The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About25-0074<^A-000^1 P-VFIELD PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT i^1^ Ij ^ IS AUG117 E 5th SMet PO Box 58 Washburn, wrSWl'd (715)373-6138 permits (EObayfieldcountv.wi.gov www.bayfieldcounty.wi.gov/zoning / it!j/ ^!l!lf;lJ ', )unty Use Only: Zoning District: ^^\ Shoreland: Y®-<> Notices SentQTy/^fFee Paid: &ll^Z^ Cf2<o02S^o Agenda Item: ^ Meeting Date: I Units'.2.S-W7TPermitff:zs- .00 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT APPLICATION Property Owner: L Lueth Holding Company, INC Telephone Number: 651-398-1595 E-Mail Address: lllueth@yahoo.com Mailing Address: 912 South State Street City, State, Zip: New Ulm MN 56037 Contractor (if applicable): Danula Construction Authorized Agent (if applicable): Robert Schierman Telephone Number: 218-260-0928 E-Mail Address: Pawnmanrob@gmail.com Mailing Address: PO Box 122 City, State, Zip: Herbster Wl 54844 Telephone Number: 715-919-0329 E-Mail Address: DDanuta@gmail.com Project Address (if different from mailing address): 21470 Blueberry Lane Cornucopia Wl 54827 Legal Description (use Tax Statement or Deed): 2 Parcels in Gov Lot 2 & 3 Da.<^ '^ ^ ^o<- Z02-zg_- c^lo3<o2- Section, Township, Range: Section 33 Township 51 N Range 6W Tax ID #: 37575 Town of: Bell Lot Size (Acres/Square Feet): 2.927 Acres Classification of Uses Request (see Bayfield County Sec. 13-1-62): Multiple Structures 13-1-33(a) Briefly state what is being requested and why (if needed attach additional sheet): Requesting a Conditional Use Permit for a second residence on Tax ID 37575 as existing residence is not habitable in winter months. Please include the following with this application OR it will be returned for completeness: C$f Site Plan, minimum 8 '/2"xl 1 "/maximum 11 "xl7", that includes north arrow, dimensions of lot(s), proposed/existing structures with dimensions and number ofstories/floors, parking area and other areas associated with proposed use. NOTE: All structures to be associated with proposed use need to be included or a future application will be required. [S Town Board Recommendation form (Do not give to Town Clerk, form must be sent by Zoning Department) "8 Appropriate Fee(s) - see fee schedule "B. $30 check payable to Reg. of Deeds E^l Copy of recorded Deed(s) ID) K "1 iS N " F l^ 'Hi , . . ., ,. iiiU AUL- ! .;/'Jr. ''-' Have you consulted with the Zoning Department prior to applying for this permit? Q YES D NO If NO, it is highly recommended that you consult with the Zoning Department before submitting the apptkiation. ; .:i! ; ; .! I (we) declare that this application, including any accompanying information, has been examined by me (us) and to the best of my (our) knowledge and belief it is true, correct, and complete. I (we) acknowledge that I (we) am (are) responsible for the detail and accuracy of all information that 1 (we) are providing and that will be relied upon by Bayfield County in determining whether to issue a permit. I (we) further accept liability which may be a result ofBayfield County relying on this information I (we) are providing in or with this application. I (we) consent to county officials charged with administering county ordinances to have access to the above- described property at any reasonable time for the purpose of inspection. I (we) further acknowledge that receiving Zoning Committee approval does not allow the start of business or construction, I (we) must first obtain permit(s) from the Zoning Department. I (we) am aware that all structures involved with this application will require an individual land use application and fee and any changes involved with this application after issuance will require additional approval and issuance. Owner/s or Authorized Agent Printed Name: Lc^ey Lynn Lueth, Registered Agent Owner/s or Authorized Agent Signature: ^ .C\]TUJIS^^-*^_ _ Date: °/1- NOTE: If a single property owner is acting on behattof multiple property owners or a designated agent is signing on behalf of the owner(s), a letter of authorization must accompany this application. Address to Send Permit: PO BOX 122 Herbster Wl 54844 300-foot public notice map TOWN OF BELL FRED J &TAMARA L SCHLICHTING D N R STATE OF WISCONSIN 21590 BLUEBERRY LN 101 S WEBSTER ST CORNUCOPIA, Wl 54827 MADISON, Wl 53707 MICHAEL P & STEPHANIE J DORAN KEYES, PHILIP J TRUSTEE JOHNSON, LYNNE S & DAVID R WESTPHAL 3116 EVERGREEN RD MARGARET M TRUSTEE TRUSTEES AMESJA50014 1739 JULIET AVE 1351 HEATHER COURT ST PAUL, MN 55105 CHANHASSEN, MN 55317 M&J FANTA LEGACY LLC FRED J SCHLICHTING L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC 15484UPTONRD 21590 BLUEBERRY LN 912 SOUTH STATE ST EAST LANSING, Ml 48823 CORNUCOPIA, Wl 54827 NEW ULM, MN 56073 Bayfield County, Wl 9/11/2024, 11:26:35 AM Flood Plain Boundaries Active Dec 16th, 2011 AE. »*-- Wetlands Rivers Road Type '~~ Town Lake Superior Shoreline Recession Sagments= r.:rc:=w"-~—""•--—. Building Foolprtnt 2015 * Building bayffeld_gls.SOE.T_Bell Index Intemedlate 0 0 0.01 0.03 1:1,380 0.03 0.05 0.06 mi 0.1km BayfieU County Land Records Department .Bayne!dc°""t>'z°"inaAPP«raUonhttp5://m^8.bayflel<ta>un^J.goveml^'B; Surface Water Data Viewer Map Legend I I Wetland Indicators Ponds/Open Water Lake Class Areas Riverine/ditch Class Areas Wetland Class Areas Wetland Class Points /^ Dammed pond Rvj Excavated pond Filled/drained wetland Wetland too small to delineate Jjjj Filled excavated pond ^// Filled Points r-j Wetland Class Areas Filled Areas • Wetland Identifications and Confirmations * NRCS Wetspots Railroads I 0.1 0.03 0.1 Miles NAD_1983_HARN_Wisconsin_TM 1: 1,980 DISCLAIMER: The information shown on these maps has been obtained from various sources, and are of varying age, reliabiiity and resolution. These maps are not intended to beused for navigation, nor are these maps an authoritative source of information about legal iand ownership or public access. No warranty, expressed or implied, is made regarding accuracy,applicability for a particular use, completeness, or legality of the information depicted on this map. For more information, see the DNR Legal Notices web page; http://dnr.wi.gov/iegal/ Notes L Lueth Holdings CUP 3]'"^ss&m 1»,r ;N^'!8N^ 'ira'miffRmn <uEa(EDSES3 y BOOSESBfiiroSlBSaiBE)SBlEDiEOS 8/15/2024, 6:06:40 PM Override 1 Lake Superior 1 2 Building Footprint 2009-2015 Bdsting New Meander Lines Unknown Approximate Parcel Boundary Wetlands L I Section Lines Rivers - Government Lot Tie Lines I—I Municipal Boundary All Roads Town Survey Maps UnRecorded Map Driveways 0.02 1:1,566 0.04 0.07 mi 0.03 Bayfield 0.06 0.12 km Bayfield County Land Records Department https://maps.bayfieldcounty.wi.gov/BayfieldWAB/ .' ~ J .= = 1 C- ^ i i— ^7 ; ^ : < c ;' C ^ ~ d ~ . 7 : 1: 1 0 - 1 /^ F .{ ' c S ^ T : - C - / ' - - - - - _ v : ll ?Sl5 5 ' g^ i i |s?t^t EBNiu t S 2j^ 6 -I : ^ Is l l l F3 » * . a d '' i • np7AI i - U j; /U ®^u;)\^i^/ P "VFIELD PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT AUG 117 E 5th Street PO Box 58 ;: : Washburn, Wl 54891 (715)373-6138 £ermits@)bavfieldcounty.wi.xQy www.bayfieldcounty.wi.Rov/zoning 62t)76 County Use Only: Zoning District: 'R.-l Shoreland: Yes Fee Paid: Refund: Permitff: Date: LAND USE PERMIT APPLICATION Property Owner Name:L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC Telephone Number:651-398-1595 E-Mail Address: lllueth@yahoo.com Mailing Address: 912 South State Street City, State, Zip:Mew Ulm MN 56037 Contractor; Danula Construction Authorized Agent Name (if applicable): Robert Schierman Telephone Number;218-260-0928 E-Mail Address: Pawnmanrob@gmail.com Mailing Address: PO Box 122 City, State, Zip: Herbster Wl 54844 Telephone Number: 715-919-0329 E-Mail Address: DDanula@gmail.com PROJECT LOCATION Project Address (ifdiiferent from mailing address): 21470 Blueberry Lane Cornucopia Wl 54827 Legal Description (if additional space is needed, attach a separate sheet): ? Parcels in Gov Lot 2 & 3 ^e^^ \n ^oc. l.o?_9 R.- Scl(o^2 Section, Township, Range: Section 33 Township 51 N Range 6W Tax ID #: 37575 Town of: 3ell Lot Size (Acres/Square Feet): ?.927 Acres PROJECT DESCRIPTION (check all that apply) Proposed Use: E Residential D Commercial D Municipal Proposed Project: El New Construction D Addition/Alteration D Change/New Use D Relocate (existing structure) D Temporary (12 or less months, does not apply to RV placement) Structure Type: E Residence/Principal Structure D Detached Garage D Boathouse (one story only) D Open-sided/Screened Structure (gazebo, etc.) D Stairway to navigable waters D Sign D RV Placement a Shipping Container D Shoreland Grading (Class A) D Other (explain): Foundation Type: D Basement D Walkout Basement B Slab D Crawlspace D Ground D Skids D Other (explain): Proposed Sign is: D New D Replacement D On-premise D Off-premise D 1-sided D 2-sided D On-building D Multi-Tenant Length: Width: Height: Proposed RV is: D New D Replacement Year: Vin #: Make: Model: PROPOSED PROJECT AREA • Area to nearest square foot of outside dimensions including unfinished area, attached garages and above grade decks or porches (does not apply to Signs or RVs) Basement;NA Other: 1st Floor: 1272 Loft: Total Square Footage: 1272 2"d Floor:3rd Floor: Overall Height (finished grade to peak): 16 1^^L.^^}0^~ SITE PLAN \W~ I 'U ZU/.i v '- v ^ ^--\A^ ^-y ^y y\ r f t f f ^ f^ / ff ^^^ L^-^ REQUIRED (PLEASE COMPLETE BELOW)County Use Only Overall footprint (including eaves/overhangs) Verified overall footprint All applicable setbacks (include on site plan too)Verified setbacks Road Centerline/Right-of-Way Notes/Comments North Lot Line South Lot Line .Sfiplic/HeUifig-Fank Existing Structure/Building Elevation ofFloodplain Ordinary High-Water Mark (OHWM) NOTE: Please indicate "see attached" on this page if submitting site plan as a separate document. AUG U.?-!<;< FLOOR PLAN Indicate Floor: D Basement ^ 1st Floor D Loft D 2nd Floor D 3rd Floor D Other €P^ ^ \\-Q.C^1^ All applicable dimensions need to be shown on the floor plan and noted below Floor without attached exterior components with Porch 1 with Porch 2 with Deck 1 with Deck 2 with Attached Garage with Other (explain); Entry Dimensions (in feet) 30 x 32 x x x x 10 x Square Footage 960 sq.ft. 60 sq.ft. 192 sq.ft. sq.ft. sq.ft. sq.ft. 60 sq.ft. County Use Only Dimensions (in feet) x x x x x x x Square Footaee sq.ft. sq.ft. sq.ft. sq.ft. sq.ft. sq.ft. sq.ft. Comments/Notes: NOTE: Please indicate "see attached" on this page if submitting floor plan/s as a separate document. LAND USE PERMIT APPLICATION REVIEW • AU6i6Z0^1 1) Will this be the first structure on the site? D Yes B No !„ , ,,!; 2) What is the total number of bedrooms on the property once tin's project is complete i _? 3) Is there a proposed/existing sanitary system on the property? D Proposed - Type_ B Existing - Typecitysewer 4) Will any of the following occur within the proposed project/structure? E New Electrical Installation 13 New Plumbing Installation B Sleeping 5) Has the location of the proposed project been staked including structure, sanitary system, and well? B Yes D No 6) If required, who marked the property lines? D Applicant/Property Owner El Licensed Surveyor 7) Is the property in the shoreland, within 300 feet of a river/stream/jandward side offloodplain or 1000 feet of a lake/pond/flowage? B Yes D No D Unsure 8) Is there wetland located on or near the property? E3 Yes D No D Unsure 9) Is there floodplain located on or near the property? 0 Yes D No D Unsure 10) Is this project associated with any of the following: D Rezone B Conditional Use D Special Use D Variance 11) Did you contact the town to see if any permits/requirements apply to your project? E] Yes D No The following items are included with the application: B Site Plan B Building Elevations ^ •S>4~A c l- -* E Floor Plan/s <\U & t- ^ -l B Fees All Land Use Permits expire Two (2) Years from the date of issuance if construction or use has not begun. Sanitary Permit, if required, issuance needs to occur prior to Land Use Permit issuance. Failure to obtain a permit or starting construction without a permit will result in penalties. The local Town, Village, City, State or Federal agencies may also require permits. The construction of one- & two-family dwellings and new plumbing/electrical installation for residential use structures (accessory/principal) require review and approval by the local Uniform Dwelling Code (UDC) authority. All municipalities are required to enforce the UDC. If subject property is part of a Condominium Plat, applicant hereby certifies and represents that applicant has all necessary approvals and recorded documents required to complete the project for which this permit is sought including requirements set forth in Wisconsin statutes pertaining to condominium associations, the Declaration of the Condominium Association in which the property is located, and all other rules, regulations and requirements pertaining to that Condominium Association. You are responsible for complying with state and federal laws concerning construction near or on wetlands, lakes, and streams. Wetlands that are not associated with open water can be difficult to identify. Failure to comply may result in removal or modification of construction that violates the law or other penalties or costs. For more information, visit the Department of Natural Resources wetlands identification web page, dnr.wi.BOV/topic/wetlands, or contact a Department of Natural Resources service center (715)685- 2900, I (we) declare that this application, including any accompanying information, has been examined by me (us) and to the best of my (our) knowledge and belief it is true, correct, and complete. I (we) acknowledge that I (we) am (are) responsible for the detail and accuracy of all information that I (we) are providing and that will be relied upon by Bayfield County in determining whether to issue a permit. I (we) further accept liability which may be a result ofBayfield County relying on this information I (we) are providing in or with this application. I (we) consent to county officials charged with administering county ordinances to have access to the above- described property at any reasonable time for the purpose of inspection. Owner/s or Authorized Agent Printed Name^ace^-ynn Lueth, Registered Agent Owner/s or Authorized Agent Signature: r-^ (\Vl,AjtS^^-—•— _ Date: NOTE: If you are signing on behalf of theo^neri[sy^ letter of authorization must accompany this application Address to Send pen... PO Box 122 Herbster Wl 54844 This building plan is intended to meet the intent of the Wisconsin Building Code. It is theresponsibility of all b-ades Involved to completely verify code compliance, The users of this planreleases the designer from any claims or lawsuits that may arise during the construction or anytimethereafter. Every effort has been made in preparing these plans and checking them for accuracy.The drawings are provided "as is" w?out warranty of any kind. TTie drawings may containomissions or other inaccuracies. The designer assumes no responsibility or liability of thesaomissions and any incidental, indirect or consequential damages whatsoever arising from the useof these drawings or the information provided therein. These drawings are intended for a qualifiedand competent trademen capable of determining the details required before, during and after construction. All persons involved shall verify all details, dimension and notes prior to commencement of workand to report any discrepancies to the designer for further edits. Roof and Ftoor system details to be verified and/or specified by the deslgner/supplier. It Is th(responsibility of the builder to verify all information provided by manufactured floor and roofsystems provider prior to construction. Any alterations specified by roof and floor designerssuperceed any information provided in these drawings I General Notes:I-All asssamblies and components tomanufacturers specific instructions.I-All dimensions are to rough framing unless otherwise noted.1-AII sizing of engineered lumber specified by suppliersupercedes sizing designated in these documents.1-AJI exterior walls to be 2"x 6- and all interior walls to be 2" x 4" unless otherwise noted.1-A11 exterior walls lo receive hausewrap. Housewrap1 be taped at all seams.-All eves and valleys to receive Ice and Water Shield. ]-Rash all window and door openings.I-Seal all wait and ceiling penetrations that connect to outside air.I-All guard rails to be min. 36-AFF. I-All baluslar spacing to follow the 4" sphere rule.I-Unless otherwise noted, include double trimmer studs onall openings greater than 5'-6" (assuming uniform loading)l-lnstall increased number of trimmer studs surtablB to carry pointloads above headered openings, (consult engineered plans)-unless othemnse noted all openings, in bearing walls, lessthan 4'-6'to receive (min.) 2-2'x 12° DF headers, (assumed uniform loadingmtess otherwise noted all openings, In bearing walls, greaterthan 4'-6" to receive (min.) 3-2"x 12" DF headers, (assumed uniform loading)-h fs tha sole responsibility of the specific trades, performingthere duties, to confirm that the information contained inthese documents completely complies with all local and statebuilding codes.|4WAC contractor to test and balance HVAC system and leaveinstructions for owner.[-All Electrical installations shall comply with the requirements ofWisconsin Administrative Electrical Code, Vol 2., ch SPS 316I-Design and installation of plumbing shall comply with the requirementsof the Wisconsin Plumbing Code. ch SPS 382 to 387property lines are assumed unless a certrfied surveymap has been provided-The contractor is to have all utility lines verified by therespecUve utilrty company. TTie contractor to have DiggersHotline perform a locate priorto any excavation.-The contractor to be make a reasonable attempt to locateany private utility lines, located on ste, priorto excavation C^b^ Drg.No. 21-11-862 \£~/^-^^M.. pia^,. T^os^s. Extremepasiirps Residential Construclion Planning 71470 State Hwy 137Ashland, WI 54806Office Mobile715-682-5019 715-209-3977 WWW.ExtremeMeasuresPlans.com .QTo0 IOT^ LU LU ^Qffl^0IllI0 ^^§i ^•<Q Cover zm%Q oT .3 06 Sc a l e : 1 / 4 " = 1 ' - 0 " AP P R O V E D : W R E CH E C K E D B Y : W R E DA T E : 0 8 - 2 3 - 2 0 2 2 Ca b i n a<3 0 ro sM ir&ffw.. Piffs^. lExtreme Mobile 715-209-3977 WWW.ExtremeMeasuresPlans.com AFFIDAVIT OF AUTHORITY (Corporation, LLC, etc.) PURPOSE. This Affidavit of Authority is used to certify the individual applying for a permit is authorized when the property is owned by a corporate/business entity. ) )ss. STATE OF WISCONSIN BAYFIELD COUNTY ) The undersigned affirms and states as follows: 1. Address of Subject Property: 2l4'?0 BlU<JoO^ LCMU- L.Lu^t-h MA)<^ C<. 0^rvbC^p«^L:) / 2. The Subject Property is owned by: (Name of Company) 3. The name(s) of the current President or Managing Member: i-^^^--^ i—*^.^- » \ 4. I certify that the comoanv named in oaraaraoh 2 is valid and in effect on the date sianed below. I am the duly appointed agent of the Company named above in paragraph 2, and I have the authority under the terms of said authorization to apply for permits from the Bayfield County Zoning Department concerning the Property described in paragraph 1. I further certify that the information and statements made within this affidavit are true, accurate, and complete to the best of my knowledge. 5. I am authorized by the above-named Company to apply for and bind the Company to the terms and conditions of any permit that may be issue by the Bayfield County Zoning Department. 6. By signing this affidavit, I attest that I am unaware of any known or unknown person(s) who would contest this application. I agree to indemnify Bayfield County or such person or legal entity sufferina a damaae resultina from anv illeaalities ofXre^aDDlication for oermit. Dated^ c\/nl^ Subscrjb@cf and/sworn to before me this day of b' f{) ^^/» ^ 20^.H fM ^ Laie^ LJU-C^ Print Nar ^\"nji"///^^^^^O^OTA/^ \1*^*^*1 Not&ry Public, My commission:.•±IJ County, Wisconsin .pLf^JL^,^A-.^BV'9.-^^a^ re ^ in' Office of the Minnesota Secretary of State Certificate of Incorporation ^ I \' InrM I, Mark Ritchie, Secretary of State of Minnesota, do certify that: The following business entity has duly complied with the relevant provisions of Minnesota Statutes listed below, and is formed or authorized to do business in Minnesota on and after this date with all the powers, rights and privileges, and subject to the limitations, duties and restrictions, set forth in that chapter. The business entity is now legally registered under the laws of Minnesota. Name: File Number: L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. 490236100061 Minnesota Statutes, Chapter: 302A This certificate has been issued on: 05/22/2012 ^^M^TU^ ^^ Mark Ritchie Secretary of State State of Minnesota '•'•unjma\ ^ <^^QT^^^ MINNESOTA SECRETARY OF STATE MINNESOTA BUSINESS CORPORATION ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 302A Filing Fee S 160.00 49023610006 ^ I!: I? II I !i: IS AUG 'i 6,02/l ,'.oi.in' READ THE INSTRUCTIONS BEFORE COMPLETING THIS FORM. The undersigned incorporator(s) is an (are) individual(s) 18 years of age or older, aad adopts the following articles of incorporation: Note: A professional corporation governed under Chapter 319B must include an attachment with the following information: (This information is only required if this is a professional corporation.) 1. Statement that the Minnesota firm elects to operate and acknowledges that it is subject to Minnesota Statutes, Chaptcr319B.01to319B.12. 2. List the professional service the corporation is authorized to provide under Chap. 319B, subd 19. ARTICLE I - BUSINESS NAME Name of Corporation: (Required) (Must include a corporate or professional designation in their name.) L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. ARTICLE U - REGISTERED OFFICE AND AGENT The Registered Office Address of the Corporation is: (Required) 16 N. Minnesota Street, New Dim, Minnesota 56073 %a®§^ Street Address (A PO Box by itself is not acceptable) The Registered Agent at the above address is: Lacey L. Lueth City State f-tt{ED ff(^ MAY 2 2 2012 'Y^U^78^nlujLSecretaiyofState 100 shares. (Must authorize at least one Agent's Name (A registered agent is not required.) ARTICLE II I-SHARES The corporation is authorized to issue a total of share.) ARTICLE IV - LNCORPORATORS I (We), the undersigned incorporator(s) certify that I am (we arc) authorized to sign these articles and that the information in these articles is true and correct. 1 (We) also understand that if any of this information is intentionally pr knowingly misstatc that criminal penalties will apply as if I (we) had signed these articles under oath. (Provide thejiapie^id address of each incorporator. Each incorporator must sign below. List the incorporators on an additional shee^f^o/have more than two, incorporators.) Karia Figueroa, 101 N. Brand Blvd., 11th Floor, Glendale, CA 91203 Incorporator's Name Street Address City State Signature Incorporator's Name Street Address City State Zip Signature List a name, daytime phone number, and e-mail address of a person who can be contacted about this form. Shikha Chand _ 323-962-8600 exl. 883 onlin8filings@l8galzoom.com Contact Name Phone Number E-Mail Address /'1<'/'1 L. '-; i-r: Letter of Authorization Bayfield County Planning & Zoning Department PURPOSE. This Letter of Authorization is used to authorize a single property owner to act on behalf of multiple property owners or a designated agent to act on behalf of the property owner/s. If multiple property owners, each property owner must submit this signed letter. I, Lacfiy Lufith _(property owner), authorize Rob Schierman (authorized agent) to submit a land use/r.up _ (Example: land use, special use, conditional use, rezone/map amendment, appeal, variance, text amendment, etc.) for the following described project (Example: construction of residence or other structure, short-term rental or other use change, etc.) nonstmntinn of rBsidsnnB _application on my behalf for the following described property: Legal description of subject property: Address of subject property: 21470 Blueberry Lane Cornumpia, Wl Signature 9/11/2024 Dated Document Number State Bar of Wisconsin Form 7-2003TRUSTEE'S DEED Documenl Name THIS DEED, made between Elizabeth L, Kleemeier as Trustee of The William R. and Dorothy M. Bechtel Revocable Trust ofJune 20 2005 _ (whether one or more), and L Lueth Holdine Company. Inc. .("Grantee," whether one or more), Grantor conveys to Grantee, without warranty, the following described real estate, together with the rents, profits, fixtures and other appurtenant interests, in BAYFIELD _ County, State of Wisconsin ("Property") (if more space is needed, please attach addendum); See the annexed Exhibit A. DANIEL J. HEFFNERBAYFIELD COUNTY, WIREGISTER OF DEEDS 2022R-596362 09/14/2022 10:32AMTF EXEMPT #:RECORDING FEE: $30.00TRANSFER FEE: $1,320.00 PAGES: 2 Recording Area Name and Return Address L.Lueth Holding Co., Iq^ 912 South State St. New Ulm, MN 56073 in; i fs; 17222-22 04-010-2-51-06-33-1 05-002-S Parcel Identification Number (PIN) li AUG 1 bZUZ^ T^'m U? !IJi Dated ^pk.rwh^ ^( ^t)<^- -(SEAL) The WiUiam R. and Dorothy M. Bechtel Revocable Trust of June 20,2005 L,A^- ^•^2^i-^w~~ ' Elizabeth L,Kleemeier, Trustee .(SEAL) _(SEAL)_.(SEAL) AUTHENTICATION Signature(s) authenticated on ACKNOWLEDGMENT STATE OF wa^v^Va^ioc^) )ss. .COUNTY ) TITLE; MEMBER STATE BAR OF WISCONSIN (If not, authorized by Wis. Stat, § 706.06) THIS INSTRUMENT DRAFTED BY: ATTORNEY MAX T. LINDSEY, SB#1112865 Personally came before me on T^( {0/2 ^- .• ..<,? ,..,"'/^. ," .'^'.••' '•:'y '•••the above-named Elizabeth L. Kleemeier -^-^-'- instrum^pt^Bid acknowledged the same. to me known to be the person(s) who executed thp fore^bitig '-^ '. '•: ^'u>. *"'". ^. Y^/;.^M ^'•:'.^. ^7^ e^^ ~~:^~.''' •.<"'" ANICH.WICKMAN&LINDSEY.S.C.,^^^ ~ Notary Public, State of ^^ ^My Commission (is permanent) (expires: (Signatures niny be nuthentlcntcd or acltnowledged. Bulh are not necessnry.)NOTE; THIS IS A STANDARD FORM. ANY MODIFICATIONS TO THIS FORM SHOULD BE CLEARLY IDENTIFIED. TRUSTEE'S DEED © 2003 STATE BAR OF WISCONSIN FORM NO. 7-2003 * Type name below signatures. Bayfield County Register of Deeds Document # 2022R-596362 Page 1 of 2 "A" Parcel 1: A parcel of land located in Government Lot Two (2), Section Thirty-three (33), Township Fifly-one (51) North, Range Six (6) West, Town of Bel), Bayfield County, Wisconsin, more particularly described as follows: Starting at the East 'A corner of Section 33; thence North 1°09' West, along the line between Sections 33 and 34, 176.4 feet; thence South 84°08' West 326.1 feet; thence South 87 °55' West 808,7 feet; thence North 87°35' West 601.2 feet; thence North 83 °34' West 457 feet; thence North 79°34' West 248.39 feet to an iron pipe which is the Point of Beginning. Thence North 1°09' West- 200 feet to an iron pipe. Thence North 1 °09' West 450 feet to the shore of Lake Superior. Thence Northwesterly along said shore 102,07 feet; thence South 1 009' East 380 feet to an iron pipe. Thence South 1°09' East 257 feet to an iron pipe. Thence South 79 °34' East 102.07 feet to the Point of Beginning, Being Lot 22 on the unofficial and unrccorded Plat made by Thomas W, Nelson, Registered Surveyor ofAshland, Wisconsin, under date of July 15, 1957 and entitled Siskiwitt Bay Subdivision. Parcel 2: A parcel of land located in Government Lots Two (2) and Three (3), Section Thirty-three (33), Township Fifty-one (51) North, Range Six (6) West, Town of Bell, Baylleld County, Wisconsin, more particularly described as follows: Starting at the East '/< corner of said Section 33; thence North 1°09' West, along the line between Sections 33 and 34, 176,4 feet; thence South 84°08' West 326.1 feet; thence South 87°55 West 808.7 feet; thence North 87 °35' West 601.2 feet; (hence North 83 °34' West 457 feet; thence North 79°34' West 350,46 feet to an iron pipe which is the Point of Beginning. Thence North 1°09' West 257 feet to an iron pipe. Thence North 1 °09' West 380 feet to the shore of Lake Superior. Thence Northwesterly along said shore 102,07 feet; thence South 1 °09'East 370 feet to an iron pipe, Tlwnce South 1 °09' East 256 feet to an iron pipe, Thence South 79 °34' East 102.07 feet to the Point of Beginning. Being Lot 23 on the unofficial and unrecorded Plat made by Thomas W, Nelson, Registered Surveyor ofAshland, Wisconsin, under date of July 15, 1957 and entitled Siskiwitt Bay Subdivision. Bayfield County Register of Deeds Document # 2022R-596362 Page 2 of 2 8/15/24,5:36 PM Novus-Wisconsin Access rev. 12.0206 Real Estate Bayfield County Property Listing Today's Date: 8/15/2024 ^*F' Description Tax ID: PIN: Legacy PIN: Map ID: Municipality; STR: Description: Recorded Acres: Calculated Acres: Lottery Claims: First Dollar: ESN: ^ Tax Districts 1 04 010 044522 001700 Updated: 10/28/2022 37575 04-010-2-51-06-33-1 05-002-82000 (010) TOWN OF BELL S33 T51N R06W 2 PAR IN GOVT LOTS 2 & 3 DESC IN DOC 2022R-596362 2.927 2.927 0 Yes 107 Updated: 7/14/2017 STATE COUNTi' TOWN OF BELL SCHL-SOUTHSHORE TECHNICAL COLLEGE property Status: Current^ ic !]'' I? li ¥ 1^)1 £ !1" !p. 1! it?-ls _!!!rJ{ • ' Creat^tiOn: 7/14/2017 3:33:20 PM I'i . i) 'ili AUG -i ;^0/4 1!-/; Ownership L LUETH HOUMWG COMPANY INKS Updated: 10/28/2022 NEW ULM MM Billing Address: Mailing Address: L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC INC 912 SOUTH STATE ST 912 SOUTH STATE ST NEW ULM MN 56073 NEW ULM MN 56073 Site Address * indicates Private Road 21470 BLUEBERRY LN Property Assessment 2024 Assessment Detail Code Gl-RESIDENTIAL 2-Year Comparison Land: Improved: Total: CORNUCOPIA 54827 Acres 2.927 2023 201,200 38,900 240,100 Updated: Land 201,200 2024 201,200 38,900 240,100 8/9/2018 Imp. 38,900 Change 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% * Recorded Documents 0 TRUSTEES DEED Date Recorded: 9/14/2022 a QUn- CLAIM DEED Date Recorded: 3/16/2017 B QUFT CLAIM DEED Date Recorded: 3/16/2017 Updated: 7/14/2017 2022R-596362 2017R-567601 2017R-567600 Property History Parent Properties 04-010-2-51-06-33-1 05-002-80000 Tax ID 7888 HISTORY a Expand All History White=Current Parcels Pink= Retired Parcels a Tax ID: 7888 Pin: 04-010-2-51-06-33-1 05-002-80000 Leg. Pin: 010107208000 37575 This Parcel T Parents ^Children https://novus.bayfieldcounty.wi.gov/access/master.asp?paprpid=37575 1/1 BJLy FIELD Bayfield county Planning & Zoning Department 117 E 5th Street P.O. Box 58 Washburn, WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-6138 Fax: 715-373-4010 Property Owner: L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC 912 SOUTH STATE ST NEW ULM, MN 56073 Description Conditional Use Permit Total: Payment Amount: Submission Number: CU-00087 Transaction Number: CU-00087-12189 Amount $500.00 $500.00 $500.00 Reference: 2602 Paid by: HOT MESS HOLDINGS LLC 86985 LENAWEE RD, HERBSTER, WI 54844 Payment Type: cheque Receipt of payment does not guarantee eligibility of permit and is not proof of issuance of a permit. CU-00087 SPECIAL USE B/CONDITIONAL USE REVIEW CHECKLIST 1) 1St Application is DATE STAMPED 2) [?? Is Zoning District filled in (upper right-hand comer of application) 3) J\| Is Shoreland filled in (upper right-hand comer of application) 4) IXT Copy of Recorded Deed(s) are attached a. All pages are needed 5) LM Copy of Tax Statement is attached 6) F^[ Property ownership on Recorded Deed/Tax Statement matches Application 7) y\\ Mailing Address of Applicant is filled out on Application 8) P< Agents mailing address is filled out (needed for sending meeting packet) on Application 9) ]><| Legal description on Deed matches Application 10) .fSJ Site Address/Tax ID is filled out on Application 11) -f\| Acreage Amount is filled in Application 12) P<1 Classification List is filled out on the Application 13) X^l Describe exactly what they are asking for on the front of Application 14) ^J Application is signed a. |_| If Authorized Agent signed, letter of authorization included b. |_| If ownership is Trust or business, affidavit of authority is included 15) Xl Town Recommendation is attached a. K\ Property Ownership is same as Application b. 1^3. Legal description is the same as Application c. W Site Address/Tax ID is the same as Application d. Kl Acreage Amount is same as Application e. [Xf Describe exactly what they are asking for on the front of form 16) J/><] Land Use is attached (if applicable) a. 1)<T Land use application is DATE STAMPED b. 1><j Legal description is the same as Application c. I_I Land Use Review Checklist completed 17) f)<| 3 00-foot public notice map and mailing labels is attached a. Include Tribal when they are within Reservation Land even though its privately owned 18) |^<J Aerial GIS Map with subject lot(s) outlined and adjacent property owners is attached 19) W Site plan is attached with the following information included: a. |>\| (North) is shown b. IKI Lot Dimensions are shown c. ^[ Existing or proposed buildings with dimensions and floors/stories are shown 20) |X| Application Fee Paid and \~~\ ATF is Paid (if applicable) a. ^>Q Land Use Fee is Paid (if applicable) |_| ATF is Paid (if applicable) b. ^ $30 Affidavit Fee Paid (Reg. of Deeds) 21) \yf Wisconsin Wetland Inventory Map is attached 22) |_| EIA is attached (if required) 23) Data Base has been reviewed to verify property is code compliant a. I I All Structures have been permitted b. D Sanitary Permitted_When? c. j No violations Sanitary, etc.) 117 E 5th Street B^FIEL]D wa^n,= (715)373-6138 PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT Fax: (715)373-0114 zoning@bavfieldcountv.wi.gov www.bavfieldcounty.wi.gov/zoning September 11,2024 Robert Schierman pawnmanrob@gmail.com RE: Conditional Use Permit and Land Use Permit Applications for Tax ID #37575 and associated with Submission CU-00087 and LU-01270 Mr Schierman: The following comments need to be addressed for your applications to move forward. Conditional Use Permit application: ^L Need completed affidavit of authority for Lacey Leuth to solely act on behalf of the LLC. Department will make copy and include with Land Use Permit application. Need completed letter of authorization for Robert Schierman to act on behalf of the LLC. Department will make copy and include with Land Use Permit application. ^ Note the department will autogenerate the town board recommendation form based on the information you provided on the application. See attached form that was autogenerated. ^) Confirm that department staff can add the following to the legal description on the application, "DESC IN DOC 2022R-596362". ^^ Note that the property is zoned R-l not R-RB as the town board recommendation submitted states. ^ WTiat are the dimensions of the existing cabin and how many stories is it? Confirm that department staff can add this to the site plan. ^\[ Is the existing cabin still being utilized as a short-tenn rental? Is the existing cabin connected to the sanitary district? Land Use Permit application: ^» Confirm that department staff can add the following to the legal description on the application, "DESC IN DOC 2022R-596362". 2) Need completed impervieus surface form. r\o+- r<ac^^'\r~&c^ ftZ-^ SS,) Due to printing, information on the floor plan and elevations are missing. Can you provide copies that do not have white streaks, so all information is legible? 4) Provide letter from sanitary district official approving connection to public sanitary system. Required prior to permit issuance. ^ Need review fee in the amount of $979 (Land Use Permit application review fee 1272 sq fit x $0.75/sq ft=$954) + fIfflpCTVTOTrs-Snrt5ce'l1orm review fee = $25). -^cY r<.c^u^edl ^L\\ Sincerely, Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department ec: lllueth(%yahoo.com and ddanula(%gmail.com Conditional Use Permit application: 1) Completed affidavit of authority for Lacey Leuth submitted 9/18/2024. 2) Completed letter of authorization for Robert Schierman submitted 9/18/2024. 3) Noted.-.Zoning to generate TBA. 4) The department staff can add "DESC IN DOC 2022R-596362" to the legal description. 5) NotecL.the property is zoned R-l. 6) The dimensions of the existing cabin are 43' x 33' 1 story. Yes, the department staff can add this to the site plan. 7) The existing cabin is still being utilized as a short-term rental (in the summer as it seasonal). 8) The existing cabin Js connected to the sanitary district Land Use Permit application: 1) The department staff can add "DESC IN DOC 2022R-596362" to the legal description on the application. 2) Do not need completed impervious surface form per RH email dated 9/16/2024. 3) New plans submitted 9/18/2024. 4) Letter from sanitary district confirming connection to public sanitary system forthcoming. 5) Review fee of $954 (1272 sq ft x $0.75/sq ft=$954) submitted 9/18/2024. Ruth Hulstrom From: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 15, 2024 3:44 PM To: Ruth Hulstrom Cc: lllueth@yahoo.com; ddanula@gmail.com Subject: Re: CUP request - Multiple Structures on Tax ID 37575 Sounds good. On Tue, Oct 15, 2024 at 3:40 PM Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@)bayfieldcounty.wi.gov> wrote: Rob, It does not need to happen prior to Thursday's meeting but we would need the site better staked or someone to show staff where the proposed location of the structure will be prior to issuing the Land use permit. Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zoning Department 117 E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washburn,WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-3514 Fax:715-373-0114 Email: ruth.hulstroiTi(a),bavfieldcount\7.wi.&ov B-WFIKLD From: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 15, 2024 3:32 PM To: Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@bavfieldcounty.wi.gov> Cc: lllueth@yahoo.com; ddanula@gmail.com Subject: Re: CUP request - Multiple Structures on Tax ID 37575 I would be happy to meet on-site and review. Would you like this to happen prior to Thursday's meeting? Rob On Tue, Oct 15, 2024 at 2:02 PM Ruth Hulstrom <rulh,_hulstrom@>bayfieldcounty.wi.gov> wrote: Rob, Department staff went to the site yesterday to inspect the setbacks and found a single red flag and a tree that was spray painted near the site identified for the proposed development. Were there any other markers placed to stake the area that we missed? Or could you meet us at the site to outline the entire project area? Thanks, Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zonmg Department 117 E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washbum,WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-3514 Fax: 715-373-0114 Email: ruth.hulstroiTi(%bayfieldcount\'.wi.cov BAyFJRLD From: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, October 10, 2024 11:46 AM To: Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom(5)bavfieldcountv.wi.gc>y> Cc: lllueth@vahoo.com; ddanula@gmail.com Subject: Re: CUP request - Multiple Structures on Tax ID 37575 That is in the works. I know the LU Permit can't be issued until it is filed with the Department. On Thu, Oct 10, 2024 at 11:43 AM Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@ibayfieldcounty.wi.gov> wrote: Understood. Do you have documentation from the sanitary district authority that the second residence will be able to connect to the sanitary district yet? Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zoning Department 117E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washburn,WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-3514 Fax: 715-373-0114 Email: ruth.hulstrom(%bayfieldcount\r.wi.eoY BAyFIJSLD From: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, October 10, 2024 9:20 AM To: Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@bayfieldcounty.wi.gov> Cc: lllueth@yahoo.com; ddanula@gmail.com Subject: Re: CUP request - Multiple Structures on Tax ID 37575 Section 13-1-61 (m) (m) UVOD Unincorporated Village Overlay District. (A)10/29/2013) (1) The Unincorporated Village Overlay District is created to accommodate the land use patterns of those established unincorporated villages where, in order to ensure development consistent with the intent of this Chapter, special provisions shall be applied. (2) The Unincorporated Village Overlay District shall encompass the lands contained in the Villages of Drummond, Cornucopia, Iron River, Herbster, Grand View. and Port Wing as these boundaries are delineated on the orders creating these respective sanitary districts created under the provisions of Ch. 60.3. Wis. Stats, and on file at the Register of Deeds Office. (3) This District shall also include the property included within the Cable Sanitary District service area in Section 18-43-7, in the Town of Cable, and any lands in Bayfield County that are within a Sanitary District Service area. On Wed, Oct 9, 2024 at 4:15 PM Ruth Hulstrom <rMhJwistrom_@b_ayfMd^_oyjityM.^ov^ wrote: Follow up question, you have indicated that the second residence will be 49 feet from centerline and 16 feet from right-of-way. The requirement is 63 from centerline and 30 feet from right-of-way, whichever is greater. Is there a reason you have not met this requirement? Thanks, Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zoning Department 117 E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washbum, WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-3514 Fax: 715-373-0114 Email: ruth.hulstrom^bavficldcoun^.wi.eov EMyFIET.D From: Ruth Hulstrom Sent: Monday, September 16, 2024 8:57 AM To: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> Cc: lllueth@vahoo.com; ddanula@gmail.com Subject: RE: CUP request - Multiple Structures on Tax ID 37575 Rob, You are correct. Apologies for the error, the proposed development is beyond 300 feet of the OHWM so impervious surface is not required. Please disregard these comments. Thanks, Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zoning Department 117 E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washburn, WI 54891 Phone: 7-15-373-3514 Fax:715-373-0114 Email: i-uth.hulstrorn(2)bavfieldcount\r.wi.£ov B^yFIJSI.D From: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob(a>fimail.com> Sent: Thursday, September 12, 2024 2:58 PM To: Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@bayfieldcountv.wi.gov> Cc: lllueth@yahoo.com; ddanula@gmail.com Subject: Re: CUP request - Multiple Structures on Tax ID 37575 Good Afternoon Ruth, Can you please explain why an Impervious Surface Worksheet and associated fee are being required? If you look at the plan and survey you can clearly see that no structures exist or are being proposed within 300'of the OHWM. Rob On Wed, Sep 11 , 2024 at 3:08 PM Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@)bayfieldcounty.wi.gov> wrote: Rob, I realize I forgot to put a time on September 19th, we will need responses no later then 9 am on the 19th. Thanks, Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zoning Department 117E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washbui-n, WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-3514 Fax:715-373-0114 Email: ruth.hulstL-om(S),bayfieldcount\'.wi.sov B^yFJRT.D From: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, September 11, 2024 2:16 PM To: Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@bayfieldcountv.wi.Rov> Cc: lllueth@yahoo.com; ddanula@gmail.com Subject: Re: CUP request - Multiple Structures on Tax ID 37575 Thank you for your email, I will have the information for you ASAP. Rob On Wed, Sep 11 , 2024 at 1:41 PM Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@ibayfieldcounty.wi.gov> wrote: Rob, See attached Letter with comments related to the conditional and land use permit applications for Multiple Structures on Tax ID 37575. These comments need to be addressed no later then Thursday, September 19th for the request to have a chance of being added to the Planning and Zoning Committee meeting agenda for October 17th. I will be completing the on-site inspection for the applications end of this week or early next week and may have follow up comments. Let me know if you have any questions. Thanks, Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zoning Department 117 E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washburn, WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-3514 Fax:715-373-0114 Email: ruth.hulsti-oiTt^bayfieldcoun^.wi.eov B^yFIEI.D Ruth Hulstrom From: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 15, 2024 3:44 PM To: Ruth Hulstrom Subject: Re: 21470 Blueberry Lane I'll track that down On Tue, Oct 15, 2024 at 3:38 PM Ruth Hulstrom <mth,hulstrom@)bayfieldcounty.wi.gov> wrote: Rob, Can you provide a letter signed by Paul and not just a word document? Thanks, Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zoning Department 117E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washburn, WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-3514 Fax:715-373-0114 Email: ruth.hulstrom(a),bavfieldcountvr.\vi.eov BAy FIELD From: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 15, 2024 3:35 PM To: Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@bayfieldcountv.wi.gov> Subject: Fwd: 21470 Blueberry Lane Attached, in the email from the Town of Bell, is the Letter confirming that the proposed residence will be served by public sewer. Rob Forwarded message From: Bell Sanitary <betlsanitary(a)gmail.com> Date: Tue, Oct 15, 2024 at 1:45 PM Subject: Re: 21470 Blueberry Lane To: Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@)gmail.com> Good afternoon, This should satisfy Zoning, Lacey will have to fill out paperwork for a new hookup and be approved by the Board. The paperwork is available on our website. Bell Sanitary District, org. Pauline Colamatteo Business Manager Bell Sanitary District #1 On Thu, Oct 10, 2024 at 11:56 AM Robert Schierman <pawnmanrob@gmail.com> wrote: Good Morning Mark, I am working on a CUP application for Lacey Lueth for a 2nd residence on a parcel at the above referenced property. I need a letter from the Sanitary District confirming that a new residence at this location will be connected to the Sanitary District to submit to the Zoning Department. Can you please provide me with this required letter? The property information is as follows: 2 L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC NEW ULM MN 21470 BLUEBERRYLN CORNUCOPIA 54827 TAX I D 37575 Mail To (or I can pick up at your office) Robert Schierman PO Box 122 HerbsterWI 54844 An email copy of the letterwould be fine too. Let me know if you have any questions. RobSchierman 218-260-0928 R^yFIELD PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT 117 East Fifth Street PO Box 58 Washburn, Wl 54891(715) 373-6138 Fax: (715)373-0114 E-mail: zonincigDbavfieldcountv.wi.ciov Web Site: www.bavfieldcountv.wi.cfov September 25, 2024 L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY, INCC/0 ROBERT SCHIERMAN 912 SOUTH STATE STREET NEWULM, MN 56037 To Whom It May Concern: We are sending you this letter to advise you of the upcoming Bavfield County Planning and Zoning Committee Public Hearing and Meeting. This notice is also being sent to adjoining landowners; owners of land within 300 feet of the proposed use; the town clerk of the town in which the property is located, and the town clerk of any other town within 300 feet of the proposed use. This written notice is in regard to a Conditional Use Application for permit to place a second residence on the property submitted bv L Lueth Holding Company. Inc. owner and Robert Schierman, agent. To obtain information regarding this request: please visit our web site: http://www.bavfieldcountv.wi.aov/198/Plannina-Zonina-Committee. Scroll down to Agendas & Minutes. Click on Most Recent Agenda. This matter will be addressed by the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee at their meeting on Thursday. October 17. 2024 at 4:00 pm in the County Board Room of the Bayfield County Courthouse, Washburn Wisconsin. Be advised; the Town of Bell will consider this application prior to the Planning and Zoning Committee meeting (please call the Town Clerk to verify the date and time of their meetina and the date and time of the Plan Commission Meeting). If you wish to comment on this matter, you are invited to attend the hearing or write to the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department. If any person planning to attend this meeting has a disability requiring special accommodations, please contact the Planning and Zoning Department 24 hours before the scheduled meeting, so appropriate arrangements can be made. Note: Written and digital input pertaining to any agenda items will be accepted until noon the day prior to the Planning and Zoning Committee Meeting (Section 13-1-41(b)(1) and 13-1-41A(b)(2)). Subsequent input must be delivered in person at the meeting. Any aggrieved party may appeal the Planning and Zoning Committee's decision to the Board of Adjustment within 30-davs of the final decision. Sincerely, Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department enc. public hearing notice ec: MaryBeth Tillmansjown Clerk, PO Box 280, Cornucopia, Wl 54827 Robert Schierman, Authorized Agent, PO Box 122, Herbster, Wl 5484^ Adjacent Property Owners (7) Planning and Zoning Committee Members (Dropbox) Office File (Sent by Zoning) k/debsdata/zc/coverletter/conditionaluse/lluethholdingcompany-schiermanDAK/clo (9/25/2024-11:06am) Sent out: (9/25/2024) Application Packet (cover letter and notice) ** Please Note: Receiving approval from the Planning and Zoning Committee at the meeting does not authorize the beginning of construction or land use; you must first obtain land use application/Dermit card(s) from the Planning and Zoning Department. k/debsdata/zc/coverletter/conditionaluse/lluethholdingcompany-schierman DAK/clo (9/25/2024-11:06am) Sent out: (9/25/2024) BAYFIELD COUNTY PLANNING AND ZONING COMMITTEE OCTOBER17, 2024, AT 4:00 PJVI. BOARD ROOM, COUNTY COURTHOUSE WASHBURN, WISCONSIN The Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee of the County Board of Supervisors will hold a public hearing on Thursday, October 17, 2024, at 4:00 P.M. in the Board Room of the Bayfield County Courthouse in Washburn, Wisconsin relative to the following: G L Sandstrom Enterprises LLC, owner and Patricia Sandstrom, agent request a conditional use permit (in the shoreland w/wetlands present) to renew and continue operating the existing nonmetallic mine and for temporary crushing. Property consists of (2) parcels both in Forestry-1 zoning district; Parcel #1 is a 40-acre parcel (Tax ID# 22932), described as the SW % of the NE ^A, in Document # 2015R-557400 and Parcel #2 is a 40-acre parcel (Tax ID# 22959), described as the NW ^A of the SE 1A in Document # 2015R-557400, both in Section 27, Township 45 North, Range 5 West, Town of Lincoln, Bayfield County, Wl. Included in this request will be the reauirement(s) of the reclamation plan, which will be addressed separately. Mathv Construction Co, owner and Jefferv Johnson, agent request a conditional use permit to renew and continue operating the existing Nonmetallic Mine. Property is in a Forestry-1 zoning district; a 40-acre parcel (Tax ID# 19873), described as the SE % of the NE % in Document #2014R-554449, in Section 29, Township 47 North, Range 8 West, Town of Iron River, Bayfield County, Wl. Included in this request will be the reauirement(s) of the reclamation plan, which will be addressed separately. Donald & Tischa Ludzack, owner and Karl Kastroskv. agent are petitioning for a zoning district map amendment. The parcel is a 0.613-acre parcel (Tax ID #38479) described as a parcel in Lot 13, Block 12, Assessor's Plat No 2, in Doc #2021R-591658, Section 18, Township 43 North, Range 7 West, Town of Cable, Bayfield County, Wl from R-1 to R-4. Metes and bounds description(s) available on the Planning and Zoning Committee website (Agendas). L Lueth Holding Company. Inc., owner and Robert Schierman, agent request a conditional use permit (in the shoreland, w/wetlands present) to place a second residence on the property. Property is an R-1 zoning district; a 2.927-acre parcel (Tax ID# 37575), described as 2 parcels in Gov't Lot 2 & 3 in Doc #2022R-596362, in Section 33, Township 51 North, Range 6 West, Town of Bell, Bayfield County, Wl. Yellow B LLC, owner and Sandi Eberhard, agent are petitioning for a zoning district map amendment (in the shoreland w/wetlands present). Property consists of (2) parcels. Parcel #1 is a 3.0-acre parcel (Tax ID #27156), described as a parcel in NW 1A of the NE 1/4, in Doc#2023R-601044. Parcel #2 is a 5.75-acre parcel (Tax ID#27154), described as (2) parcels in the NE 1/4 of the NE 1/4, In Doc # 2023R-601044, both in Section 28, Township 48 North, Range 9 West, Town of Oulu, Bayfield County, Wl from R-2 to F-1. Metes and bounds description(s) available on the Planning and Zoning Committee website (Agendas). Immediately following the public hearing, the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee may approve, modify and approve, or disapprove the proposed items and/or proposed amendments and formulate and adopt its recommendations to the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors with respect thereto (if applicable). Copies of all items, petition(s) and/or proposed amendments are available online at (https://www.bavfieldcountv.wi.gov/198/PlanninQ-Zoninci-Committee). Scroll down to Agendas & Minutes. Click on Most Recent Agenda. All interested parties are invited to attend said hearing to be heard. Any person wishing to attend who, because of a disability, requires special accommodations, should contact the Planning and Zoning office at 373-6138, at least 24 hours before the scheduled meeting time, so appropriate arrangements can be made. Immediately after the public hearing, the Planning and Zoning Committee will hold its regular monthly meeting. If further information is desired, please contact the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department, at the Courthouse, Washburn, Wisconsin - Telephone (715) 373-6138 or visit ourwebsite: httD://www.bavfieldcountv.wi.gov/zoninci. Ruth Hulstrom, AICP / Director Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department k/debsdata/zc/phnotice/2024/#10oct17 Proofed by: REH Prepared by: dak (d)9/20/2024-1:57pm);(f)9/24/2024-8:40pm) Zoning Committee Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee Public Hearing and Public Meeting Thursday, October 17, 2024 4:00 P.M. Board Room, County Courthouse, Washburn, WI This meeting will be held in the Bayfield County Board Room. The public will be able to participate in the meeting in person or via voice either by using the internet link or phone number below. Microsoft Teams Meeting J oin the meeting now Meeting ID: 276 585 245 115 Passcode: sXNQVq Dial in by phone +1 715-318-2087,,889643791# United States, Eau Claire Find a local number Phone conference ID: 889 643 791 # Committee Members: Charly Ray-Chair, Fred Strand-Vice Chair, Dennis Pocernich, James Crandall, & Madelaine Rekemeyer 1. Call to Order of Public Hearing: 2. Roll Call: 3. Affidavit of Publication: 4. Public Comment - [3 minutes per citizen] 5. Review of Meeting Format - (Hand-Out Slips to Audience) 6. Public Hearing: (open for public comment) A. G L Sandstrom Enterprises LLC / Patricia Sandstrom (Lincoln) - reclamation plan B. G L Sandstrom Enterprises LLC / Patricia Sandstrom (Lincoln) - [Conditional Use] - continuation of non-metallic mine/temporary crushing in an F-l zoning district C. Mathy Construction Co / Jeffery Johnson (Iron River) - [Conditional Use] - reclamation plan D. Mathy Construction Co / Jeffery Johnson (Iron River) - [Conditional Use] - continuation of non-metallic mine in an F-l zoning district E. Donald & Tischa Ludzack / Karl Kastrosky (Cable) - [Rezone] - rezone property from R-l toR-4 F. L Lueth Holding Company Inc / Robert Schierman (Bell) - [Conditional Use] - second residence on a lot G. Yellow B LLC / Sandi Eberhard (Oulu) - [Rezone] - rezone property from R-2 to F-l 7. Adjournment of Public Hearing: 8. Call to Order of Planning and Zoning Committee Meeting: 9. Roll Call: k/debsdata/zc/agenda/#2024/#10octPrepared by: dak (d)9/20/2024-3:05pm);(f)9/23/2024-9:18am Proofed By: REH Zoning Committee 10. New Business: (public comments at discretion of Committee) A. G L Sandstrom Enterprises LLC / Patricia Sandstrom (Lincoln) - reclamation plan B. G L Sandstrom Enterprises LLC / Patricia Sandstrom (Lincoln) - [Conditional Use] - continuation of non-metallic mine/temporary crushing in an F-l zoning district C. Mathy Construction Co / Jeffery Johnson (Iron River) - [Conditional Use] - reclamation plan D. Mathy Construction Co / Jeffery Johnson (Iron River) - [Conditional Use] - continuation of non-metallic mine in an F-l zoning district E. Donald & Tischa Ludzack / Karl Kastrosky (Cable) - [Rezone] - rezone property from R-l toR-4 F. L Lueth Holding Company Inc / Robert Schierman (Bell) - [Conditional Use] - second residence on a lot G. Yellow B LLC / Sandi Eberhard (Oulu) - [Rezone] - rezone property from R-2 to F-l ll.Other Business D. Minutes of Previous Minutes: (September 19, 2024) E. Discussion regarding update on county short-term rental management after adoption of new zoning ordinance language F. Discussion regarding update on zoning code rewrite G. Committee Members discussion(s) regarding matters of the P & Z Dept. 13. Monthly Report / Budget and Revenue 14,Adjournment Ruth Hulstrom, AICP / Director Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department Note: Any aggrieved party may appeal the Planning and Zoning Committee's decision to the Board of Adjustment within 30-days of the final decision. Any person wishing to attend who, because of a disability, requires special accommodations, should contact the Planning and Zoning office at 373-6138, at least 24 hours before the scheduled meeting time, so appropriate arrangements can be made. Please Note: Receiving approval from the Planning and Zoning Committee does not authorize the beginning of construction or land use; you must first obtain land use application/permit cardfs) from the Planning and Zoning Department. k/debsdata/zc/agenda/#2024/#10octPrepared by: dak (d)9/20/2024-3:05pm);(f)9/23/2024-9:18am Proofed By: REH Zoning Committee ^- Planning and Zoning Committee BJLYFIELD StaffReport Meeting Date: October 17, 2024 Agenda Item: L Lueth Holding Company Inc / Robert Schierman (Bell) - [Conditional Use] - second residence on a lot Report Date: October 11, 2024 Prepared by: Ruth Hulstrom, AICP - Director Request Summary: L Lueth Holding Company, Inc., owner and Robert Schierman, agent are applying for a Conditional Use Permit to construct a second residence located on Tax ID 37575 in the Town of Bell, legally described as two parcels in Gov't Lot 2 & 3, hereinafter referred to as the subject property. The subject property totals 2.927 acres and is zoned Residential-1, R-l and located in the Shorelands with wetlands present. There is also floodplain running through the middle of the lot. An existing residence is located northeast of the proposed residence, approximately 70 feet. It is unfeasible to split the property and have each building located on a lot that meets the zoning dimensional requirements. Therefore, pursuant to Bayfield County Section 13-l-33(a), see below, a Conditional Use Permit is required to construct the second residence. (a) Multiple Residences. A conditional use permit shall be required for more than one (1) residence on a parcel of land, unless that parcel could be divided under the terms of the Bayfietd County Subdivision Control Ordinance with each building located on a resulting lot and meeting applicable setback requirements. No more than one residence may be located on a substandard lot. (®a)e/i?i976); (©3/28/2003); (A)9/30/2004); 8®3.»28/2006): (A)1/2a'200B);. (A)2/27;2D18) The Town of Bell recommended approval with the condition that only one residence can be utilized as a Short Term Rental. To date, six pieces of correspondence have been received in opposition or with concerns related to the request. Alternatives: 1) The Planning and Zoning Committee can approve a Conditional Use Permit to have two residences on an R-l zoning district for Tax ID 37575. 2) The Planning and Zoning Committee can approve with conditions a Conditional Use Permit to have two residences on an R-l zoning district for Tax ID 37575. 3) The Planning and Zoning Committee can deny a Conditional Use Permit to have two residences on an R-l zoning district for Tax ID 37575 due to substantial evidence that it does not meet Bayfield County Ordinances. Ivswssf r B^yFIELD PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT 117 E 5th Street PO Box 58 Washburn,WI 54891 (715)373-6138 permits@>bavfie!dcountv.wi.Rov www.bavfieldcountv.wi.Rov/zoning Count'!H<-N+'&d 1 fiCT 082024 HiiVNd f :o Znninq ijei r TOWN BOARD RECOMMENDATION (TBA) FORM Note: Receiving Town Board approval does not allow the start of construction or business. You must first obtain your permit(s) from the Zoning Department. The Zoning Department must send the TBA form to the town clerk, Property Owner: L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY Authorized Agent (if applicable)ROBERT SCHIERMAN Contractor (if applicable): DANULA CONSTRUCTION Su1^ectpr<wer)ytofi»i^at^ Property Address: 21470 BLUEBERRY LN INC Telephone Number: 6513981595 Telephone Number:2182600928 Telephone Number: 7159190329 Legal Description (use Tax Statement or Deed): 2 PAR IN GOVT LOTS 2 & 3 DESC FN DOC 2022R-596362 Section, Township, Range: S33-T51N-R06W Zoning District: R-l ^ReqiiiEStIn^raiatiign'^^1^ v% -'^ Requesting: D Special Use A D Other Town of: Bel] Shoreland Yes. Wetland Yes FIoodpiain No D Special Use B 0 Conditional Use Briefly state what is being requested and why (if needed attach additional sheet): Multiple Structures 13-I-33(a) - Requesting a Conditional Use Permit for a second not habitable in winter months. E-Mail Address: lllueth@yahoo.com E-Mail Address: pawnmanrob@gmail .corn E-Mail Address: ddanula@gm ai 1. corn Tax ID #: 37575 Lot Size (Acres/Square Feet): 2.927 ACRES :^i D Rezone D Subdivision Plat/Land Division residence on Tax ID 37575 as existing residence is Town Use Only: We, the Town Board, TOWN OF f^JUU _, do hereby recommend to: a Table ^Approval D Disapproval What is your reasoning for tabling, approval, or disapproval (if needed attach additional sheet)? ^U^L. l^fhjLSJS fSpQt^ AfAKl^^al^ OLfifV tr^oJ^ U}\44i. A{u.tr^l^io^ ^U^oL-f- f^JL^ rrv^t ^JL^L^^A^£. ^^^ IQA, U^hTn^Adf 0(,s o^ SkoT+T^^'nCi^AdaJ-.- Have you reviewed this for Compatibility with the Comprehensive and/orLand Use Plan?: ^» Yes D No Signatures: Chairman: Date: Return completed form to the Zoning Department Deb Kmetz I)M^^GT£ • da Idh. From: Sent: To: Subject: Vanden Langenberg, Susan K - DNR <susan.vandenlangenberg@wisconsin.gov> Thursday, October 3, 2024 8:55 AM Deb Kmetz RE: October (Planning and Zoning Committee) Meeting Hi Deb, Please let the committee know that no letters will be sent for the 10/17/24 Planning and Zoning Committee meeting. Thanks and have a good day! We are committed to service excellence. Visit our survey at httD://dnr.wi.eov/customersurvev to evaluate how I did. Sue Vanden Langenberg Cell Phone: (608) 843-3290 Susan.VandenlanRenberB@wisconsin.gov From: Deb Kmetz <Deb.KMetz@bayfieldcounty.wi.gov> Sent: Tuesday, September 24, 2024 1:20 PM To: Bonita Baltobelli (baltobelli@mesabidailynews.net) <baltobelli@mesabidailynews.net>; Daily Press (Jmcshane) <jmcshane@spooneradvocate.com>; Daily Press (presslegals@ashlanddailypress.net) <presslegals@ashlanddailypress.net>; The Daily Press, EditorDaily Press <pressnews@ashlanddailypress.net>; Jen Moritz <jmoritz@mx3.com>; ladena. chitwood@ecpc. corn (ladena.chitwood@ecpc.com) <ladena.chitwood@ecpc.com>; Linda Coleman <linda@washburnlawyers.com>; Mackenzie Kundinger <legals@ashlanddailypress.net>; Abeles-Allison, Mark <Mark.Abeles-Allison@bayfieldcounty.wi.gov>; Paul Gaier <paul.gaier@apg-wi.com>; Vanden Langenberg, Susan K - DNR <susan.vandenlangenberg@wisconsin.gov>; William (Bill) Sande - US Army Corp of Engineers (William.M.Sande(5)usace.army.mil)<William.M.Sande@usace.army.mil> Cc: Ruth Hulstrom <ruth.hulstrom@bayfieldcounty.wi.gov> Subject: October (Planning and Zoning Committee) Meeting CAUTION: This email originated from outside the organization, Do not click links or open attachments unless vou recoanize the sender and know the content is safe. Daily Press-Please confirm you received this email. Bill to Bayfield County Board of Adjustment (Acct 2002060) Attachment # 1 Public Hearing (Legal Notice). ** Reminder, notices are not to be published as a box and they are to be published in The Daily Press. Attachment ft 2 Publication Sheet - to be published October 3 and October 10. (For Daily Press Only). Please have Affidavit of Publication to our office by: October 14, 2024 V. (^ 2^ Attachment # 3 Agenda (Weekly meeting portion of the Press for Posting, not f<r Legal Notice for publication) 'Respectfiiffy, 'De6 De.fsbie. Xmetz, Office Manager Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Dept 117 E 5th Street P.O. Box 58 Washburn,WI 54891 (715) 373-6138 (715) 373-0114 (Fax) deb.kmetz@bavfielclcountv.wi.gov www. bavfieldcountv.wi.gov/147 Ruth Hulstrom F- From: Zoning Sent: Thursday, October 3, 2024 10:20 AM To: Ruth Hulstrom Subject: FW: Regarding proposed L Lueth holding company building site Trent Wiesner I Clerk I Planning and Zoning Department ll7 E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Phone: 715-373-3515 From: Jenny Doherty <jnnydoherty(a)yahoo.com> Sent: Thursday, October 3, 2024 9:47 AM To: Zoning <zoning@bayfieldcounty.wi.gov>; tosuper4(5)corni-wi.org Subject: Regarding proposed L Lueth holding company building site j You don't often get email from innvdoherty@vahoo.com. Learn why this is important To Whom It May Concern, This Letter is in regard to the proposed L Lueth Holding Company building a second residence on Blueberry Lane in Cornucopia,Wisconsin. I am first disappointed of the very late notice of this as we just received the Public Hearing Notice 2 days ago and we are supposed to respond to the Town of Bell Planning and Zoning meeting which is to be held today. I do not understand why this notice was so late as it was stamped received on August 16, 2024 in Bayfied County. I find this delay unacceptable and frankly, it leaves some questions as to the intent of the delay. Could it be so that less people on Blueberry Lane have time to respond to this matter? After looking over all the documents, my biggest concern is that this property will be used as a Short Term Rental. The current house on the property is being used as a Short Term Rental and we have had a few issues with that. I don't oppose Lueth Holding building a residence to live in but I do oppose building another Short Term Rental. The other objection I have is that the proposed build is very close to the Windswept property and is on the far edge of the lot. Can it be moved a bit closer to the original house and shed that is currently on the property? Thankyou foryour attention to this matter. Sincerely, Jeanette Fanta Doherty (248) 763-5048 M&J Fanta Legacy, LLC 21240BlueberryLane CornucopiaWI Yahoo MailforiPad ^n.^Trent Wiesner V: From: Kevin Roberts <robe0453@alumni.umn.edu> !hi l!:; fr) Is' II \W !g in\]ii1 K [\J] 'fi II I'f;' i'", !!|;Sent: Thursday, October 3, 202412:54 PM |^ '" VJ " ' "' " j||! To: tobsuper4@cornywi.org || f]p'j- q '^ y'n'^ il' Cc: Zoning Subject: Concerns about approval of additional house constructidrt;i(?feBJuiebefit5yiiLi?tne •,; You don't often get email from robe0453@alumni.umn.edu. Learn why this is important Hi Jackie, I heard about the proposal to receive approval for another house on the former Bechtel lot, and I wanted to send the following letter to voice my concerns. I am working and can't make the meeting itself, but I hope the below will be considered before final approval is recommended. ec to Bayfield County Planning and Zoning At the upcoming planning meeting, a variance in support of an additional residence on the property adjoining 21470 blueberry lane will be discussed. I would like to state my opposition to this plan. The owner, Lacy Lueth, proposes to build an additional house, although another home cannot technically be accommodated based on existing regulations.There is already one house on the property, but it has been converted into an Airbnb. The owner has already demonstrated a desire to inject short term rental housing into Blueberry Lane. Regardless of their stated intent, I have every expectation that this new house will similarly be used as a short- term rental. If the variance is approved and the house is built, nothing will prevent this from happening. Given the existence of an Airbnb on the other side of the lot - and the fact that the owner already possesses multiple properties in the area - this is hardly a stretch. The presence of an Airbnb on blueberry lane, although legal, has already altered the landscape and caused consternation on the part of the surrounding residents: • Local property owners are stewards of the beach, the lake, and the natural wetlands that surround this area. We care for this area and have a vested interest in its preservation. Short term renters have no long-term consideration for the impact they have on the local environment, and act accordingly. • I especially worry about the renters lighting fires on the beach, something that requires a degree of care and awareness that is rarely found in Airbnb guests. An ill-tended fire at the wrong time can quickly get out of control and cause a catastrophe for all of us. Renters having beach fires is already a common occurrence at the existing Airbnb. • Airbnb guests are frequently loud, obnoxious, and are up late drinking and partying in an area that is usually exceedingly quiet. Sound carries extremely well in this area, particularly on the beach, and the revelry can often be heard for great distances. I doubt the guests are even aware of how much they are disturbing the local residents; those who aren't familiar with the area wouldn't know or appreciate how well sound carries here. T Ttt°l^tx • A longer-term concern of mine is the ability of locals to walk up and down the beach. This is technically trespassing per riparian rights, but the owners have long allowed individuals to freely walk the beach because it is something we all enjoy. This was fine when it was primarily property owners, families of property owners, and local residents, because it fostered a sense of community. But those walking the beach are increasingly people from out of town - and out of state - who have no connection whatsoever to the local area. Airbnbs, especially multiple Airbnbs, further accelerate this trend. All it takes is one property owner to grow tired of the intrusion and enforce their rights by posting 'no trespassing' signs, and the ability to walk the beach is lost to all of us. If this comes to pass - which I increasingly see as inevitable, given the current trajectory - it will impact local Cornucopians who are not Blueberry Lane property owners as much as it impacts the owners themselves. While owning and operating short term rentals in Wisconsin is obviously legal, it's time to have a conversation about what this portends for the local residents, the blueberry lane property owners, and the environment. I have serious reservations about the plan to build a house on the proposed lot, and fear that it will further .destabilize the balance between these local interests. Thank you for hearing my concerns, |D} ^ ^ ^ U ^ ^ P, OCT 03'ZO'Z4 Kevin Roberts »^,f;^, ... /,„-,„„, ;,^,.rtaytielo i-.o. /'ornny ijep''Property owner on Blueberry Lane , - .....-, ft IAy2- Trent Wiesner l • [CJ ^ U HE OCT 06/'024From: Marie Versen <mjversen@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, October 6, 2024 11:00 AM Hayiielri i;f!. .''nmnci Dyp' To: Zoning Subject: Opposition to the conditional use permit for a second residence on Blueberry Lane in Cornucopia You don't often get email from mjversen@gmail.com. Learn why this is important Marie and Robert Versen 21800BlueberryLane Comucopia, WI, 54827 mj versen(%gmail .corn 612-616-2229 October 5, 2024 Bayfield County Zoning Committee Planning and Zoning Department 117 E. 5th Street Washbum, WI 54891 Dear Members of the Bayfield County Zoning Committee, I am writing to express my opposition to the conditional use permit application submitted by L. Lueth Holding Company and Robert Schierman for the placement of a second residence on their property located on Blueberry Lane in Comucopia. It is my understanding that this second residence is intended for rental purposes, and I have significant concerns regarding the potential impacts this could have on our community and environment. Firstly, one of the primary issues is the increased risk of wildfires. With the property being located along the shoreline and wetlands—areas highly vulnerable to environmental changes—the placement of a second residence that will be used for rental heightens this risk. Rentals often see fluctuating occupancy, and when renters are not present, there is a strong likelihood that the property may be left unattended, increasing the potential for campfires or other fire sources to be improperly managed. This raises a serious concern for the safety of nearby properties and the broader community, especially during the drier seasons when fire hazards are significantly higher. Secondly, the increased traffic in the area is another point of concern. The addition of a rental property will likely result in a noticeable rise in the number of vehicles and visitors, leading to greater wear on the local roads and increased noise in what is traditionally a quiet, residential area. This influx of traffic could negatively impact the character of the shoreline and wetlands, disturbing wildlife and detracting from the natural beauty that so many residents and visitors value. Moreover, the environmental sensitivity of wetlands cannot be overstated. Any development, particularly one that encourages transient use, could have long-term negative consequences on the delicate ecosystems that exist there. The wetlands play a crucial role in water filtration, flood control, and providing habitat for local wildlife. Further development could disrupt these important functions, leading to detrimental environmental effects that would be difficult to reverse. V:3«>Ti-In conclusion, I urge you to carefully consider the potential consequences of grantinglthi? conditional use permit. The increased risk of wildfires, the strain of additional traffic, and the environmental threats to the shoreline and wetlands are significant concerns that must be weighed against any potential benefits of this project. I strongly oppose the placement of a second residence for rental use in this sensitive area and request that the committee deny this permit. I will not be able to attend this meeting due to a prior commitment. Thank you for your time and consideration of my concerns.Q I E II 11 [n^Sincerely, Marie and Robert Versen I! OCT QuZUZ4 ^ayfieid Co^ Zoning Oepi r t III ^ !s !inijOCT 0/ZU24 i1'Nancy Jarvis 21160 Blueberr^Lan^ y^,^ ,,,, ^^, ,,„ Cornucopia,WI 54827 Bayfield Zoning Committee Planning and Zoning Department 117 East 5th Street Washburn,WI 54891 To: Bayfield County Zoning Committee I understand that there is a zoning change request on BLueberry Lane in Cornucopia, Wl. I am writing to voice opposition to the conditional use permit application submitted by L. Lueth Holding Company and Robert Shierman for a second residence on their Blueberry Lane property. The purpose of this permit appears to be the addition of rental(s) on the property, and I believe this will have detrimental impact on our road and Blueberry Lane community. The current lot size requirement on Blueberry Lane was increased from 100 to 150 feet, so this is only a single lot size of two hundred feet. There should only be a single residence on that size Lot. The owners already use the current residence for rental, so it is highly likely that they could be adding a second rental unit to their property. This has noise, traffic and property value implications that are detrimental to the owners of Blueberry Lane. Renters often have different activities and norms than owners, who currently enjoy a quiet, multigenerational family approach when vacationing, rather than temporary, occasionally, high volume partying. There are certainly wetland concerns. Higher use will have higher impact on these precious wetlands. Renters may not have the care and concern with this unique ecosystem and will also potentially impact from wildfires when visitors who do not understand fire dangers want to enjoy a bonfire. We know this extremely well as there was a careless, and out of control file a few years ago that required emergency services and quite a bit of Blueberry Lane manpower to avoid disaster on adjacent residences. This was started by non-owners who were drinking heavily and did not understand that dry grass burns quickly across the beach and beach grass area. Please consider denying the request for a second residential unit which may be an additional rental unit on this single lot. I am not able to attend the meeting due to prior conflict. I appreciate the work you do for the county and the time you spend considering this. Cordially, Nancy Jarvis ^ issuiK Ill !,,':s ii-ZO^ F~ Charlie Fanta "" " -'vfii-ilri C>.^ ZuiiiiiQ l't-'^'M&J Fanta Legacy LLC i^~lwl v* """"'1 ' 15484UptonRd. E.Lansing, Ml 48823 October 9, 2024 To, Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department 117 E. Fifth Street P.O. Box 58 Washburn,WI 54891 Subject: L. Lueth Holding Company conditional use permit Dear Committee, I am writing about the Lueth conditional use permit for placing a second residence on the property located on Blueberry Lane in Cornucopia. Our main concern is that the new house would be used as a short term rental along with the existing cabin which is currently being used as an AirB&B. We already have occasional noise issues with the parade of people coming in and renting the place. Two short term rentals on that property would just be too much. Other concerns are: 1. Increased danger of fire during dry weather, (the forest on Blueberry Lane still has charred stumps of a large previous fire), 2. Possibility of strangers wandering on to our beach, and 3. The now existing issue of renters haphazardly having fires at multiple places on the beach. I am also upset with the placement of the house so close to the property line to the west, especially since there are other options on that double lot. To conclude, we would be in favor of the conditional use permit being denied. One last concern is that we received notification from Bayfield Planning and Zoning Committee two days before the Town of Bell Planning and Zoning meeting, giving us little time to respond or attend as our cabin is closed down for the winter. The timing gives the appearance that this issue was timed to attract as little attention from the community as possible. We would like consideration of the use permit delayed so that people on Blueberry Lane have time to be informed. Thank you. Sincerely, Charlie Fanta ^IVIarie and Robert Versen •^ ^ ^ ^ ,1 ly^ ^ 21800BlueberryLane |D| ^ ^ ^ ' ^ ^ Comucopia, WI, 54827 j| |j QQ^ Q • ,;; •/. .j c;-;;', ••n^f^i'n^ii-coiu 612-616-2229 '-:'"r'o!'1 ci)' 7""!i!tJ pe!IL October 5, 2024 Bayfield County Zoning Committee Planning and Zoning Department 117 E. 5th Street Washbum, WI 54891 Dear Members of the Bayfield County Zoning Committee, I am writing to express my opposition to the conditional use permit application submitted by L. Lueth Holding Company and Robert Schiermajn for the placement of a second residence on their property located on Blueberry Lane in Comucopia. It is my understanding that this second residence is intended for rental purposes, and I have significant concerns regarding the potential impacts this could have on our community and environment. Firstly, one of the primary issues is the increased risk of wildfires. With the property being located along the shoreline and wetlands—areas highly vulnerable to environmental changes—the placement of a second residence that will be used for rental heightens this risk. Rentals often see fluctuating occupancy, and when renters are not present, there is a strong likelihood that the property may be left unattended, increasing the potential for campfires or other fire sources to be improperly managed. This raises a serious concern for the safety of nearby properties and the broader community, especially during the drier seasons when fire hazards are significantly higher. Secondly, the increased traffic in the area is another point of concern. The addition of a rental property will likely result in a noticeable rise in the number of vehicles and visitors, leading to greater wear on the local roads and increased noise in what is traditionally a quiet, residential area. This influx of traffic could negatively impact the character of the shoreline and wetlands, disturbing wildlife and detracting from the natural beauty that so many residents and visitors value. Moreover, the environmental sensitivity of wetlands cannot be overstated. Any development, particularly one that encourages transient use, could have long-term negative consequences on the delicate ecosystems that exist there. The wetlands play a crucial role in water filtration, flood control, and providing habitat for local wildlife. Further development could disrupt these important functions, leading to detrimental environmental effects that would be difficult to reverse. In conclusion. I urge you to carefully consider the potential consequences of granting this conditional use permit. The increased risk of wildfires, the strain of additional traffic, and the environmental threats to the shoreline and wetlands are significant concerns that must be weighed against any potential benefits of this project. I strongly oppose the placement of a second residence for rental use in this sensitive area and request that the committee deny this permit. I will not be able to attend this meeting due to a prior commitment. Thank you for your time and consideration of my concerns. Sincerely, Lynne S and David R Westphal - Trustees/Property Owner 21450 Blueberry Lane Cornucopia, Wl 54827 RE: Conditional Use Application October 3, 2024 (^l»f2 OCT 1 4 2024 Bayfieid Cu. Zorrn^ W Dear Members of the Town of Bell / Cornucopia Planning Commission, the Bell town council and the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department, We are writing to strongly urge the denial of the Conditional Use Application by L. Lueth Holding Company, Inc. for a permit to place a second residence on the residential property described as 2 parcels in Gov't. Lot 2 & 3 in Doc #2022R- 596362, in Section 33, Township 51 North, Range 6 West, Town of Bell, Bayfield Coynty, Wl. If there is continued interest in the application after the scheduled October 17 public meeting, we also request that a final decision on this application be postponed until sufficient additional information can be obtained from other affected current property owners on Blueberry Lane. Despite the unusually short notice and rapid pace of this application process, there are already several concerned property owners, both those who received the County's notice and some who did not, who have expressed concern about the limited information they have received, the lack of specificity and conflicting information in the application itself and its attachments, and the negative impacts and property rights issues an approval is likely to generate. Among the concerns that have surfaced so far: * The proposed proximity of the structure to the existing neighboring property line will create an undue burden on the neighbors' right to the full enjoyment of their property. Noise from construction and occupation of the proposed residence, and the removal of existing trees and other vegetation will have a direct negative noise and visual impact on the neighboring property and will depress that property's potential resale value. * If this CUA is approved, it will set a negative precedent for similar unwanted develppments^ll along Blueberrv Lane. * What is / are the specific zoning or other issues thatj-eciuire the Conditional Use Aoplication? Our limited understanding of the general use of CUA's is that, among other things, a CUA is typically required because: there are hazards / problems inherent in the use itself, or there are special problems that its proposed location may present given the zoning of the property. Rather than speculate, we ask that these issues or problems be clearly communicated to all property owners on Blueberry Lane. * Further, we understand that general Conditional Use Permits typically require: 1. The proposed use must comply with all local ordinances. This hasn't yet been demonstrated to the residents of Blueberry Lane. 2. The proposed use must be compatible with all adjoining properties. This clearly is NOT the case when considering placing a residential structure only 24' from a neighboring property line that then has only approximately 10' additional feet to the neighbor's residence structure. The resulting noise from construction, placement of sanitary and other utilities and the sounds of occupation will place a huge burden on the existing property owners, and not just the adjacent property owners. The owner / residents of the proposed residence will also suffer these consequences. The removal of trees will damage the only existing noise and visual barriers between the existing and proposed structures. This will result in ongoing problems between neighbors that don't currently exist and that will likely require town involvement / moderation for years to come. It will also damage the neighboring property value. r n?^3. The proposed use must conform with the comprehensive land use plan of the community. Again, this hasrTt yet been demonstrated to the residents of Blueberry Lane. 4. The proposed use / structure must be served by adequate roads and public utilities. While a road already exists, will additional access / egress lanes be required? Will the proposal allow for septic / other equipment to be placed even closer than the proposed residential structure to the neighboring property line? * Will the proposed residence be allowed to be rented out as an 'AirBnB' similar to the existing structure on this property? If so, a second temporary rental on the lots owned by is a big concern due to the potential for large groups to combine (or have conflicts). If this property is to be a rental property, will there be an allowance for / prohibition of additional camping trailer(s), mobile home(s), tent(s), etc. to house additional guests during the time the structure is occupied? This has already occurred during our last visit to Blueberry Lane, though admittedly we do not know the status of the guests in the residence or trailer, other than that they all gathered / partied together. There is additional concern of any related ownership liability carried by renters of the property. * Why is this process proceeding at such an unusually rapid pace? Why have the handful of property owners who were informed not been provided more advance notice? The notices were only received in the mail on Monday 9/30 and Tuesday 10/l._Why is this CUA application process happening at a time when many of those affected are not in town? * Why have others along Blueberry Lane not been notified of this CUA, given that they may also be impacted by additional traffic, noise from construction and from the proposed structure's potential use as a second AirBnB type rental? Parking along the street of renter or visitor vehicles would also have negative impacts along the lane. These are not hypotheticals, because they have already occurred as a result of the existing rental structure, and have been noticed by others than just the immediate adjacent property owners. * Why is the interest of one recent property owner on Blueberry Lane being prioritized over the opposing interests of multiple property owners whose families have owned and paid taxes on their properties, supported the town and coexisted peacefully for generations? * Why are there inconsistencies within the documents pertaining to this CUA? For example, the included structure rendering shows a 32'x36' structure, but another hand-drawn site map shows a 16' structure. Which controls? Does this discrepancy allow for a structure with a different shape or size (larger?) to be built? Also, the rendering shows a two-bedroom residence, but the application space for the number of bedrooms is not filled in. Same concern here. WE STRONGLY URGE THE TOWN OF BELL AND BAYFIELD COUNTY TO DENY THIS CONDITIONAL USE APPLICATION. Signed, ^ Lynne Westphat |||] ,.,^-,. ,David Westphal !NJ °^ ^'^ Heidi Westphal p^\,fic,ir< i; /C.O. ^oriifid Ue'^Alan Krane :' Page Trent Wiesner Pl I^L n) ^ II" i^ II 1 I? h'n It! N 1^ ii~J ! i is ^ K\ OCT 1 n2U24 From: FRED Schlichting <fredschlichting@hotmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, October 15, 2024 10:18 AM To: Zoning Subject: conditional use permit for 21470 Blueberry Lane Cornucopia, Wl '''^ilWS 1.) /Oni,,;, ; ,;-.. You don't often get email from fredschlichting@hotmail.com. Learn why this is important Dear members of the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee, My name is Fred Schlichting and I live at 21590 Blueberry Lane. Cornucopia, Wl. I have lived at this property for almost 40 years. I am writing in opposition to the issuance of a conditional use permit to L. Lueth Holding Company, Inc. for property 21470 Blueberry Lane in Cornucopia. This conditional use permit is on your agenda for your October 17, 2024 meeting which I cannot attend because of being out of town. I am opposed to this permit for a number of reasons. First, it would be the first time that one parcel of land on Blueberry Lane would be allowed to build a second residence on their property. Blueberry Lane is high taxed, lakeshore property that has always had single family homes. Allowing a property owner to add a second residence in close proximity to the first residence would not be in the nature of property on Blueberry Lan Second, the current owner is operating an already approved short term rental of the existing house on this property. Short term rentals have never existed on Blueberry Lane in the past. I realize the owner of the property followed the existing rules to obtain a short term rental of the property, however, noise from the property and the potential for wildfires (from beach fires) are a concern for residents on Blueberry Lane. While the present owner has said this will be a personal residence for now, nothing prevents a future request from this owner or a future owner to create the second home on this property into another rental unit. In fact this current owner allowed a trailer to be parked and used for overnight use already on the property this past summer. This, too, is not in the nature of Blueberry Lane properties and has the potential to decrease property values on the Lane. Third, it is not clear how or if the property is allowed to have two sewer connections on this property. Has the Sanitary District approved of this connection? Finally, if the owner tries to subdivide this property, it also appears to me that subdivision of this 200 foot parcel could not easily be done because of the location of the current house and the locations of the well, and sewer holding tanks. This is only from my visual look at the property from the road as it is not my property to go on. I encourage you to deny this request or at least encourage the Committee act slowly and get more input from residents before making a decision on this conditional use permit request. Fred Schlichting 21590 Blueberry Lane Cornucopia, Wl. 54827 fredschlichting@hotmail.com 715 209 1956 .-?*r-ID) i e I IT [^ OCT 1 fiZuz-i B Bayfield Co. Zoning Depi Deb Kmetz V. From: Mark Fiddler <markdfiddler@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, October 16, 2024 11:45 AM To: Zoning Cc: Elizabeth Seaquist Subject: Conditional use permit on Blueberry Lane, Cornucopia [You don't often get email from markdfiddler@gmail.com. Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderldentification ] Dear Commissioners: We are writing to express our opposition to the conditional use permit variance sought to build an additional residence on the Blueberry Lane property. We support the views of other neighbors who have concerns the second residence may be rental at some point. But beyond that, the current zoning ensures space and a feeling of wildness that makes Blueberry Lane so special. If a variance is granted in this instance, it is unclear why this would not be a "green light" to future variance requests? It is unclear what hardship is presented by the current zoning laws, laws that were in place when the current owners bought their property. Sincerely, Elizabeth Seaquist and Mark Fiddler 21250 Blueberry Lane Cornucopia Wl 612-240-8646 Sent from my iPhone ^ Deb Kmetz From: Alan Krane <wakrane@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, October 16, 2024 12:04 PM To: Zoning Subject: Opposition to proposed Conditional Use Application by L Lueth Holding Company, INc. You don't often get email from wakrane@gmail.com. Learn why this is important To the members of the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee, Please DECLINE OR REJECT this CUA for the following reasons: - There is no apparent long-term policy or regulation governing the expansion of short-term rental properties along Btueberry Lane / in Cornucopia. - Current owner along Blueberry Lane (those able to be contacted on the short notice provided) are overwhelmingly opposed to short-term rentals in this community. - Public input has not been adequately judged by ALL potential affected property owners. - Adverse noise and other disruption has already occurred from the current short-term rental at the proposed property, and the disruption has been felt by owners outside the 300 ft. range used for the notification. - Modification of the existing proposed CUA is possible that would prevent an extended appeal process and potentially large legal fees for all involved, but the modifications would require input from affected parties. PLEASE CONSIDER A TEMPORARY 69-90 DAY STAY/DELAY OF TH IS PROPOSED ACTION TO ALLOW FOR THE PARTIES TO ARRIVE AT AN ACCEPTABLE SOLUTION WITHOUT THE INVOLVEMENT OF ATTORNEYS. Thankyouforyour consideration. Alan Krane, on behalf of Lynne Westphal, David Westphal and Hejdj Westphal (Krane) r 11 \'it ^ : I October 16, 2024 lin OCT 1 ^0^4 IL// Letter to Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee "/field Cu ^\^", ''v.,.; To: Charly Ray - Chair and members of the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee. Subject: Agenda Item: L Lueth Holding Company, Inc., owner and Robert Schierman, agent request a conditional use permit. Dear Mr Ray, The Conditional Use Permit in question concerns lots are shoreland lots zoned R-1. It is my understanding that Section 13-1-26 of Bayfield County Zoning Code requires a minimum area of 30,000 square feet and a minimum average 150 foot width to build a residence. The building must also adhere to side set backs, wetland set backs, and set back from the mid-point of Blueberry Lane. Any lot that doesn't meet these requirements would be considered "substandard". A lot that meets these requirements may have a residence and an accessory building on the property. The accessory building cannot be habitable. The owner, is requesting to build an additional residence which will result in two residences each on a substandard lot and apparently not in conformance with the intent of the ordinance. I request that your committee suspend the hearing on this application for conditional use permit (CUP) for 60 days to give me time to appeal to our town Planning Commission regarding their recommendation to grant this CUP. Specifically, did they consider the minimum 150' width requirement, and if so, would it have changed their recommendation. Before closing I would like to add that I have a great deal of respect for the members of our town's planning commission and the great work they have done, including the great effort they have put forth developing our Short-Term Rental Ordinance. Thank you for your consideration Roger Lindgren 21980 Blueberry Lane Cornucopia Wl 54827 CC Jackie Eid- Chair, Town of Bell Planning Commission loove exceciaiionsB-^FIELE) PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT 117 East Fifth Street PO Box 58 Washbum, Wl 54891(715) 373-6138 Fax: (715)373-0114 E-mail: zoninci@fbavfieldcountv.wi.goy Web Site: www.bavfieldcountv.wi.gov November 6, 2024 (pr \^/ ; /"•^my LaL LUETH HOLDING COMPANY, INCC/0 ROBERT SCHIERMAN 912 SOUTH STATE STREET NEW ULM, MN 56037 RE: Conditional Use Application (Ordinance: Section 13-1-33(a)-Multiple Structures) requesting a second residence. Property is an R-1 zoning district; a 2.927-acre parcel (Tax ID# 37575), described as 2 parcels in Gov't Lot 2 & 3 in Doc #2022R-596362, in Section 33, Township 51 North, Range 6 West, Town of Bell, Bayfield County, Wl. To Whom It May Concern: As you know, the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee conducted a public hearing / meeting on October 17, 2024 where Robert Schierman, agent informed the Committee of your application for a second residence. After discussion and review, the Committee denied your request based upon the following: • The property is zoned R-1, Residential • The property is located in the shorelands with wetland present. There is a floodplain running through the middle of the property • The existing residence is a seasonal cabin. If the applicant desires to have an all-season residence they can remodel and winterize the existing cabin, or they can remove the existing cabin and build an all-season residence. • The Town recommended that only one residence on this property can be used for a short-term rental. Since local units of government cannot limit short-term rentals, the only way the County can honor the Town's recommendation is to limit housing on this parcel to one residence. • The applicant has not demonstrated a hardship to justify a second residence Conditional Use Permit. • The Town's recommendation • Relevant public input • Community welfare • Prevention of overcrowding on the natural resources • The location of the proposal with respect to floodplain • Potential incompatible impacts on other land and land uses Any person aggrieved by a decision of the Planning and Zoning Director and/or Planning and Zoning Committee, may request a public hearing before the Board of Adjustment. The appeal notice shall be filed with the Planning and Zoning Director within thirty (30) days after written notice of the order or decision appealed from was sent by first class mail to the aggrieved party. Thank you for your cooperation and please let our office know if you have any questions or comments. Drafted by: Bayfield Co Planning and Zoning Dept (reh-11/6/2024-11:14am) k:zc/]etters/2024/#10oct/llueth-schierman Proofed by: above expectationsB-^FIELD PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT 117 East Fifth Street PO Box 58 Washbum. Wl 54891 (715) 373-6138 Fax: (715)373-0114 E-mail: zoninci0ibavfieldcountv.wi.aov Web Site: www.bavfieldcountv.wi.qov Sincerely, Ruth Hulstrom, AICP/Director Bayfield County Planning & Zoning Dept. Enc: Voided checks (#2601 and #2555) for land use application and Register of Deed's recording fees and receipt for conditional use application ec: MaryBeth Tillmans, Town Clerk, P.O. Box 280, Cornucopia, Wl 54827, Robert Schierman, Authorized Agent, PO Box 122, Herbster, Wl 54844 Office File Drafted by: Bayfield Co Planning and Zoning Dept (reh-11/6/2024-11:14am) k:zc/letters/2024/#10oct/llueth-schierman Proofed by: B Ay FIELD PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT 117 East Fifth Street PO Box 58 Washbum, Wl 54891 (715) 373-6138 Fax: (715)373-0114 E-mail: zoning<p)ba yfieldcounty, wi.gov Web Site: www.bayfieldcountv.wi.gov December 30, 2024 L Lueth Holding Company, Inc 912 South State Street New Ulm, MN 56037 To Whom It May Concern: We are sending you this letter to advise you of the upcoming Bavfield County Planning and Zoning Committee Public Hearing and Meeting. This notice is also being sent to adjoining landowners; owners of land within 300 feet of the proposed use; the town clerk of the town in which the property is located, and the town clerk of any other town within 300 feet of the proposed use. This written notice is in regard to a Conditional Use Application to place a second residence on the property submitted by L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. To obtain information^ regarding this request; please visit our web site: http://www.bayfieldcountv.wi.gov/198/Plannina-Zoninfl-Committee. Scroll down to Agendas & Minutes. Click on Most Recent Agenda. This matter will be addressed by the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee at their meeting on Thursday, January 16, 2025 at 4:00 pm in the County Board Room of the Bayfield County Courthouse, Washburn Wisconsin. Be advised; the Town of Bell will consider this application prior to the Planning and Zoning Committee meeting (please call the Town Clerk to verify the date and time of their meeting and the date and time of the Plan Commission Meeting). If you wish to comment on this matter, you are invited to attend the hearing or write to the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department. If any person planning to attend this meeting has a disability requiring special accommodations, please contact the Planning and Zoning Department 24 hours before the scheduled meeting, so appropriate arrangements can be made. Note: Written and digital input pertaining to any agenda items will be accepted until noon the day prior to the Planning and Zoning Committee Meeting (Section 13-1-41(b)(1) and 13-1-41A(b)(2)). Subsequent input must be delivered in person at the meeting. Any aggrieved party may appeal the Planning and Zoning Committee's decision to the Board of Adjustment within 30-days of the final decision. Sincerely, Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department enc. public hearing notice & agenda ec: MaryBeth Tillmans, Town Clerk P.O. Box 280, Cornucopia, Wl 54827 Robert Schierman, Authorized Agent, PO Box 122, Herbster, Wl 54844 Adjacent Property Owners (8, 7 mailed no address for remaining) Planning and Zoning Committee Members (Dropbox) Office File ** Please Note: Receiving approval from the Planning and Zoning Committee at the meeting does not authorize the beginning of construction or land use; you must first obtain land use application/permit card(s) from the Planning and Zoning Department. k/debsdata/zc/coverletter/conditionaluse/lluethholdingCUPsecondresidencereh (12/30/2024-2:50pm) Sent out: (12/30/2024) PIIBLIiC HEARIMlS[y;i tt^ E;s ^ ';-^ ^s kL2sP:;H Wc^& EI ^ ^53 BAYFIELD COUNTY PLANNING AND ZONING COMMITTEE JANUARY 16, 2025 AT 4:00 P.M. BOARD ROOM, COUNTY COURTHOUSE WASHBURN, WISCONSIN The Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee of the County Board of Supervisors will hold a public hearing on Thursday, January 16, 2025 at 4:00 P.M. in the Board Room of the Bayfield County Courthouse in Washburn, Wisconsin relative to the following: Donald & Anne Sullivan request a conditional use permit to construct and operate a private cemetery consisting of 25-30 cremated remains. Property is an A-1 zoning district; 0.56 acres of a 6.05-acre parcel (Tax ID# 29336); described as a parcel in W 7i of NE % NE 1/4 lying South of State Hwy 13 in Doc.# 2017R-569574, Section 26, Township 51 North, Range 4 West, Town of Russell, Bayfield County, Wl. Talitha Goldammer request a conditional use permit to construct and operate a campground consisting of 30 tent sites (29 individual & 1 group), camp building (restrooms, showers, common/recreation area, & camp host apartment), and maintenance building (workshop, laundry room, sewing loft, & office). Property is an R- RB zoning district; a 17.7-acre parcel (Tax ID# 39369); described as a parcel in NW % SW 1/4 in Doc 2022R-596267 LESS plat of Sawgrass First Addition, V.8 P. 14 and LESS Lots 1 & 2, CSM 2353 in Doc 2024R-603897, Section 26, Township 51 North, Range 6 West, Town of Bell, Bayfietd County, Wl. Included in this request will be the reguirement(s) of the Environmental Impact Analysis (EIA). L Lueth Holding Company, Inc., owner and Robert Schierman, agent request a conditional use permit (in the shoreland, w/wetlands present) to place a second residence on the property. Property is an R-1 zoning district; a 2.927-acre parcel (Tax ID# 37575), described as 2 parcels in Gov't Lot 2 & 3 in Doc #2022R-596362, in Section 33, Township 51 North, Range 6 West, Town of Bell, Bayfield County, Wl. Immediately following the public hearing, the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee may approve, modify and approve, or disapprove the proposed items and/or amendments and formulate and adopt its recommendations to the Bayfield County Board of Supervisors with respect thereto (if applicable). Copies of all items, petition(s) and/or proposed amendments are available online at (https://www.bavfieldcountv.wi.aov/198/Planninci-Zoning-Committee). Scroll down to Agendas & Minutes. Click on Most Recent Agenda. All interested parties are invited to attend said hearing to be heard. Any person wishing to attend who, because of a disability, requires special accommodations, should contact the Planning and Zoning office at 373-6138, at least 24 hours before the scheduled meeting time, so appropriate arrangements can be made. Immediately after the public hearing, the Planning and Zoning Committee will hold its regular monthly meeting. If further information is desired, please contact the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department, at the Courthouse, Washburn, Wisconsin - Telephone (715) 373-6138 or visit ourwebsite: http://www.bavfieldcountv.wi.aov/zoning. Ruth Hulstrom, AICP / Director Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department k/debsdata/zc/phnotice/2025/Uan Proofed by:. Prepared by: reh (12/27/2024-10:07am) Zoning Committee Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee Public Hearing and Public Meeting Thursday, January 16, 2025 4:00 P. M. Board Room, County Courthouse, Washburn, WI This meeting will be held in the Bayfield County Board Room. The public will be able to participate in the meeting in person or via voice either by using the internet link or phone number below. Microsoft Teams Meeting Join the meeting now Meeting ID: 279 199 232 485 Passcode: KF9Ux9b9 Dial in by phone +1 715-318-2087,.544483960# United States, Eau Claire Find a local number Phone conference ID: 544 483 960# Committee Members: Charly Ray-Chair, Fred Strand-Vice Chair, Dennis Pocernich, James Crandall, & Madelaine Rekemeyer 1. Call to Order of Public Hearing: 2. Roll Call: 3. Affidavit of Publication: 4. Public Comment - [3 minutes per citizen] 5. Review of Meeting Format - (Hand-Out Slips to Audience) 6. Public Hearing: (open for public comment) A. Donald & Anne Sullivan (Russell) - [Conditional Use] - Cemetery in an A-l zoning district B. Talitha Goldammer (Bell) - [Conditional Use] - Campground and EIA in an R-RB zoning district C. L Lueth Holding Company Inc / Robert Schierman (Bell) - [Conditional Use] - second residence on a lot in an R-l zoning district 7. Adjournment of Public Hearing: 8. Call to Order of Planning and Zoning Committee Meeting: 9. Roll Call: 10. New Business: (public comments at discretion of Committee) A. Donald & Anne Sullivan (Russell) - [Conditional Use] - Cemetery in an A-l zoning district k/debsdata/zc/agenda/2025/1 Jan Prepared by: reh (12/27/2024-9:47am)Proofed By: Zoning Committee B. Talitha Goldammer (Bell) - [Conditional Use] - Campground and EIA in an R-RB zoning district C. L Lueth Holding Company Inc / Robert Schierman (Bell) - [Conditional Use] - second residence on a lot in an R-l zoning district Agenda Review and Alteration D. Alex & Mackenzie Strauch (Barnes) - [Special Use] - Dwelling in an C zoning district E. Telemark Properties LLC / Matthew Pobloske & Fred Scheer (Cable) - [Final Plat] - Telemark Hills Phase 1 in an R-RB zoning district ll.Other Business D. Minutes of Previous Minutes: (November 21, 2024) E. Committee Members discussion(s) regarding matters of the P & Z Dept. 12-Monthly Report / Budget and Revenue 13.Adjournment Ruth Hulstrom, AICP / Director Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department Note: Any aggrieved party may appeal the Planning and Zoning Committee's decision to the Board of Adjustment within 30-days of the final decision. Any person wishing to attend who, because of a disability, requires special accommodations, should contact the Planning and Zoning office at 373-6138, at least 24 hours before the scheduled meeting time, so appropriate arrangements can be made. Please Note: Receiving approval from the Planning and Zoning Committee does not authorize the beginning of construction or land use; you must first obtain land use application/permit card(s) from the Planning and Zoning Department. k/debsdata/zc/agenda/2025/1 Jan Prepared by: reh (12/27/2024-9:47am) Proofed By: Zoning Committee Planning and Zoning Committee PJLVFIELD StaffReport Meeting Date: January 16, 2025 Agenda Item: L Lueth Holding Company Inc / Robert Schierman (Bell) - [Conditional Use] - second residence on a lot in an R-l zoning district Report Date: January 12, 2025 Prepared by: Ruth Hulstrom, AICP - Director Request Summary: L Lueth Holding Company, Inc., owner and Robert Schierman, agent are applying for a Conditional Use Permit to construct a second residence located on Tax ID 37575 in the Town of Bell, legally described as two parcels in Gov't Lot 2 & 3, hereinafter referred to as the subject property. The subject property totals 2.927 acres and is zoned Residential-1, R-l and located in the Shorelands with wetlands present. There is also Floodplains running through the middle of the lot. An existing residence is located northeast of the proposed residence, approximately 70 feet. It is unfeasible to split the property and have the proposed residence and the existing residence located on a lot that meets the zoning dimensional requirements. Therefore, pursuant to Bayfield County Ordinance Section 13-l-33(a), see below, a Conditional Use Permit is required to construct the second residence. (a) Multiple Residences. A conditional use permit shall be required for more than one (1} residence on a parcel of land. unless that parcel could be divided underthe terms of the Bayfield County Subdivision Control Ordinance with each building located on a resulting lot and meeting applicable setback requirements. No more than one residence may be located on a substandard lot. ^WHWQ); (©sra&'aoa);(A?30/2004); S®3ii2W2006): (A)1/29/2008): (A)2^27/2018) The department is waiting for confirmation from the sanitary district that the proposed residence can connect but otherwise has no significant concerns about the proposed request so long as the town and surrounding neighbors raise no objections. If appropriate, the Committee can consider whether to place a condition requiring a deed restriction that limits the subject property to one short-term rental unit only for a certain period of time. B-TFIELD PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT 117 E 5th Street PO Box 58 Washburn,WI 54891 (715)373-6138 permits (a) bayfieldcountv.wi.Rov www.bavfieldcounty.wi.Rov/zoninR County JAN 1 ^ 2025 Bayfield Co. Zoning Dept TOWN BOARD RECOMMENDATION (TBA) FORM Note: Receiving Town Board approval does not allow the start of construction or business. You must first obtain your pennit(s) from the Zoning Department. The Zoning Department must send the TEA form to the town clerk. Property Owner: L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC Telephone Number: 6513981595 E-Mail Address: lllueth@yahoo.com Authorized Agent (if applicable) ROBERT SCHIERMAN Telephone Number: 2182600928 E-Mail Address: pawnmanrob@gmail.com Contractor (if applicable): DANULA CONSTRUCTION Telephone Number: 7159190329 E-Mail Address: ddanula@gmail.com Property Address: 21470 BLUEBERRY LN, CORNUCOPIA, Wl 54827 Legal Description (use Tax Statement or Deed): 2 PAR IN GOVT LOTS 2 & 3 DESC IN DOC 2022R-596362 Section, Township, Range: S33-T51N-R06W Town of: Bell Tax ID #: 37575 Zonmg District: R-l Shoreland Yes Wetland Yes Floodplain No Lot Size (Acres/Square Feet): 2.927 ACRES Requesting: D Special Use A D Special Use B 0 Conditional Use D Rezone D Other D Subdivision Plat/Land Division Briefly state what is being requested and why (if needed attach additional sheet): Multiple Structures 13-l-33(a) - Requesting a Conditional Use Permit for a second residence on Tax ID 37575 as existing residence is not habitable in winter months. Town Use Only: We, the Town Board, TOWN OF TbjgJ I _, do hereby recommend to: D Table ^C Approval D Disapproval What is your reasoning for tabling, approval, or disapproval (if needed attach additional sheet)? ftp^O)\;AjP u3Uti. Q( .tta^Ii ^ ^ flLT4z^^ 4l<6^ t^_ ^4<t0ttv_^ fl'^ AL>I-I^«?^<Q^ t^Tl't-z.^. CU)a^ <3rri^ Have you reviewed this for Compatibility with the Comprehensive and/or Land Use Plan?: 1^-Yes D No Signatures: Chamnan:^%^ SupGrvisoi^^l^^^,'^--^-.^. / Supervisor:iswC Date:^T Return completed form to the Zoning Department Town of Bell Plan Commission Meeting January 9, 2025 Town of Bell Community Center Meeting called to order at 4:02 PM. In attendance: Jackie Eict, Ken Roman, Nancy Moye, John Anderson, Sean Presnail. Guests: Phil Moye, Mark Ehlers, Susan Keachie, Roger Lindgren, Alan Krane. 1. Review/Approve Prior Meeting Minutes: Moye makes motion to approve December minutes, seconded by Roman. Approved unanimously. 2. Updates/Correspondence: Roman recently traveled to Washburn to inquire about the work needed to update our Comprehensive Plan maps and some other datasets and is awaiting feedback from the appropriate County officials. 3. Senior Housing: Platted Alley Way: A plot of land has been identified to potentially site a senior housing development in Cornucopia. There are some unresolved questions about the location of the existing sewer line in the area and what its implications may have on potential development of this land. No action by the Commission necessary at this time. 4. Leuth Conditional Use Permit: Eid makes motion to approve the Town's recommendation for a conditional use permit, with a provision recorded in the deed that only one residential dwelling at a time be utilized as a short-term rental, seconded by Moye. This motion is identical to the one initially approved by the Commission at its October meeting. Approved 4-1-0. 5. Goldammer Conditional Use Permit: Construct Campground: Anderson makes motion to table Goldammner permit until the Commission receives additional information to answer questions regarding the various infrastructural impacts of the proposed campground and that the Sanitary District receives the appropriate information and time to effectively evaluate the proposed campground. Seconded by Moye. Approved unanimously. The Commission will consider a resolution in support of increasing the Sanitary District's access to information on proposals/permits that affect the District's infrastructure and capacity and its authority/autonomy to manage sanitary issues on behalf of the Town at its February meeting. 6. February Meeting Date: Next meeting scheduled for Thursday, February 6, 2025 at 4:00 PM. Motion to adjourn by Eid, seconded byAnderson, approved unanimously. Meeting concluded at 6:20 PM. ;£EIg| January 14,2025. (IU J/';-' ! ,. /, Dear Members of the Bayfield Planning and Zoning Committee: t1aynefd Co. 2nnir My letter concerns the reconsideration of the CUP permit denied in October of 2024 requested by Lacey Lueth, which is scheduled on your agenda again for January 16, 2025. I was in attendance in Oct. as an interested citizen of the Town of Bell. The proceedings of that meeting and the decision-making process was subjective and left questions in my mind related to the fairness of the decision to deny. I will reference a couple of the bullet points in the denial letter and a couple new issues with bullet points for brevity. • Town's recommendation. Your disagreement with the TOB stipulation of language attached to the property to allow only one STR on Property at time was not well researched. The Deed language could afford enforcement. You declined your leadership's suggestion about legal counsel. In a recent posting on Wisconsin Surplus Land under Bayfield County several parcels were listed with the language of "additional requirements- "No STR can be placed on this parcel for 10 years". Example: Lot 09643. How is this acceptable for the county to do but not a private citizen? • Relevant Public Comment. The opposition to the allowing a second home to be built on this property was based on misinformation from a few of the neighbors who have not shared their concerns with any entity that might investigate and or enforce the regulation the is in place in the TOB STR Ordinance. I did additional research after the meeting and was not able to confirm noise problems, fire threats etc.that were purported by some of the letters mailed to you prior to the Oct. meeting. State Law pertaining to STRs presents challenges to neighborhoods where zoning previously was able to restrict the development of this type of housing. There are homes in the TOB and specifically on Blueberry Lane that do have 2nd facilities that can and do house people from time to time and these were allowed to be built. • Do we throw the "baby out with the bath water because of potential problems" or do we develop well defined regulation that is allowed within the law. Last winter your committee struggled with the issue of developing and adopting an ordinance at the Bayfield County Level. I listened to these meetings on two occasions, heard the discussion and saw ambivalence among the various members resulting in nothing being done at the county level to provide oversite (beyond what the Dept. of Health does) nor leadership for local townships. It seems to me that each entity of government can do better if we are working together to solve issues that may be county wide and/or more specific to individual townships. • Again on Jan. 9, the TOB Planning Commission heard discussion from some people opposing the building of a residence on Ms. Lueth's property. We listened to many of the same concerns brought forth and it was heavily on the subjective issues. The TOB Commission voted 4-1 to recommend to the Town Board to support the allowance of this CUP. I believe you will receive another letter of support from a commissionaire, the contents of which I am familiar. I can attest to the accuracy of his observations and support many of the points he makes in his letter. Please reconsider the decision made in October for this CUP request knowing there is support at the local level for this CUP to be allowed. Sincerely, Nancy Moye 20755 Lost Creek Road Herbster, Mn 54844 njmigh@gmail.com ;»1 January 15, 2025 ^ JAN 1 , '^ To: Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee nai^u^. ..3. Zoning Depfc From: Roger and Nancy Lindgren 21980 Blueberry Lane, Cornucopia Wisconsin, Mark and Cindy Polich 21840 Blueberry Lane Cornucopia Subject: L Lueth Holding Company, Inc., owner and Robert Schierman, agent request a conditional use permit (in the shoreland, w/wetlands present) to place a second residence on the property. Tax ID 37575. Dear Committee members, In summary, we recommend denying this request for the following reason. This issue is not about the owner. We welcome her as a neighbor. She has the option within the existing Bayfield County zoning rules that allow for expanding and remodeling the existing residence or demolishing the structure and building a new residence that would meet her needs, without a Conditional use permit. Reference can be made to other properties on Blueberry Lane that may have guest houses and/or bunk houses useful for extending family sleeping area but not with kitchen, bath, and living spaces suitable as an additional residence More Specifically: L Lueth Holding Company proposes to build a second residence on their existing shoreland lot with an average width of approximately 200 feet and 127,500 square feet. Under current Bayfield County zoning rules, this would not be allowed thus requiring a conditional use permit to waive the following requirements: 1. Sec. 13-1-33 Multiple Structures. (®@)6/1/1976); (®@) 12/15/2009) Multiple Residences. A conditional use permit shall be required for more than one (1) residence on a parcel of land, unless that parcel could be divided under the terms of the Bayfield County Subdivision Control Ordinance with each building located on a resulting lot and meeting applicable setback requirements. No more than one residence may be located on a substandard lot. 2. Section 13-1-60 of the Bayfield County Zoning Code requires a minimum area of 30,000 square feet and a minimum average 150-foot width to build a residence. The building must also adhere to side setbacks, wetland setbacks, and a setback from the mid-point of Blueberry Lane. A lot that meets these requirements may have a residence and an accessory building on that property. 3. Section 13-1-26 (c) of the Bayfield County Zoning Code reads: a legally created lot for a parcel that met minimum area and minimum average width requirements when created, but does not meet current lot size requirements, may be used as a building site if all of the following apply. (1) The substandard lot or parcel was never reconfigured or combined with another lot or parcel by plat, survey, or consolidation by the owner into one property tax parcel. (2) The substandard lot or parcel has never been developed with one or more of its structures placed partly upon an adjacent lot or parcel. (3) The substandard lot or parcel is developed to comply with all other Bayfield County Zoning Ordinance requirements. Since the property in question is only 200 feet wide, it does not meet the requirement of a minimum average width of 150 feet for each residence - or a total of 300 feet - Section 13-1-60. You will notice in the below screenshot, the existing building is in the middle of the approximately 204 feet owned by Lueth, resulting in a substandard lots even less than 100' Building a second residence would result in creating two substandard lots. Building a residence on a substandard lot would not be allowed since this lot was originally part of four 100-foot plots with a warranty deed recorded on 4/6/1962 and had a single tax id: 7888. It was then split into two 200-foot lots in 2017 creating two tax ids: 37575 and 37574. Therefore, it does not meet the requirement detailed in section 13-1-26 (c) (1). Since this property has an existing 596 sq ft residence upon it, it does not meet the requirement detailed in 13-1-26 (c)(2). ]Q | fi | gj j&,>; 1 5 2:025 1^ Background Information Oayfield Co. Zoning Depl L Lueth Holding Company Inc is requesting a Conditional Use Permit to construct a second residence on 21470 Blueberry Lane. This property is listed as 2.927 acres (127,500 sq ft) with a width of approximately 200 feet and has an existing 596 sq ft home. Owner appears to be claiming that the property is already platted by the government as two "lots". Based on the photo below from the GIS map the lot appears to include two 100-foot plats. However, the lot has one address and one Tax ID. It is not a subdivided lot. It appears that all the property west of 29140 Blueberry Lane were platted in 100-foot segments, and starting with that property east, all were platted in 150-foot segments. https://maps.bavfieldcountv.wi.gov/BavfieldWAB/ This property was originally part of a single property with four 100-foot platted lots for a total width of 400 feet. A warranty deed was recorded 4/6/1962 with the TAX ID: 7888. In 2015, this property was subdivided into two 200- foot lots, each with a single TAX ID: 37574 and 37575. EB Bayfield County Land Records and CIS 1.3 csSSBSSSBiiseeBssBSBflEOSCEO 'sSBassww ^ lyBBGBCaEBIiBSiaSBGSCmEB'5ED02XD3B0 "<-- .^.^V.' ^'-^^^ —<^^m^ uyuu)y/u3& *>.SXKED8GEB 00QEB5BIvjjttscyssQ wtt6u,iBHass'a& D) IEIIS JA^' 1 :' ^025 Bayfield Co. Zoning Dept pl EG^ Sec. 13-1-60 Zoning District Dimensional Requirements.JA<V ' .; W^B For the Zoning D«pt To twu* a Laid UMPtrmlt The Following Unwnttons are Rnqulnd Zoning District R-RB, R-1 F-1,R-2,A-1 R-3 F-2, A-2 t,C* R4 (a) Sewer/water (b) Sewer only (c) Water only Minimum Area 30,000 sq. ft. 41/2 acres 2 acres 35 acres 20,000 sq. ft. 10.000sq.ft. 15,000 sq. ft. 20,000 sq. ft. Minimum Average Width/Frontage Non-Shoreland / Shoreland 150' 300' 200' 1,200' 100' 75' 75' 100' d<^A?Pt & Rear Yard Setbacks Accessory Building 10' 30' 20' 30' 5' 10' 10' 10' Principal Building 10' 75' 20' 75' 5' 10' 10' 10' ® Aug 2018 Shoreland Setback Ordinary High.Water Mark 75' from OHWM or Bank/Bluff Lake Superior Varies may be set by Dept. .Section 14.1.40 SurveyLots/Parcels in shoretand must and Recording Requirements. (b) Commercial zoning districts within and utilizing the services of a sanitary district shall be permitted to apply R-4 Zoning District lot size standards. Commercial zoning districts not located within a sanitary district that involves a residence shall apply R-1 Zoning District lot yize standards. (c) The minimum road frontage on a cul-de-sac shall be fifty (50) feet in a R-1, R-3, R-4, R-RB, Commercial, or Industrial Zoning District. (d) Thf radius of a cul-de-sac shall not be less than forty-five (45) feet in a F-1, R-2, A-1 , R-3, F-2. A-2, Industrial, Commercial, or R-1 Zoning District. (e) The aide yard setback for buildings and structures may be reduced to not less than one-third of the otherwise required setback where a proposed division of land will separate buildings of an existing farmstead. The reduced setback shall apply only along the property line that separates the existing farmstead and only to buildings and s'juctures that predate the proposed division. The Zoning Committee may require drainage, visual screening, and other measures to mitigate the effect of side yard setback reduction as a condition of diviyion approval. Sec. 13-1-26 (a) If vour lot does not meet the requirements above, please read Sec 13-1-26 below Substandard Lots of Record. (A lot which does not meet the applicable lot size and dimensional requirements) Substandard Lots of Record. The following substandard lots of record, if recorded in the Bayfield County Register of Deeds Office, may be used as building sites, subject to the provisions set forth in subsection (b) below: (1) A non-shoreland substandard lot or contiguous lots of record which is or are not serviced by a public sanitary sewer and which is or are at least 10,000 sq. ft. in area and 65 ft. in width at the building line (2) A non-shoreland substandard lot or contiguous lots of record which is or are served by a public sanitary sewer and which is or are at lfac,l 7500 sq. ft. in area and 50 ft. in width at the building line. (b) Substandard lots of record must comply with the following provisions in order to be used as building sites. (1) The proposed use of the site is permitted in the zoning district in which it is located. (2) All applicable setback requirements of this ordinance and a I provisions of the Bayfield County Sanitary and Private Sewage Ordinance are complied with. (c) Buildings Sites on Substandard Shoreland Lots. A legally created lot for a parcel that met minimum area and minimum average width requirements when created, but does not meet current lot size requirements, may be used as a building site if all of the following apply; (1) The substandard lot or parcel was never reconfigured or combined with another lot or parcel by plat, survey, or consolidation hy thR owner into one property tax parcel. (2) The substandard lot or parcel has never been developed with one or more of its structures placed partly upon an adjacent lot or parcel. (3) The substandard lot or parcel is developed to comply with all other Bayfield County Zoning Ordinance requirements. (d) Other Substandard Lots. A building permit for the improvement of a lot having lesser dimensions than those described in suhsHrtions (a) and (b) abnvn, or a shoreland lot having lesser dimensions than those described in suh.sHr.tion (c) above shall be issued only after the granting of a variance by the Board of Adjustment. Note: If you have a sub standard lot of record, it may be buildable provided it meets the above criteria and you obtain a copy of the recorded deed showing the parcel was created before your Township adopted zoning. G °o novus.bayfieldcounty.wi.gov/access/master.asp ^ System Explorer Bayftetd County Public Acoenl/Wazs ^ RM| t-stare <J| faaaoaaLEuDfiity ^ Link to Ireasurer Page ro Pay 2nd half or PMt Yur taxnsnly by Qedlt Card, Echeck, or Debit:ard to the Bayfteld County Tieasurer jsu Ihb IhK. ^ ^WfiayfleldCounty Jl<^odil Qiid -By =or Credit Card or Echeck payments to:he following mitnlcipallttes use The wnldpallty Hr* below. December and January Jurtsdldton ^JianiflUams '•'o<ll'ta 'S> TcnnrQ Of Bayflpld - - - - -^.Otfc^LEarfIfild " ~" [Public Access Real Estate TaxIU |,8^ inn: •Name! fta: *: Suireh Raaulta Record! Found: 1 Wt./KoacyID: l ! LasWrg.: TuID: 7888DOROTHY M BECHTEL8737 OCUSVILU RO UWT 501SILVER SPRING MO 20910 Pmperty naRu»nfa V7/3025 1M5 00 PN Officials Zoning JAN " '' 'W^> ^gyjpetd Co. Zoning Depi nt owio-MHtt-u-i CMUMOOCiri7— 6.0KKC...IUITOIKMW'awTtmi OwttBfK DOROTHY M BECHTU.1737 OOUSVILLE «DUNFTMlSILVER SPRING MD 20910 Real Estate Bayfield County Property Listing Today'* Date! 1/8/2025 Updated: 7/M/2017 OH)10-2-5U)M3-1 05-002-80000 010107208000 (010) TOWN OF BELLS33 T51N R06WLOT 20-23 IN GCWT LOT 26. 3INV.174P.503 •IV.206R155WG6.010 5.9600^to (R-l}Rfi5ldentiBi-l Updated: 3/1S/2006 STATEcounrrTOWN Of BELLSCHL-SCWTHSHORETECHNICAL COLLEGE Tax ID:PIN: LegicvPIN:Map ID; Municipality: STR:Desalptton: Recorded Acres: Cakulated Acres: Lottery Claims: First Dollar: Zoning:ESN: I Tu Districts 104010044522001700 <*> Ownership DOROTHY MBECHTIL ' Status: Archived (2017) Created On: 3/15/2006 1:15:02 PM Updated; 3/8/2017SILVER SPRING MD DOROTHY H8ECHTELATTN: KATHLEEN HAYDEN8737 COLESVILIE WDUNIT 501SILVER SPRING MD ?Q910 DOROTHY M BECHTELATm: KATHLEEN HAYDEN8737 OOLESVILLE TOUNFT 501SILVER SPRING MD 20910 ^ Stte Address !* Indicates Private Road N/< -t Property Afssmurt "Pdatui: 9/IB/2015 2017 »M€s«ment Detail Code Acres Land Imp.Gl-RESIDENTIAL 6.010 248,40» 38,900 2-YurComp.llson Improved; Total: 2016 2017 Change 248,400 248,400 0.0% 38,900 38,900 0.0% 28?,300 287,300 0.0% * Recorded Documents Updated: 3/15/2006B TERMINATION OF DECEDENTS INTEREST Bl Proparty Hirtory Date Recorded: 11/16/2015 2015R 561271 1152-210 child Properties a CONVERSION WMa-l-si-Vs-w-i, BMoa-Biooo Date Recorded: 174-503 M-OW2-bl-Ob 3J-1 0^-00^-62000 0 W(UUUNT»DIEDDate Recorded: 4/6/1962 2JOU6 174 SOa HISTORY a£iuaad-AII Hidw Wtille-Curfent Parcels Plnk-Retlrtxl Pa((;d& ISm ThUPand •tparenu *OUMt»nBTax ID: 3/SM Pin: &4-01D-2-bl-Ob-3J-l OS-CW2-81000BTutID: 37')/5 nn:I>4-01D-2-5l-U6-33-l 05-002-B200Q Tax 103757< 3/t>/t) •^ System Explorer Bayfidd County Public,\nimn 0 BeaLEsBle ^ Personal Propeity ^ Upk To Ireasyrer Page •o Pay 2nd half or Past Year taxes •nl» by Credll Card, Echeck, or Debit:aid to the Bayfietd County Treasurer ise Mils link. '- pa» Havlldd Cnunh Trnia-.r n,>tJSy Itayfl*** County Treasii-rpdlt Card w Qedit Card or Ed»eck payments to he following muntdpatlties use thenunidpality link betow. December and January Jurisdiction <-'. A>JownOfBavfJrid /.*>.Uha2Uiavfield 1<^ Otv Of Washbum *a0014e IPublic Access Real Estate I Tax ID: : 37575 | PIN; ; !.| .1 i Owner Name: plrst: Site Mdrau- »; <• l>m;04-OU)-2-5I-06-33-lC6<OM2«»T«XlDl37S7S 2.927AC.Isaa-ratMuwwOOVTUIT2 Owners: L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC912 SOUTH STATE STNEW UtM MN 56073 Mte: 2147& BUUBERRY LN Search Alt/LnimlD: i—] ri I tast/om.: Road: _1 r ,1 Tax ID: 37575L LUEIH HOLDING COMPANY INC912 SOUTO STATE STNEW ULM MN 56073 SeaichReaulla Baconlt Found; 1 V7/2085 12:45:00 PM ainlir Real Estate Bayfield County Property Listing Today's Date: 1/8/2025 drD«acitpUon T.xID:PIN: Legacy PIN; Map ID: Munldpallty; STR: DemlpUon: Recorded Acres: Cakufated Acres: Lottery Claims: First Dollar:ESN: ^ Tax Districts 1(M 010044522 001700 Recorded DocumentsB TRUSTEES DEED Date Recorded: 9/14/2022 B QUn-CLAIM DEED Date Rccordod: 3/16/2017 B QUIT CLAIM DEEDDate Recorded: 3/K/20I7 Updated: 10/28/202237575 04.0M-2-SI-06-33-1 05-002-82000 (010) TOWN OF BEU-S33 T51N R06W21WRINGOVTLOTS2& 3DESCINDOC2022R-596362 ?.927 2.9270 Yes Property Status: Cumnt Created On; 7/11/2017 3:33:20 PM <*>o«n>enlilp L IUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC Updated- 10/28/2022 NEW Ul M MN Mailing Addff^fts;L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY L LUETH HOLDING COMPANYINC IKC91? SOUTH STATE ST 912 SOUTH STATE STNEW ULM MN 56073 NEW UIM MN 5W73 ? Ste Address * Indicates Prhrate Road 214/0 BLUEBERRY LN Updated: 7/14/2017 S1 ATECOUNTYTOWN OF BELLSCHL-SOUTHSHORE TCCHNIOU.CO.IEGE Updated: 7/14/2017 2022R-596362 2017R-567601 2017R-567600 -J Property Assessment 2024 toeumCTt DetailCode Gl-RESIDENTIAL 2-Ycar Comparison Land; Improved:Total; CORNUCOP1A M827 Updated; 8/9/2018 Acres land 2.927 201,200 Imp. 38.900 2023 2024 Change 201,200 201,200 0.0% 38,900 38,900 0.0% 240.100 2<t0,100 0.0% S Property History Pwent Properties 04-010.2-51-06-33-1 05-002-MOOO HISTORY Ofanpnd All HtetQry Whlte=Current Parcels Plnk=Retlred Parcels B Tax Uk 7888 Pbu 0+010-2-S1-06-33-1 OS-002-aiOU l — Phi- 01ifcjU•p Trent Wiesner E®E|^gj From: Kevin Griffin <kevinpgriffin@hotmail.com> \^ - i-,;i/!i Sent: Wednesday, January 15, 2025 9:32 AM UU jA?v ••!/';'--' To:. . zoning ....... „ . ..... . ., Bavfield Co. Zoning ObptSubject: Re: L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. CUA for second residence o'nl^'-Tlot I: You don't often get email from kevinpgriffin@hotmail.com. Learn why this is important To the members of the Bayfield County Planning & Zoning Committee: I'm the resident at 21940 Blueberry Ln in Cornucopia, Wl and was made aware of a conditional use permit application that could allow for another short-term rental property to be built on a critical shoreline habitat area. I'm in favor of restricting and limiting short-term rental properties in the area due to the risks associated to the environment from visitors that do not appreciate or can participate in the level of stewardship required in maintaining this critical habitat. The increases in short term rentals in the recent past is a frustration of many of my neighbors on Blueberry Lane. Below: I've copied the language from the email from my neighbor, Alan Krane from 21450 Blueberry Ln, provided you. I am in agreement with his arguments to deny the CUA for a second residence on R-llot as referenced below. Thank you, Kevin Griffin From Alan Krane: Please decline / deny the above-referenced conditional use application (L. Lueth Holding Company, Inc. for second residence on R-l lot) forthe reasons below. • Nothing in the Town's or the County's statutes requires the approval of this conditional use application. • The application proposes a second residence on a substandard shoreland parcel which already contains a residential structure. Sections 13-1-33, 13-1-60 and 13-1-26 all pertain to this application. - Under Sec. 13-1-26 (c) (1) requires that for a Substandard Shoreland Lotto^be used^as a building site, "The substandard lot or parcel was never reconfigured or combined with another lot or parcel by plat, survey, or consolidation by the owner into one property tax parcel." Butthis property had a single tax id since a warranty deed was recorded on 4/6/1962. In 2017, the lot was divided into two lots, creating two tax ids: 37574 and 37575. According to this application, the two lots have since beerLconsoNdatedJnto a single tax id: 37575, so it does not meefthe reciuirement detailed in Sec.13-1-26 (c) (1). - This property already has an existing residence on it, so it does not meet the reauirement detailed in Sec. 13-1-26 (d (2). The applicant has proposed a revised application to include a quit claim deed which they hope wilt address residents' strong opposition to the proposed new structure. Having seen a draft of the proposed language in the quit claim deed, it is unacceptable because it has the following flaws:xgx&u• The language does not specify which of the two structures (existing or prop)! restricted from use as a STR. • The language is vague enough to potentially allow both structures to be used as STR s sequentially (but not concurrently) for up to 240 days during the year, assuntti?f^l^c^fe?onln9 ;^eP^ permitting and other requirements are met. • The restrictions on use of either or both residences as STRs may be removed "at any time", if approved by Bayfield County. Unfortunateb^lhe lajrgyage of the proposed quit claim deed, as of Jan.14, 2025, has NOT been included in the agenda packet online for the County Planning & Zoning Committee meeting, so most interested property owners are not aware of what is being proposed. • Nothing prevents the applicant from having a 4-season residence on this property, and no hardship has been demonstrated by the applicant. Existing Bayfield County zoning allows for winterizing / remodeling the existing residence or removing the existing structure and building a new residence to meet their needs without a Conditional Use Permit. Agent has described the owner of the corporate applicant as being "homeless", but this is not true. The owner owns at least three other residences: New Dim, MN; Iron River, Wl; Herbster, Wl. Any inconvenience caused by their decision to allow others to live in one of those residences is entirely the owner's responsibility, and that decision is reversible by the owner. • If approved, this CUA will set an unacceptable precedent for future rapid growth in property and population density that are inconsistent with the rural character of the properties on Blueberry Lane and the surrounding area of Bayfield County. • The proposed structure would more than double the waste material production of this property. Beyond the negative impacts on Blueberry Lane privacy and wetland / shoreland preservation from this proposal, is the significant existing overuse burden on the Town of Bell Sanitation District resources. At a Bell Plan Commission meeting on Thursday, Jan. 9th, the district president stated that the town is already exceeding the agreed-upon DNR volume limit and has been for approximately three years. In addition to the recent rapid growth from short-term rentals and other growth, the town is reviewing proposals for a senior living facility and a new campground. The district president said that rapid continued growth would likely / possibly require cutting sanitation services provided to existing customers in some significant way, for example, requiring them to contract with private firms to transport the waste and negotiate agreements with other towns (and pay them?) willing to take the waste. • The applicant is a corporation. The primary purposes of corporations are to make money and to protect their owners and stakeholders from risks and liabilities stemming from business operations. These corporate objectives are not consistent with the primary land use and rights to enjoy their residential property of the property owners on Blueberry Lane. To date, other than the applicant, none of the property owners has expressed support for this application. • Local residents both east and west of the Lueth corporately-owned property have already experienced problems in 2024 with noise, potential fire control issues, use of a trailer to increase capacity and lightweight furniture being left on the beach by the owner and their rental guests. On two occasions this past summer, the property owner was a significant contributor to the noise levels. Approval of a second residence would increase the noise and damage risk. • Just two days ago, I was told by a Blueberry Lane neighbor that the long-term owner of this property may have registered it as a protected wetland / shoreland with a statewide or regional conservation organization. This was confirmed by another property owner. Yesterday, to try to confirm or refute this information, I contacted the Landmark Conservancy, the Nature Conservancy and the DNR for further information. I haven't gotten responses yet, but I will not be surprised if we learn that Bill and Dorothy Bechtel did register this property somehow. The Bechtels valued wetland / shoreland preservation, and they worked to prevent unnecessary increases in building and population density in natural residential areas like Blueberry Lane. Bill was instrumental in helping establish government policy and ordinances for both commerce zones and preservation zones on the local, county, state and regional levels going back many years. Read more about Bill Bechtel here: https://www.apg-wi.com/ashland daily press/opinion/letters/northland-loses-a-friend-with-bechtel-s- passine/artide e80e62ba-d99a-lle4-81c3-53239edc2cc0.html We ask that you apply logic and ordinance and respect the legacy of Bill Bechtel's vision by declining / voting against the L. Lueth Holding Company, Inc. conditional use a pplication. ^?wfet'~L'" •'"•nsh... Subject: Re: L. Lueth Holding Company, Inc. CUA for second residence on R-1 lot ID) EEUI To the members of the Bayfield County Planning & Zoning Committee: P ,; ,,,,^J/'j'; "\..' /1025 Please decline / deny the above-referenced conditional yse^pplicatioiLd-. Lu^lftR>fiftiQninQ Dept Company, Inc. for second residence on R-1 lot) for the reasons below. • Nothing in the Town's or the County's statutes requires the approval of this conditional use application. • The application proposes a second residence on a substandard shoreland parcel which already contains a residential structure. Sections 13-1-33, 13-1-60 and 13-1-26 all pertain to this application. - Under Sec. 13-1-26 (c) (1) requires that for a Substandard Shoreland Lot to be used as a building site, "The substandard lot or parcel was never reconfigured or combined with another lot or parcel by plat, survey, or consolidation by the owner into one property tax parcel." But this property had a single tax id since a warranty deed was recorded on 4/6/1962. In 2017, the lot was divided into two lots, creating two tax ids: 37574 and 37575. Accordino to this application, the two lots have since been consolidated into a single tax id: 37575, so it does not meet the requirement detailed in Sec. 13- 1-26 (c) (1). - This property already has^an existing residence^n it, sojtdoes noLmeetthe requirement detailed in Sec. 13-1-26 (c) (2). • The applicant has proposed a revised application to include a quit claim deed which they hope will address residents' strong opposition to the proposed new structure. Having seen a draft of the proposed language in the quit claim deed, it is unacceptable because it has the_following flaws: o The language does not specify which of the two structures (existing or proposed) would be restricted from use as a STR. o The language is vague enough to potentially allow both structures to be used as STR s sequentially (but not concurrently) for up to 240 days during the year, assuming proper permitting and other requirements are met. o The restrictions on use of either or both residences as STRs may be removed "at any time", if approved by Bayfield County. Unfortunately, the lanauage of the proposed auit claim deed, as of Jan.14, 2025, has NOT been included in the agenda packet online for the County Planning & Zoning Committee meeting, so most interested property owners are not aware of what is being proposed. • Nothina prevents the applicant from having a 4-season residence on this property^ and no hardship has been demonstrated by the applicant. Existing Bayfield County zoning allows for winterizing / remodeling the existing residence or removing the existing structure and building a new residence to meet their needs without a Conditional Use Permit. Agent has described the owner of the corporate applicant as being "homeless", but this is not true. The owner owns at least three other residences: New Ulm, MN; Iron River, Wl; Herbster, Wl. Any inconvenience caused by their decision to allow others to live in one of those residences is entirely the owner's responsibility, and that decision is reversible by the owner. • If approved, this CUA will set an unacceptable precedenffor future rapid growth in property and population density that are inconsistent with the_ rural character of the properties on Blueberry Lane and the surrounding area of Bayfield County. - The proposed structure would more than double the waste material production of t| Beyond the negative impacts on Blueberry Lane privacy and wetland / shoreland t^'jserj^|iap ff^/i V—1-:—JL &-y(» p7or this proposal, is the sionificant existing overuse burden on the Town of Bell Sanitation [district resources. At a Bell Plan Commission meeting on Thursday, Jan. 9th, the district pvs that the town is already exceeding the agreed-upon DNR volume limit and has been for approximately three years. In addition to the recent rapid growth from short-term rentals and other growth, the town is reviewing proposals for a senior living facility and a new campground. The district president said that rapid continued growth would likely / possibly require cutting sanitation services provided to existing customers in some significant way, for example, requiring them to contract with private firms to transport the waste and negotiate agreements with other towns (and pay them?) willing to take the waste_ • The applicant is a corporation. The primary purposes of corporations are to make money and to protect their owners and stakeholders fromjisks and liabilities stemmino from business operations. These corporate objectives are not consistent with the primary land use and rights to enjoy their residential property of the property owners on Blueberry Lane. To date, other than the applicant, jrpne of thej?ropertv^wners has expressed support for this application. • Local residents both east and west of the Lueth corporately-owned property have already experienced problems in 2024_with noise, potential fire control issues, use of a trailer to increase capacity and lightweight furniture being left on the beach by the owner and their rental guests. On two occasions this past summer, the property owner was a significant contributor to the noise levels. Approval of a second residence would increase the noise and damage risk. • Just two days aqo, I was told by a Blueberry Lane neighbor that the long-term owner of this property may have registered it as a protected wetland / shoreland with a statewide or regional conservation organization. This was confirmed by another property owner. Yesterday, to try to confirm or refute this information, I contacted the Landmark Conservancy, the Nature Conservancy and the DNR for further information. I haven't gotten responses yet, but I will not be surprised if we learn that Bill and Dorothy Bechtel did register this property somehow. The Bechtels valued wetland / shoreland presen/ation, and they worked to prevent unnecessary increases in building and population density in natural residential areas like Blueberry Lane. Bill was instrumental in helping establish government policy and ordinances for both commerce zones and preservation zones on the local, county, state and regional levels going back many years. Read more about Bill Bechtel here: httDS://www.apa-wi.com/ashland daily press/oDinion/letters/northland-loses-a-friend-with- bechtel-s-passina/article e80e62ba-d99a-11e4-81c3-53239edc2cc0.html We ask that you apply logic and ordinance and respect the legacy of Bill Bechtel's vision by declinina / votinq aaainst the L. Lueth Holding Company. Inc. conditional use application. Property owner and Trustees Lynne Westphal David Westphal Heidi Westphal Alan Krane Trent Wiesner __. ^ ^ ^ nnnf 5 Z025From: Kevin Roberts <robe0453@alumni.umn.edu> Sent: Wednesday, January 15, 2025 11:45 AM Subject: Re: Letter for inclusion at upcoming Zoning Committee mee^Jld co- zoni"g Dept You don't often get email from robe0453@alumni.umn.edu. Learn why this is important Sorry, I forgot to sign this. I am Kevin Roberts, owner of 21380 Blueberry Lane. On Wed, Jan 15, 2025 at 11:32 AM Kevin Roberts <robe0453(aalumni.umn.edu> wrote: Hello, I would like to express my opposition to the conditional use permit still being sought by L Lueth Holding Company. I submitted a detailed letter last October when this application was initially submitted, so I won't duplicate that here. But I will summarize my key concerns again: -1 don't believe for a second that this second property won't be used as an additional short-term rental, no matter what platitudes are being offered. - The existing rental has proven problematic for noise and fire safety concerns. - The renters who stay at the existing L Lueth rental - and indeed, many renters who stay at other short term rentals in the area - clearly think the entire stretch of beach in Cornucopia is a public beach. I have begun asking passers by (as they multiply annually) for details, and a common theme is that they are renters who assumed (or were told) that the entire beach is a public thoroughfare. I correct them when this happens,but I can only repeat myself so many times before I get fed up. I routinely have to restrain my dog (who stays on his property) 15+ times on a typical summer day so that complete strangers who are renting a house for a weekend can trespass through my front yard. I've even had to chase people out of my beach furniture who simply parked there as if it were their right to do so. Short term rentals on Blueberry Lane itself are particularly difficult in this regard, but this is a broader problem for me as the tourist population expands. I strongly suspect that Lacy Lueth is telling her renters that they are allowed to walk the beach, which is patently false. Anyone who walks the beach does so because the owners have allowed it up until now, and they have done so because it used to be owners and their friends/families who were doing the walking. But the short term landlords of the area are taking this goodwill on the part of the Blueberry Lane owners and monetizing it for their own personal profit, which I find profoundly unjust. Incidentally, there used to be a sign near the marina (the only truly public section of the beach) that denoted the end of the public area. It washed away years ago and was never replaced. I would like to pursue replacing that sign and making it clear that only the eastern end of the beach is a public space. ^g .!/.M 'u^.i : nil 1:: 2025 ^ January 14, 2025 ^gyfjeld Co. Zoning Dept. Dear Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee: I write you today to urge your positive reconsideration of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) filed by L. Lueth Holding Company (Lueth), whose approval was recommended to you by the Town of Bell Plan Commission and Board of Supervisors in October 2024, and re-recommended to you by the Town Plan Commission and Board of Supervisors this month, in order to site a second residential structure on property Lueth owns on Blueberry Lane in the Town of Bell. Although I presently serve as Secretary of the Town Plan Commission, in no way do I speak for this or any other Town entity in any capacity here; I tender these comments solely as a full-time resident and elector of the Town and County. I was inspired to communicate with you in more detail about this permit proposal in order to correct several points of disinformation that have been entered into the record of this proceeding in opposition to it, which may have unduly influenced your initial decision to deny this permit despite the Town's recommendation for approval. The Town of Bell Clerk initially received the Lueth CUP application and supporting documents via mail from the Bayfield County Department of Planning and Zoning on Monday, September 30, 2024. They were forwarded by the Clerk to the Plan Commission Chair via email on Tuesday, October 1, 2024, and subsequently forwarded to the entire Commission via email on Wednesday, October 2, 2024 for its collective consideration the following day at its regular monthly meeting. I agree with some commenters in this proceeding that the timeframe given the Town by the County to initially consider this CUP was abbreviated, but this is unfortunately a long-standing practice of the County. We often do not receive documentation that we are required to consider and recommend the disposition of until just 24 to 72 hours before the legal deadline for publishing public notices of Plan Commission meetings and including these items on our agenda. While the County may have actually received the Lueth CUP documents in mid-August, the fact of the matter is that they were not transmitted to the Town until a month and a half later, and we glil .p."1 oshave learned to adjust our workflow accordingly in order to perfomic(file°81fl'^el(ryyltN^'ff?°the County's short-fuse notification protocols. So long as materials such as these are received and properly publicly noticed for consideration as a meeting agenda item, any claim of "delay" on behalf of the Town for the purposes of suppressing public input is speciously intemperate and demonstrates ignorance of public meetings and records laws. The fault regarding the perception of a compressed timetable for this proceeding ultimately lies with the County, not the Town. Knowing that the parcel in question on which Lueth proposed building a residential structure already included a residential structure actively employed as a short-term rental property, the Plan Commission formulated several questions about proposed use of the new structure in the short-term rental context. There were relatively few questions about the dimensions, siting, and sanitary connections of the new structure, as according to the documentation provided it met with all applicable County zoning regulations regarding substandard lot configuration and setbacks; would connect to an existing line in the Comucopia sewer system with adequate capacity for the new structure; and was otherwise not in open conflict with the Town's Comprehensive Plan. It is not my duty to recommend greater restrictions in these contexts on a property simply to satisfy the aesthetic preferences of neighboring property owners. Two people attended the Plan Commission's regular meeting on October 3, 2024 to speak on this agenda item. The first was former County Zoning Administrator Rob Schierman, who spoke on Lueth's behalf in his role as a regulatory consultant. Mr. Schierman explained to the Commission that Lacey Lueth was seeking via this permit to build a permanent residence for herself in the Town of Bell. Ms. Lueth, the owner of Cranberry Over Superior in Herbster as well as two short-term rental properties in the Town of Bell (one on Blueberry Lane and the other on State Highway 13), presently has no permanent residence of her own: Mr Schierman explained that, until recently, she had been living in residential quarters attached to her restaurant, but had vacated these in order to provide housing to one or more restaurant employees. While there was no mention made of the Highway 13 STR property, Mr. Schierman asserted that the existing residential structure on Blueberry Lane is unsuitable for year-round habitation. JAN ". . /'^o Bayfietd Co. Zoning Depl The issue of short-term rental use of the new property was addressed directly by the Plan Commission. According to state statute, the WI DATCP Tourist Rooming House License already awarded to the Blueberry Lane property can accommodate as many as four rental units, and the existing two-bedroom structure on the property constitutes two of those units. So ifLueth did decide at some point to utilize the new two-bedroom structure as an STR, the legal capacity already existed to do so with little recourse left to the County or Town via its existing licensing and permitting processes. However, it was Mr. Schierman who suggested that, as a means by which to alleviate this concern, the Town recommend approval of the CUP with a deed covenant restricting the use of this parcel for short-term rental purposes. He was adamant that Lueth had no intention of expanding the short-term rental footprint on this parcel and proposed this restriction in good faith to legally concretize that position. The other person to speak on this agenda item at our October meeting was Fred Schlichting, a resident ofBlueberry Lane. Mr. Schlichting raised several concerns with this CUP, none of which were grounded in empirical evidence or actual fact. Having heard the Commission's discussion about the application's compliance with applicable County regulations and the lack of local regulatory power to prohibit short-term rentals more broadly, Mr. Schlichting first spoke about problems with trash, traffic, and noise from the Lueth STR property. However, there is no record of any complaints tendered to the Town by Mr. Schlichting or any other Blueberry Lane resident regarding these issues, and the Town cannot take any sort of enforcement action or develop elements of public policy without evidence to justify it. Mr. Schlichting also expressed concern about fires or the potential for fires along the shoreline due to the operation of the Lueth STR. There are no fire department call-logs for incidents on Blueberry Lane of this nature in any way connected to the existing STR property, and I attempted to inform Mr. Schlichting of the Town's own short-term rental licensing ordinance, which requires responsible siting of any objects or devices using open flames and explicitly prohibits their use "during any red flag warning issued by the National Weather Service or when the appropriate burning restrictions are imposed by the Wisconsin Department of Natural ^ I @ '! 8 11 ,]^\ "•.. r-^ Resources."! Mr. Schlichting did not seem to be aware that the TowWj?dl°liW& rental licensing ordinance despite its enactment in November 2023, and literally dismissed these facts out of hand. Finally, Mr. Schlichting advocated that we deny the CUP based on the premise that since the value of properties on Blueberry Lane are some of the highest in the Town of Bell, they should receive special consideration due to the potential for devaluation of these properties by the expansion of short-term rentals in the area, and the potential impact that might have on Town property tax revenues. Leaving aside the key fact that Lueth's proposed new property would not be utilized as an STR, I found it offensive that we were effectively being asked to customize land-use policy recommendations based on perceived economic privilege. Furthermore, current peer-reviewed research at the intersection of housing policy and economics in Wisconsin shows that when the density of STRs in a given neighborhood increases, property values also increase, and that this effect is most magnified in rural areas, which seems to contradict Mr. Schlichting's assertion.2 This information was also dismissed out of hand. After further discussion, the Plan Commission recommended approval of the Lueth CUP with a provision recorded in the deed that only one residential dwelling at a time be utilized as a short- term rental, by a majority vote of 3-0-1. At the Town of Bell Board of Supervisors' regular meeting on October 8, 2024, the Lueth CUP was on the agenda. There were no public comments tendered in opposition to the CUP at this meeting, despite multiple opportunities to provide them. Mr. Schierman and Ms. Lueth were in attendance and Mr. Schierman provided the same information to the Board that he provided the Plan Commission: Ms. Lueth needed a home of her own, she wanted to live in the Town of Bell, and she thought it best to live adjacent to one of her existing short-term rental properties. After some perfunctory questions to Mr. Schierman, the Board of Supervisors also approved recommendation of the CUP with the deed restriction by a majority vote of 4-0-1. 1. Town of Bell Ordinance #2023-01, Section 4(10), available online athttEis^Z/bellwi.gov/wp- content/uploads/2023/12/Ordinance-Short-Term-Rentals-2023-0120231213J 7442614.pdf. 2. Sergio Garate and Anthony Pennington-Cross, "Short-Term Property Rental Platforms and the Housing Market: House Prices and Liquidity," Journal of Housing Research 32(3) (February 2022), p. 1-20. Sil IGEI JAN '• ;.• '^^ Bayfield Co. Zoning Dept Thus it was only after opponent commenters' original objections to this CUP had been thoroughly considered and rejected for lack of substance by the Town Plan Commission, and after making zero effort to advance these objections with the Town Board of Supervisors, did they assemble a correspondential posse for your benefit to promote the perception of grievous harm to the Town from this CUP though the repetition and amplification of falsehoods, anecdote and hearsay. It is disappointing that you were swayed by this end-run maneuver during your initial consideration of this item. Fortunately, even though you were not legally obligated to do so, in your decision to reconsider this CUP you re-submitted the Lueth application for a second round of Town review and recommendation. The Plan Commission conducted this review at its regular meeting on January 9, 2025. Messrs. Schierman and Schilchting did not attend, but Blueberry Lane residents Roger Lindgren and Alan Krane were present. Mr. Lindgren abruptly left our meeting after I questioned his legal interpretation of the Lueth property's qualification to utilize the CUP process. Mr. Krane, who engaged you - but not us - with extensive comment on this CUP last year, did see fit to file new comments with the Town Plan Commission and Board of Supervisors on reconsideration. Unfortunately, the new information provided is as factually-detached as before: allegations ofSTR operation-related harm wholly devoid of any empirical evidence, now seasoned with a selective misreading of the Lueth CUP application and its supporting documents in service ofaspersions about the potential for a nefarious "corporate profit motive" lurking behind this CUP and the applicants it represents. In a lengthy and oftentimes contentious discussion, the Plan Commission engaged directly with each new objection to interrogate their veracity. In the end, the Commission voted 4-1-0 to recommend approval of the Lueth CUP using a motion identical to the one it passed in October 2024, including the proviso restricting short-term rental use of the property. The Town Board of Supervisors reconsidered the Lueth CUP at its regular meeting on January 14, 2025. Nobody arose to speak on this agenda item. After a couple minutes of discussion, this time the Board unanimously recommended approval of the CUP with the same conditions as before. nj Eg 111 ^illIll .^ •• .^Z5 1^ bayfeld Cu. Zuniny Dbpl I have been asked why the Town has not specified an operative duration for any restrictive-use covenant in its recommendations to approve this CUP. From my perspective, there are three primary reasons. First, the regulation, administration, and enforcement of such restrictions falls on the County, not the Town. Therefore, you are the proper venue in which to develop a specific duration/expiration of any covenant, as you are the ultimate local authority and subject-matter experts in this particular policy area. Second, I recognize that any such covenant represents a diminution of property rights in exchange for special regulatory dispensation, and I believe that Lueth's willingness to proactively make such a compromise in order to assuage community concerns about the intended use of new development on the property in question is an endorsement of their intention to be a good neighbor. Finally, I am concerned that, considering the dynamic of the public discourse that has developed in opposition to this proposal, any substantive amendment made to the Town's initial recommendation might be misconstrued in such as way as to try and create a false perception among you of shifting Town sentiment on this issue. With regard to questions about the inherent legality of attaching a covenant of the sort recommended by the Town for the Lueth CUP, I note that Zoning Administrator Ruth Hulstrom raised this issue at your October 2024 Planning and Zoning Committee meeting and recommended you table the CUP until receiving advice from counsel. Although I disagree with Ms. Hulstrom about where the fulcrum of legal authority exists to create and enforce a covenant such as the one proposed, and despite the fact that the County itself has imposed such STR- related covenants on public lands previously sold to private owners, that your Committee chose to move forward without consulting counsel was precipitous and ill-advised. The responsibilities of your positions require a higher level of diligence and objectivity than what you have demonstrated here. I am also concerned about your seemingly arbitrary dismissal of the Town's recommendation in this matter. While such a course of action by the County is not unprecedented, it is highly unusual to overturn a Town recommendation especially with no substantive factual or legal justification for doing so. It leaves me to wonder if County officials actually respect Town input on issues such as these, and helps me to better understand why many other Towns are !£ if? K HJ [? ?^JHJ g ^ lc; i! ^ & |!i] Ill jAiN 1 ^OZ6 1'^ ^Co,_ZoninQDep!.commencing the process of disassociating themselves from your platmmg'ahTzorting' regulations. Finally, I encourage you to not attempt to create or administer public policy based solely on who complains the most stridently. A cross-check of County property records and Town elector records reveals that, of all the parties in October 2024 who communicated with you in opposition to this CUP, only two actually live full-time and/or are electors in the Town of Bell. I was appointed to the Plan Commission during the multi-year process it undertook to research, develop, and implement a Town short-term rental ordinance, and during that process we were subjected to a lot of criticism from non- or seasonal-resident property owners with pecuniary or otherwise wholly personal interests in this marketplace, attempting to pressure the Town to bend to their will. Fortunately, local governments such as ours are, and should be, principally responsive to those who actually live and vote here. I now find myself in the uncomfortably ironic position of reminding the majority of the commenters in this issue that, as in the case ofSTR regulation, land ownership and the simple act of paying property taxes does not an engaged citizen make, and "working the refs" in the absence of actual evidence or sincere engagement with Town government to justify or advance a selfishly-preferred policy outcome does not a good neighbor make. In counterpoint, Lacey Lueth is a full-time resident with active and continued professional and civic investment in my Town and the neighboring one, including the provision of housing for her own workforce, and is willing to live literally adjacent to one of the short-term rental properties she owns here. Although we may disagree on the relative value of the short-term rental marketplace to the fabric of our community - and I am decidedly no fan of this marketplace -1 reiterate that the CUP before you has no material impact on this issue. However, I also believe that on-site oversight of such properties by their owners is perhaps the best-case scenario for maximizing their responsive and responsible operation in the interest of neighborhood harmony. Would Lueth's potential neighbors on Blueberry Lane actually prefer STR ownership and management in absentia? D) I G [? I j JAN '1 j r^ 8 ^ayfield Co. Zoning Dept Now that you have a more robust record of the actual facts on this issue and a more appropriate context from which to consider them, I hope that you can see the wisdom of modifying your position. Respectfully Submitted, ^^ John Anderson 87575 County Highway C Cornucopia, WI 54827 (608) 395-4389 shelterinplace@protonmail.com ec: Bayfield County Zoning Administrator Ruth Hulstrom Ruth Hulstrom From: Ruth Hulstrom Sent: Monday, January 27, 2025 9:31 AM To: Robert Schierman; lllueth@yahoo.com Cc: tobclerk@cornywi.org Subject: L Lueth Holding Company, Inc decision letter and affidavit Attachments: L Lueth CUP decision letter and affidavit.pdf Rob and Lacey, Please see the attached decision letter and affidavit related to your conditional use permit request for a second residence located on Tax ID 37575. A hard copy will be placed in the mail today. We will need a new $30.00 check payable to "Bayfielct County Register of Deeds" so I can record the affidavit. We will also need a new check or debit/credit card payment to process the land use permit associated with the conditional use permit once the conditions of this permit that have been met. Please provide a copy of the deed once the restriction outlined in the approval have been completed. Let me know if you have any questions. Best regards, Ruth Hulstrom, AICP | Director Planning and Zoning Department 117 E 5th Street, PO Box 58 Washburn, WI 54891 Phone: 715-373-3514 Fax: 715-373-0114 Email: ruth.hulstrom(a),bavfieldcountv.wi.eov J^-V FIELD 'I'iove .?";•;.:•. _;.3tKPA^FIELD PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT 117 East Fifth Street PO Box 58 Washbum, Wl 54891 (715) 373-6138 Fax: (715)373-0114 E-mail:zonincf(fDbavfieldcountv.wi.ciov Web Site: www.bayfieldcountv.wi.gov January 27,2025 ^»>- ^L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY, INC 912 SOUTH STATE STREET NEW ULM,MN 56037 RE: Conditional Use Application (Ordinance: Section 13-1-33-Multiple Structures) request a conditional use permit (in the shoreland, w/wetlands present) to place a second residence on the property. Property is an R-1 zoning district; a 2.927-acre parcel (Tax ID# 37575), described as 2 parcels in Gov't Lot 2 & 3 in Doc #2022R-596362, in Section 33, Township 51 North, Range 6 West, Town of Bell, Bayfield County, Wl. To Whom It May Concern: As you know, the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee conducted a public hearing / meeting on January 16, 2025, where Daryl Fuchihara, attorney, informed the Committee of your application for the above mentioned. After discussion and review, the Planning and Zoning Committee approved your request with conditions based on the town board recommendation and the applicant's offer to place a deed on the property which would limit the property to one short-term rental which is the existing residence for 25 years. The approval includes the following: • Ordinance: Section 13-1-33-Multiple Structures • Granted: place a second residence on the property with the following conditions: 1. A Quit Claim Deed for Tax ID parcel 37575 with restrictions in favor of Bayfield County can be signed and recorded with the Bayfield County Register of Deeds before the Conditional Use Permit is issued. The quit claim deed restrictions are: 1) only two residences may be built on the property, and only the existing residence may be used as a short-term rental unit. This restriction shall remain in effect until the earlier of December 6, 2049 or Approval from Bayfield County to lift the restriction, which approval may be sought at any time by L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. or its successors in title. Congratulations on obtaining this approval. Be advised, any aggrieved party has the right to appeal this decision to the Board of Adjustment within thirty (30) days. Any person aggrieved by a decision of the Planning and Zoning Director and/or Planning and Zoning Committee may request a public hearing before the Board of Adjustment. The appeal notice shall be filed with the Planning and Zoning Director within thirty (30) days after written notice of the order or decision appealed from was sent by first class mail to the aggrieved party. Enclosed is a copy of the affidavit prepared by this Dept. setting forth the terms and conditions of your permit. Your $30 check and the original affidavit will be taken to the Reg. of Deeds Office Drafted by: Bayfield Co Planning and Zoning Dept (reh-1/2/72025-5:59am) k:zc/letters/2025/1jan/llueth Proofed by: «bove exc.ec.tritK.in;.I^VFIELD PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT 117 East Fifth Street PO Box 58 Washburn, Wl 54891 (715) 373-6138 Fax: (715)373-0114 E-mail:zoninci<S>bayfieldcountv. wi.gov Web Site: www.bayfieldcountv.wi.qov for recording. After recordation, your permit card will be mailed to you provided all requirements have been met and/or submitted. Please note receiving approval from the Planning and Zoning Committee at the meeting does not authorize the beginning of construction or land use, if required you must first obtain individual land use application(s) / permit(s) from the Planning and Zoning Department. Terms and conditions of your permit shall be binding upon, and inure to the benefit of, all current and future owners of such property. Also, this permit entitles you to the work specifically described in the application and plans, and as limited by any conditions of this permit. No changes in the project or plans may be made without prior approval of the^Bayfield County Zoning Committee. The issuance of this permit does not relieve you of your responsibility to obtain a permit or approval required by your township, State ofWI, or federal authority (i.e., US Army Corps of Engineers). Be advised your Conditional Use permit shall automatically terminate 24 months from its date of issuance if the authorized building activity, land alteration or use has not begun within such time. If your Conditional Use is discontinued for 36 consecutive months, the permit authorizing it shall automatically terminate, and any future use of the buitding(s) or property to which the permit pertained shall conform to Ordinance. You are responsible for complying with state and federal laws concerning construction near or on wetlands, lakes, and streams Thank you for your cooperation and please let our office know if you have any questions or comments. Sincerely, Ruth Hulstrom, Director Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Department enc: copy of affidavit ec: MaryBeth Tillmans, Town Clerk, P.O. Box 280, Cornucopia, Wl 54827 Robert Schierman, Authorized Agent, PO Box 122, Herbster, Wl 54844 David Westphal, 1351 Heather Ct, Chanhassen, MN 55317 Office File Drafted by: Bayfield Co Planning and Zoning Dept (reh-1/2/72025-5:59am) k:zc/letters/2025/1jan/llueth Proofed by: AFFIDAVIT On January 16, 2025, the owner(s) were granted by the Bayfield County Planning and Zoning Committee a: Conditional Use 13-1-41 Ordinance 13-1-33 Multiple Structures on a Parcel Requested A conditional use permit to place a second residence on the property OOCUMENT NUMBER2025R-606522 DANIEL- J.HEFF-NER REGISTER OF DEEDS BAYHELD COUNTY, Wl RECORDED02,10/2025 AT 1 1 :5 1 AM RECORDING FEE: $30.00 PAGES: 2 Return to: Bayfield County Zoning Property Owner: L Lueth Holding Company, Inc Property Description: See attached Exhibit A This use of the property is subject to the following terms and conditions: • Ordinance: Section 13-1-33-Multiple Structures • Granted: place a second residence on the property with the following conditions: 1. A Quit Claim Deed for Tax ID parcel 37575 with restrictions in favor of Bayfield County can be signed and recorded with the Bayfield County Register of Deeds before the Conditional Use Permit is issued. The quit claim deed restrictions are: 1) only two residences may be built on the property, and only the existing residence may be used as a short-term rental unit. This restriction shall remain in effect until the earlier of December 6, 2049 or Approval from Bayfield County to lift the restriction, which approval may be sought at any time by L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. or its successors in title. The purpose of this affidavit is to make the foregoing a matter of public record in the office of the Bayfield County Register of Deeds, per Bavfield County Planninci & Zoning Ordinance, Tjtle 13, Chaoter 1, Article C, Section 13-1-41: "If a conditional use permit is approved with conditions, an appropriate record shall be made of the land use and structures permitted, and prior to the issuance of the permit the Zoning Department shall record with the Bayfield County Register of Deeds an affidavit prepared by the Zoning Department setting forth the terms and conditions of the permit and a legal description of the property to which they pertain. The recording fee shall be paid by the applicant. The terms and conditions of the permit shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit of all current and future owners of the property to which it pertains un/ess otherwise expressly provided by the permit, or unless the permit terminates under subsection (d) of this section." Also, this permit entitles you to the work specifically described in the application and plans, and as limited by any conditions of this permit. No changes in the project or plans may be made without prior approval of the Bayfield County Zoning Committee. The issuance of this permit does not relieve you of your responsibility to obtain a permit or approval required by your township, State of Wl, or federal authority (i.e., US Army Corps of Engineers). Be advised your conditional use permit shall automatically terminate 24 months from its date of issuance if the authorized building activity, land alteration or use has not begun within such time. If your conditional use is discontinued for 36 consecutive months, the permit authorizing it shall automatically terminate, and any future use of the building(s) or property to which the permit pertained shall conform to Ordinance. Bayfield County Planning & Zoning Dept. Governmental Official Printed Name and Title: Ruth E Hulstrom, Director Signature of Governmental Official:^ ^ <1^^ On thisis 2'rl+" day of~^u^^ .2025 This instrument was signed before me in the State of Wisconsin, County of BayfieldAon this , 2025day of \AA>iftni laae '"Wfn!HQI)' Notary Public-' ~J ' ' J My commission expires on: 03\\OC> \C. Receiving approval from the Planning and Zoning Committee at the meeting does not authorize the beginning of construction or land use; you must first obtain land use application/Dermit card(s) from the Zoning Department. Drafted by: Bayfield Co Planning & Zoning Dept/ (reh-1/27/2025) k/affidavit/2025/ljan/llueth Proofed by: EXHIBIT "A' Parcel 1: A parcel of land located in Government Lot Two (2), Section Thirty-three (33), Township Fifly-one (51) North, Range Six (6) West, Town of Bell, Bayfield County, Wisconsin, more particularly described as follows: Starting at the East ',4 corner of Section 33; (hence North 1°09' West, along the line between Sections 33 and 34, 176.4 feet; thence South 84°08' West 326.1 feet; thence South 87 °55' West 808.7 feet; thence North 87°35' West 601,2 feet; thence North 83 °34' West 457 feet; thence North 79°34' West 248.39 feet to an iron pipe which is the Point of Beginning. Thence North 1°09' West 200 feet to an iron pipe. Thence North 1 °09' West 450 feet to the shore of Lake Superior, Thence Northwesterly along said shore 102.07 feet; thence South 1 °09' East 380 feet to an iron pipe. Thence South 1°09' East 257 feet to an iron pipe. Thence South 79 °34' East 102.07 feet to the Point of Beginning, Being Lot 22 on the unofficial and unrecorded Plat made by Thomas W. Nelson, Registered Surveyor ofAshland, Wisconsin, under date of July 15, 1957 and entitled Siskiwitt Bay Subdivision. Parcel 2; A parcel of land located in Govenunent Lots Two (2) and Three (3), Section Thirty-three (33), Township Fifiy-one (51) North, Range Six (6) West, Town of Bell, Bayfield County, Wisconsin, more particularly described as follows: Starting at the East ',4 corner of said Section 33; thence North 1°09' West, along the line between Sections 33 and 34, 176.4 feet; thence South 84°08' West 326.1 feet; thence South 87°55 West 808.7 feet; thence North 87 °35' Wesl 601.2 feet; thence North 83 °34' West 457 feet; thence North 79°34' West 350,46 feet to an iron pipe which is the Point of Beginning. Thence North 1°09' West 257 feet to an iron pipe. Thence North 1 °09' West 380 feet to the shore of Lake Superior. Thence Northwesterly along said shore 102.07 feet; thence South 1 °09' East 370 feet to an iron pipe. Tlwnce South 1°09' East 256 feet to an iron pipe. Thence South 79 °34' East 102.07 feet to the Point of Beginning. Being Lot 23 on the unofficial and unrecorded Plat made by Thomas W, Nelson, Registered Surveyor ofAshland, Wisconsin, under date of July 15, 1957 and entitled Siskiwitt Bay Subdivision. Document Number THIS DEED, made between State Bar of Wisconsin Form 3-2003 QUIT CLAIM DEED Document Name L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. ("Grantor," whether one or more), and L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. ("Grantee," whether one or more). Grantor quit claims to Grantee rents, profits, fixtures and County, State of Wisconsin addendum): See the annexed Exhibit A. tee the following described real estate, together with the 'ther appurtenant interests, in Bayfield ("Property") (if more space is needed, please attach DOCUMENT NUMBER2025R-606545 OANIEL J. HEFFNER REGISTER OF DEEDS BAYFIELD COUNTS. Wl RECORDED 02, 1 2/2025 AT 8:00 AM RECORDING FEE: $30.00 TF EXEMPT #: 3 PAGES: 2 Recording Area Name and Return Address L Lueth !!o!ciing Company. ;,ic. 912 South State Street New Ulm, MN 56073 iDl iUl IE rr ^ I'e Z025 '<y[i;:;id ' .1. ?i;i'iiii(4 i.^C'1 04-010-2-51-06-33-1 05-002-82000 Parcel Identification Number (PIN) This is not (is) (is not) homestead property. Dated * * AUTHENTICATION Signature(s) authenticated on * .(SEAL) _(SEAL) 1L. Lj^eth Holding (^pmpanf^Inc. *Lace^Luethf Chief Executive Officer AC/t eth/Chi. Zo£^ TITLE: MEMBER STATE BAR OF WISCONSIN (If not, authorized by Wis. Stat. § 706.06) THIS INSTRUMENT DRAFTED BY: Daryl T. Fuchihara (#1118530) Johnson, Killen & Seller, PA., Duluth, MN ACKNOWLEDGMENT STATE OF WISCONSIN 8a.^lyJ-/^ )ss.COUNTY ) .(SEAL) .(SEAL) Personally came before me on JF&.^L. l)j 9-0 S^S' the above-named^gfiey L.ue-4'^'^Y"^to me known to be the person(s) who ex^Ck^A.?the-fefe^t^ instrument and acknowledged the same. ^'(-y.-"' M"n&=C3-w •SEA CO ..•'.??.-^'Notary Public, State of Wisconsin "'^'•. My Commission (is permanent) (expires: '^7^3^-Q?^ .••'.! -, f~ ^ "V^ /s^ *'*"*•'* a^\ "^Ss (Signatures may be authenticated or acknowledged. Both are not necessary.) //T,. ^Yi\\x NOTE: THIS IS A STANDARD FORM. ANY MODIFICATIONS TO THIS FORM SHOULD BE CLEARLY IDEN'Tfflttt' QUIT CLAIM DEED * Type name below signatures. © 2003 STATE BAR OF WISCONSIN FORM N0.3-2003 !i "! EXHIBIT "A" Parcel I: A parcel of land located in Government Lol Two (2), Section Thirty-thrcc (33), Township Fifty-one (51) North, Range Six (6) West, Town of Bell, Bayfield County, Wisconsin, more particularly described as follows; Starting at the East ,4 corner ofSeclion 33; thence North 1°09' West, along the line between Sections 33 and 34, 176.4 feel; thence South 84°08' West 326.1 feet; thence South 87 °55' West 808,7 feet; (hence North 87°35' West 601.2 feet; thence North 83 °34' West 457 feet; thence North 79°34' West 248.39 feet to an iron pipe which is the Point of Beginning. Thence North 1°09' West 200 feet to an iron pipe. Thence North 1 °09' West 450 feet to the shore of Lake Superior. Thence Northwesterly along said shore 102.07 feet; thence South 1 °09' East 380 feet to an iron pipe. Thence South 1°09' East 257 feet to an iron pipe. Thence South 79 °34' East 102.07 feel to the Point of Beginning. Being Lot 22 on the unofficial and unrccorded Plat made by Thomas W. Nelson, Registered Surveyor ofAshland, Wisconsin, under date of July 15, 1957 and entitled Siskiwitt Bay Subdivision. Parcel 2; A parcel of land located in Govenunent Lots Two (2) and Three (3), Section Thirty-three (33), Township Fifty-one (51) North, Range Six (6) West, Town of Bell, Bayfidd County, Wisconsin, more particularly described as follows: Starting at the East 'A corner of said Section 33; thence North 1°09' West, along the line between Sections 33 and 34, 176.4 feet; thence South 84°08' West 326.1 feet; thence South 87°55 West 808,7 feel; thence North 87 °35' West 601.2 feet; thence North 83 °34' West 457 feet; thence North 79°34' West 350,46 feet to an iron pipe which is the Point of Beginning. Thence North 1°09' West 257 feet to an iron pipe. Thence North 1 °09' West 380 feet to the shore of Lake Superior. Thence Northwesterly along said shore 102,07 feet; (hence South 1 °09' East 370 feet to an iron pipe. Thpnce South .1°09' East 256 feet to an iron pipe. Thence South 79 °34' East 102.07 feet to the Point of Beginning. Being Lot 23 on the unofficial and um'ecorded Plat made by Thomas W, Nelson, Registered Surveyor of'Ashland, Wisconsin, under date of July 15, 1957 and entitled Siskiwitt Bay Subdivisinn Subject to the following restriction in favor ofBayfield County: Only two residences may be built on the property, and only the existing residence may be used as a short term rental unit. This restriction shall remain in effect until the earlier of: fl) December 6, 2049; or (2) Approval from Bayfield County to lift this restriction, which approval may be sought at any time by L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. or its successors in title. Town, City, Village, State or Federal Permits May Also Be Required LAND USE -SANITARY- SIGN - SPECIAL - CONDITIONAL - X (ZC Mtg: January 16,2025) (Tn of Bell - January 14,2025)BOA - BAYFIELD COUNTY PERMIT WEATHERIZE AND POST THIS PERMIT ON THE PREMISES DURING CONSTRUCTION No. 25-0074 Tax ID: 37575 Issued To: L LUETH HOLDING COMPANY INC Location: S33 - T51 N - R06W Town of Bell Legal Description:2 PAR IN GOVT LOTS 2 & 3 DESC IN DOC 2025R-606545 For: Multiple Structures 13-1-33 - place a second residence on the property Condition(s): 1. A Quit Claim Deed for Tax ID parcel 37575 with restrictions in favor of Bayfield County can be signed and recorded with the Bayfield County Register of Deeds before the Conditional Use Permit is issued. The quit claimdeed restrictions are: 1) only two residences may be built on the property, and only the existing residence maybe used as a short-term rental unit. This restriction shall remain in effect until the earlier of December 6, 2049 or Approval from Bayfield County to lift the restriction, which approval may be sought at any time by L Lueth Holding Company, Inc. or its successors in title. NOTE: This permit expires two years from date of issuance if the authorized construction work or land use has not begun. Changes in plans or specifications shall not be made without obtaining approval. This permit may be void or revoked if any of the application information is found to have been misrepresented, erroneous, or incomplete. Ruth Hulstrom Authorized Issuing Official March 05, 2025 This permit may be void or revoked if any performance conditions are not completed or if any prohibitory conditions are violated. Date