or
captive cervid tested positive for CWD in the last 10 years.
• Enact new rules to require the disposal of harvested cervid carcasses in approved
landfills, rendering, or composting facilities.
• Enact new rules to prohibit the export of live cervid animals from areas within 10
miles of a known positive CWD detection within the last five years.
• Enact new rules to require all captive cervid operations to install solid perimeter or
double-fencing.
• Once a reliable live animal CWD test has been developed, enact rules to prohibit the
transport of live cervids unless the animal tests negative for CWD.
Motion by Crandall, Newago to approve Resolutions No. 2019-30; No. 2019-31; No. 2019-32;
No. 2019-33; No. 2019-34; No. 2019-35; No. 2019-37; No. 2019-38; Wisconsin Counties
Association Resolutions, with two changes in the Human Services/Health Services Expansion
Resolution. Motion carried.
16. Bayfield County Amendatory Ordinance No. 2019-09; Amendment to Section 2-3-1,
Designation of Standing Committees in Bayfield County Code of Ordinances, Wisconsin;
The Executive Committee discussed this Amendatory Ordinance. Amendatory Ordinance No.
2019-09 will help Committees reach a quorum. There was a discussion regarding the importance
of regular Committee meetings and the commitment that County Board members make.
WHEREAS, Wisconsin Statutes §59.03(2) provides that, except as elsewhere specifically
provided in the statutes, the board of any county is vested with all powers of a local,
legislative and administrative character; and
WHEREAS, Wisconsin Statutes §59.02(2) permits the enactment of ordinances by the
County Board of Supervisors; and
WHEREAS, Section 2-2-3, Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin, authorizes
County Board committees or individual supervisors to introduce proposed ordinances; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed to be in the best interest of the County of Bayfield to Amend
Section 2-3-1; and
WHEREAS, it is deemed to be in the best interest of the County of Bayfield that the Code of
Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin, be further modified and amended in the manner
hereinafter set forth.
NOW, THEREFORE, the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors does hereby ordain as
follows:
Section 1. Subsection (c) of Section 2-3-1 [Designation of Standing Committees.] of Chapter
3 [County Board Committees, Commissions and Boards] of Title 2 [Government and
Administration] of the Code of Ordinances, Bayfield County, Wisconsin is hereby created to
read as follows, with additions highlighted by the double underline feature (additions):
71
(c) The County Board Chair and County Board Vice-Chair will be ex officio members of all
Bayfield County Board Committees in the event any such committee does not have enough
members present to form a quorum. As an ex officio, the County Board Chair and Vice-Chair
can be used to meet a Committee quorum and as part of the Committee quorum have the
right to discuss, debate, make motions and vote on all matters before the committee. Only
one ex-officio committee member may be used to meet a Committee quorum.
If quorum is present without using the County Board Chair or Vice-Chair, as an ex officio,
the County Board Chair and Vice-Chair will not be considered ex-officio members of the
committee at that time .
Section 2. Except as specifically modified and amended by this ordinance, the Bayfield
County Code of Ordinance shall remain in force and effect exactly as originally adopted and
previously amended. All ordinances or parts of ordinances inconsistent with or in
contravention of the provisions of this ordinance are hereby repealed.
Section 3. SEVERABILITY. If a court of competent jurisdiction adjudges any section,
clause, provision, or portion of this ordinance unconstitutional or invalid, the remainder of
this ordinance shall not be affected thereby.
Section 4. EFFECTIVE DATE. This ordinance shall take effect and be in full force from and
after its passage.
Motion by Oswald, Fickbohm to approve Amendatory Ordinance No. 2019-09, Amendment to
Section 2-3-1, regarding the Designation of Standing Committee in the Bayfield County Code
of Ordinances. Motion carried.
17. Discussion and Possible Action regarding Industrial Development Agency Amendatory
Promissory Note Agreement and Memorandum of Understanding;
The promissory note agreement has expired. The agreement is between Bayfield County and the
Bayfield County Industrial Development Agency.
72
73
Motion by Newago, Maki to approve the Industrial Development Agency Amendatory
Promissory Note Agreement and Memorandum of Understanding. Motion carried.
18. Local Emergency Planning Committee (LEPC) Appointments: Gayle Gonsior; Marian
Schraufnagel; Erika Kurtz; Jack Hoiby;
Jan Victorson, Emergency Management Coordinator, would like to recommend these four
individuals: Gayle Gonsior; Marian Schraufnagel; Erika Kurtz; and Jack Hoiby to join the Local
Emergency Planning Committee.
Motion by Newago, Crandall to approve the appointments of Gayle Gonsior; Marian
Schraufnagel; Erika Kurtz; and Jack Hoiby to the Local Emergency Planning Committee
(LEPC). Motion carried with one abstention.
74
19. Bayfield County Resolution No. 2019-36; Authorizing an Additional $1.5 million for County
Highway A Reconstruction in 2019; Highway Department;
This Resolution had been discussed earlier in the meeting. It would authorize an additional $1.5
million for County Highway A reconstruction in 2019.
WHEREAS, County Highway maintenance is a top priority of the Bayfield County Board.
WHEREAS the 2019 budget includes funding for four miles of County Highway A reconstruction
from Fay Road to Hessey Road;
WHEREAS the 5-Year County Highway Plan identifies an additional six miles of reconstruction
on County Highway A in 2022 from Hessey to County Highway B;
WHEREAS the 6 miles of County Highway A from Hessey to County Highway B are in very
poor condition;
WHEREAS the Highway Committee has recommended that the County Board consider
reconstructing this entire section of County Highway A in 2019 rather than portions of the project
in two separate years;
WHEREAS the estimated cost for the additional 6 miles of reconstruction will require an
additional $1,500,000 in 2019;
WHEREAS the Bayfield County Highway Department has no available resources for this until
reimbursements from flood damages come in;
WHEREAS, Bayfield County currently has fund balance available in the general fund that could
be temporarily transferred to the highway fund;
WHEREAS, the Bayfield County Highway Department will pay back the County the first
$500,000 received in flood damage reimbursements.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors
assembled this 28th day of May 2019, does hereby approve an amendment to authorize the transfer
of $1,500,000 from the General Fund Balance to the Highway Fund and to proceed with paying
back Bayfield County $50,000 in 2020 from flood reimbursement.
Increase General Fund Balance applied account 100-00-49301 by $1,500,000
Increase Transfer to Highway account 100-00-57910-50998 by $1,500,000
Increase Transfer from General Fund account 710-71-49201 by $1,500,000
Increase CTH Special Projects 710-71-53314-50290 by $1,500,000
Motion by Maki, Milanowski to approve Resolution No. 2019-36, authorizing an additional
$1.5 million for County Highway A reconstruction in 2019, with one correction to a figure in
the Resolution. A roll call was taken as follows: Newago-yes, Gordon-absent, Fickbohm- yes,
Oswald-yes, Silbert-yes, Pocernich-yes, Strand-yes, Snilsberg-absent, Milanowski-yes,
Zepczyk-yes, Crandall-yes, Rondeau-absent, Maki-yes. (10-yes, 0-no, 3 absent) Motion carried.
75
20. Bayfield County Administrator’s Report:
a) Future County Board Meeting Dates:
✓ June 25th, 2019
✓ July 30th, 2019
✓ August 27th, 2019
b) Annual Picnic (12:00, Wednesday, June 19) and Board Training with Jon
Hochkammer, WCA Outreach Manager, Board Roles and Responsibilities, 1:15 p.m.;
Following the picnic, there will be a Board Training at 1:15 p.m.
c) Cervid Study Committee Informational Meeting: Wednesday May 29, 6:30 p.m. Great
Lakes Visitor Center;
The Cervid Study Committee held a public informational meeting on May 29th. Following
the meeting, the Committee will discuss findings and finalize the report. The Cervid Study
Committee will present on June 25th at the next Bayfield County Board meeting.
d) Opioid/ Meth/ Substance Abuse Epidemic in Bayfield County;
There was discussion regarding the efficacy of the programs. A significant cost of the
epidemic is foster care. There will be more information at the June County Board meeting.
e) High School Senior, Local Government Scholarships;
County Board Supervisors presented four scholarships at various local schools.
f) County Highway N Update;
It remains closed. There is work being done.
21. Supervisors’ Reports;
The Cervid Committee is having an informational meeting on May 29th. The new Red Cliff
Recreation pamphlet is being distributed now.
22. Future Agenda Items; None identified.
23. Adjournment.
There being no further business to come before the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors’,
Chairman Pocernich adjourned the meeting at 8:05 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Scott S. Fibert
Scott S. Fibert, Bayfield County Clerk
SSF/alr